3 ms·
We're talking about sexual objectification of women specifically, not some kind of generic "objectification". So I don't think most of what you're saying is rea
by stcredzero 10y ago
We're talking about sexual objectification of women specifically, not some kind of generic "objectification". So I don't think most of what you're saying is really relevant to the topic
Generic objectification is the underlying mechanism, and the specific referent in my comments. My whole point is that the underlying mechanism is morally neutral. (Objectification as formulated by feminist scholars is largely pseudoscience, and requires the addition of an arbitrary gender direction to make ideological sense.)
regard the sexual objectification of women as inevitable
Did you honestly think I was taking the position that the sexual objectification of women is inevitable? You are the one primarily using the words "sexual" and "inevitable." Please provide a quote where I say something to this effect. It would seem you are engaging in a tactic of tacking on adjectives to what another is saying. (Nice strawman fallacy.) This analogy works well: Objectification is certainly avoidable, in much the same way that hitting a pedestrian is. Willfully objectifying someone is harmful and morally objectionable in much the same way that purposely hitting a pedestrian is. In much the same way, objectification can happen incidentally in contexts that are badly engineered. The correct approach is to change the environment in ways that minimize the possibility of incidents. Likewise, automatically ascribing a moral position in such cases makes as little sense as automatically assuming a moral stance on the part of someone in an auto accident. More information is needed beyond the mere incident to be able to say anything about morality. (Thought about in this way, the various formulations of avoidance of certain topics in the workplace makes eminent sense.)
The addition of a the moral stance seems particularly useful in terms of the use of such accusations as a power grab. The purpose is to enable vilification of people based on subjective standards. Really, the equivalent of "You're either for us or against us" should raise hackles in any humanist and liberal worthy of the name. It was unconvincing to me when George W. Bush used it as a silencing tactic to his opponents, and it hasn't developed any more substance since.
- foldr 10y agoI can’t really see any links between sexual objectification and the kind of generic “objectification” that you’re talking about. In other words, you’d need to explain how we can sensibly regard the former as a subcase of a latter. As I mentioned earlier, it simply makes no sense to link the sexual objectification of women to generic considerations of information processing. I certainly do take a moral stance on sexual objectification — why not? It is of course true that merely condemning people will not necessarily cause behaviors to change, but you could use the same argument to show that we shouldn’t take a moral stance against anything. That doesn’t show that we shouldn’t condemn bad things, only that we need to do more than just condemn them. And yes, you certainly seemed to be suggesting that the sexual objectification of women was inevitable, since you linked it to “objectification” in your generic sense, and argued that objectification in this sense is an inevitable result of human limitations on information processing.
- stcredzero 10y agoI can’t really see any links between sexual objectification and the kind of generic “objectification” that you’re talking about. Feminist pseudoscience has basically filled the searches. That doesn’t show that we shouldn’t condemn bad things, only that we need to do more than just condemn them. Please read the whole thread again. This is pretty much my position. And yes, you certainly seemed to be suggesting that the sexual objectification of women was inevitable, since you linked it to “objectification” in your generic sense, and argued that objectification in this sense is an inevitable result of human limitations on information processing. Be careful. Your biases are showing. Blind spots in a car are inevitable. Collisions because of blind spots aren't inevitable, especially when there is some caution, good design, and prudent driving involved. Just because a certain kind of error exists, doesn't mean that a certain specific subset of those errors are inevitable. That's another kind of fallacy.
- foldr 10y agoIf you don't think that the sexual objectification of women is inevitable, and if you are opposed to it, then it seems to me that we are in agreement. >Feminist pseudoscience has basically filled the searches. I don't understand what you mean by this. I was asking you to explain the link which you appeared to be making between sexual objectification and limits on information processing capacity.