3 ms·
That wasn't ranting, it was cogent and well-structured and made good points. If you disagree with those points, say so, but don't diminish it by calling it a ra
by sanderjd 10y ago
That wasn't ranting, it was cogent and well-structured and made good points. If you disagree with those points, say so, but don't diminish it by calling it a rant.
I think those points are extremely relevant for an article targeted at people trying to get involved in open source. The for-pay vs. free-time divide is a fundamental problem with using open source work as an "in" to the industry, and despite being scoff-worthy to some people, it's helpful for people coming into this with fresh eyes (ie. the target audience of the article) to be given some context.
- brighteyes 10y agoIt's that the points mentioned are the same old familiar points, and the arguments against them are also the same old familiar ones. For example, the article says "men have more privilege than women", based on the criteria provided, which are > 1. Who don’t have families to take care of (kids, parents, whatever) > 2. who have a good, steady income (i.e. not learning while, say, balancing two part-time jobs) > 3. who live close to work (minimizing a commute) And yes, women are more likely to have people to take care of. However, there are also reasons to say women are more privileged than men in this context. For example, 4. Are in college, as a lot of open source contributors are college students. Women are a lot more likely to get into college than men. 5. Are not in jail or prison. Women are far less likely to be in those situations. In other words, it is horribly simplistic to say "men have more privilege than women" in this context. It's just lazy regurgitating of the familiar talking points. It's not helpful. Yes, it's worth mentioning some people have an easier way into open source. But no, it's a bad idea to turn this into an oversimplified and false matter of "men > women".
- sanderjd 10y agoFirstly, I was responding to the idea that this topic is irrelevant or orthogonal to the rest of the article - you don't seem to disagree with that, but rather disagree with the specific points that were made. Secondly, "the same old familiar points" assumes everyone has the same familiarity with the topic that you do, which of course isn't true in general, and the target audience of the article is actively people who are unlikely to have come across this.
- xigency 10y agoIt sounds like the author is being categorically dismissive of a group of people that I can't even match. Is he against people with salaries developing software? Is he against people who aren't paid from writing software? Should people who aren't paid be paid and those employed be fired? Should whites pursue primarily agrarian careers so that non-whites can pick up technology-minded hobbies in order to transition to lucrative careers? The start and end point of his discussion in that paragraph form a very narrow loop which defies logic. -- On privilege: I completely disagree with the necessity of being engaged in a community to be a compiler developer or to learn any CS domain. But stating that free time is a privilege is a bit absurd. You could be a 23-hour a day gardener and still write a compiler. It's not as if there's a time limit. Dividing by gender is ridiculous---the first computer programmer was a woman. All that it takes to become a compiler enthusiast is the understanding of languages and computers. Having a pencil and paper is a plus. Alan Turing was gay but it didn't prevent him from inventing a form of universal computer. People should be celebrated for their differences, not admonished for not having enough outlying characteristics. Remember, the first programmers had neither computers nor compilers, and the first compiler writers had punch cards, so who exactly is privileged?
- dajomu 10y agoHe's suggesting that for a lot of people getting involved in open source it is a means to an end. Whether that is getting a job in a new field, increasing exposure or experience, etc... Usually that end is something monetary or status related. What he is then saying is that some parts of the population are more privileged than others when it comes to the free time and resources needed to achieve that. It's not necessarily just that they have the resources now, but that they may have had them in the past too (upbringing, access to education, encouragement, etc). So the discussion of privilege shouldn't necessarily be seen as a negative force trying to tear down white men, but should inform our decision making when we take other people's hardships into account. As a white male myself I understand that I have had better opportunities than a large part of the population. I'd rather take that into account and try to improve the fairness in society, than to look away from it. What to actually do about it is another matter... But acknowledging that it's a problem is the first step.