2 ms·
The problems with richer type systems (they're not "better", just more expressive, just as Dart's unsound, covariant type system is not better or or worse, just
by pron 10y ago
The problems with richer type systems (they're not "better", just more expressive, just as Dart's unsound, covariant type system is not better or or worse, just different) has nothing to do with them being Turing complete or not. And the "FUD" is nothing more than the very real reality that many teams find those language far too clever for their taste. I like Java, but others may not; you like Scala, but others may not. That's perfectly fine and normal, and doesn't make it FUD. As long as no one has good empirical evidence supporting their claims of their preferred language's superiority, these discussions are all about personal preference anyway.
Being Turing complete or not is an intrinsic quality of the type system which has not been shown to have any effect whatsoever on the effectiveness of a language. Similarly, being more or less expressive, being sound or not, supporting subtyping or not, are intrinsic qualities that have not been shown to have either a positive or a negative effect. Those are all true properties -- like Coke cans being red -- but they cannot be assigned good/bad judgment other than in people's personal preferences -- until, that is, someone actually starts collecting data.
- lmm 10y agoWe don't yet have a lot of solid empirical evidence, sure - mostly because we don't have a good measure of productivity. But the fact that we can't measure it well doesn't mean it doesn't exist. There is a fact of the matter to be found, it's more than just personal preference. > And the "FUD" is nothing more than the very real reality that many teams find those language far too clever for their taste. I've heard people literally say "we shouldn't use Scala because its type system is Turing complete" (in an organization that was already using Java). I call that FUD.
- pron 10y ago> But the fact that we can't measure it well doesn't mean it doesn't exist. There is a fact of the matter to be found, it's more than just personal preference. I agree, but we still don't know which side has the advantage and how big the effect is. I believe that if we somehow control for all other factors, the effect of linguistic features is very small, but that "simpler" languages like Java/Kotlin would have the (small) advantage over "complex" ones like Scala. I can support this from personal experience (and also for theoretical reasons), but I can't prove that. You likely have a different experience (and other theoretical justifications), but can't prove your conjecture, either. > I call that FUD. I call that silly. It's just as silly as using intrinsic features as a positive. We shouldn't use Scala for a hundred reasons, none of them having to do anything with the formal language acceptable by its type system. ;)