4 ms·
correlation is not causation. Could another likely argument be that poverty creates more stress on a relationship and it's the other way around? poverty causes
by sharemywin 10y ago
correlation is not causation. Could another likely argument be that poverty creates more stress on a relationship and it's the other way around? poverty causes relationship problems?
Also, minimum wage doesn't cover child care, so what's the point in having one partner working when it doesn't make economic sense?
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThat's a possible argument but it seems unlikely. If true, then a poor nation like India should have low marriage rates while a super rich one like the US should have high marriage rates. By Indian standards, everyone (including our very poor) is quite wealthy, so why do Indians do such a good job at getting and staying married while we don't? Compare also marriage rates and wealth over time - in the 50's marriage was a lot more common, yet by modern standards most people were poor.
- moron4hire 10y agoI doubt one would ever be able to account for all the variables when comparing disparate cultures to try to determine causality on one issue.
- sharemywin 10y agotrading places on a mass scale. Enter into a lotto were you could win all kinds of money or you could lose all your wealth.
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoTwo related points: - 'Poverty' is (mostly) relative; as you point out, almost all of the even the poorest in the US are rich in comparison to the poor in other countries; and the poorest in the world today are relatively rich compared to the poor (and even not-poor) in the past. - It is illegal, inconvenient, and low-status to live or try to live, in the US, as the poor in India, or other poorer countries, do; e.g. authorities will evict tenants living in illegal housing (and prosecute their landlords), almost no one brings their small children to work with them, building/labor/etc. standards are much more stringent legally (and culturally).
- yummyfajitas 10y agoIt is illegal, inconvenient, and low-status to live or try to live, in the US, as the poor in India, or other poorer countries, do; e.g. authorities will evict tenants living in illegal housing (and prosecute their landlords), almost no one brings their small children to work with them, building/labor/etc. standards are much more stringent legally (and culturally). Sure - the net result of this is that American poor people live in larger and much higher quality homes. Wouldn't that reduce stress? Relative poverty is an odd explanation for a change over time - if you plot a graph of % of population in the bottom 10%, you'll discover it never changes. So how can you use this to explain a change over time? I suppose one could take a "red pill" style explanation - female hypergamy combined with low perceived status can cause relationship stress. In the past, poor black people were segregated from everyone else. So a poor black man who has a badly paid job and goes to church regularly might be high status within his community. Thus, his wife will perceive him as high status and will not make trouble within the relationship. Racial and economic integration has then reduced his perceived status, and she causes trouble. The only solution to this I could see is status based segregation - allow everyone to be high status within a narrow community. I don't much like this solution, nor do I see a useful way to force the culture to do this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoSure - the net result of this is that American poor people live in larger and much higher quality homes. Wouldn't that reduce stress? Maybe; except some, small but significant, number of poor people can't even afford homes (at least at some point and for varying lengths of time). And that definitely does not reduce stress (for most of these people). But (most) people care more that their house is small-er or worse – than their neighbor's house – than that their house is 'objectively' small or bad. [Which it probably isn't, given that people seem to be mostly happy elsewhere in the world, in space and time, living in much smaller and crappier housing.] By 'relative' poverty I was referring to exactly what you mention, e.g. being in "the bottom 10%". It doesn't matter that the bottom 10% today in the U.S. are in the top < 5% (?) worldwide or the top 1% over a long enough time-span. Poverty sucks (mostly) because it is having less than others. Note that this is an empirical (and uncertain) claim based on my understanding (and memory) of what I've read about the relative research. The only solution to this I could see is status based segregation - allow everyone to be high status within a narrow community. This is a real phenomenon and it's already happening and it may in fact be an existing and positive force for good in terms of increasing human happiness. People, generally, care a LOT about their (relative) status in their community/communities.
- sharemywin 10y agoThe number one argument in marriages are money.
- panglott 10y agoCross-national comparison between India and the US introduces a whole bunch of unrelated variables.