5 ms·
>> but the quality of documentation is abysmal compared to what we used to have It is, however, more accessible and easily searchable. And also basically free.
by bluedino 10y ago
>> but the quality of documentation is abysmal compared to what we used to have
It is, however, more accessible and easily searchable. And also basically free. Many programmers have never bought or own a book related to programming - they learned from all online sources.
>> layers in between hardware and your code. It is annoying.
But it's so much more convenient. In the old days you had to learn all about your graphics card, your printer, your sound card, you'd need a certain driver for your modem or network card... Now everything is abstracted and easy to use.
- mathgeek 10y ago> Many programmers have never bought or own a book related to programming - they learned from all online sources. I wonder what the effect of this has been on overall quality of code for this subset. I know that while I've learned more from online sources than books (whether physical or electronic), the lessons I have learned from books are overall above the average quality of all my sources.
- nilved 10y agoI highly doubt there is any difference, since the only difference is the medium. If a book is published online, it's still a book.
- andrew3726 10y agoI think you're missing the point. It's not about electronic book vs physical book (If I misunterstood you, sorry and dismiss this post). It's more about the sources on the internet, I don't know many people who read complete books on the computer but rather just read relevant sections somewhere online. While this isn't bad per se, you often miss important details due to different sources (and therefore different views/reader assumptions, ...).
- sklogic 10y agoThey tend to be very different kinds of books. A comprehensive, deep printed textbook vs. what is essentially nothing more than a tutorial or a collection of practical recipes.
- nilved 10y agoDoes reading _Learn You a Haskell_ online make it any less of a book? My point is that "online sources" is a superset of "books", making them incomparable.
- Jtsummers 10y agoNo. However a lot of the things I, anecdata, find when I do a google search aren't books, but blogs and random tutorials and stackoverflow. Books, due to their published nature, tend to have a greater, more thorough, effort put into them. They are generally well laid out, usually well edited, and because people spent money on them the good ones tended to stay in the market and the bad ones tended to drop out. There's no fundamental difference (except for me, I do much better at recalling things I read from physical books than ebooks), in the source of online versus offline. But it's hard to ignore the difference in quality that tends to happen. What would be nice, and this is probably done somewhere, would be a reliable aggregator of good online documentation (whether it's an ebook version of a published text or not). Somewhere we can vet and see vetted quality sources of tutorials, manuals, etc.
- sklogic 10y agoThis is among very few exceptions. Most of the books are still proper books (no matter if they're also available as e-books). Most of the stuff people use for learning online is far below a book quality.
- mathgeek 10y ago> If a book is published online, it's still a book. reply Not really arguing the medium of actual books (which is why I specified in my previous post). More a comparison between topic-specific books and blog posts / StackOverflow.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI can tell you that the two languages I can confidently say I know well - C++ and Common Lisp - are the ones I learned from books. The rest I learned from various on-line tutorials, articles, references and sometimes from half-reading a book - and while I can code with them, I can feel my coding in them is mediocre. Hell, I feel that the generic-coding skills I have I owe mostly to books (and practice). You can't beat a book in terms of depth and undestanding. (And don't get me started on videotutorials. This is probably the least cost-effective educational medium ever invented.)
- sklogic 10y ago> more accessible and easily searchable Have not seen more easily searchable documentation than the DEC HELP system. > Many programmers have never bought or own a book related to programming And it's very sad. > - they learned from all online sources. Did they really learn anything? Without the books? Or they are simply trained to repeat few simple tricks over and over again? > But it's so much more convenient. I said needless layers. They're annoyance, not convenience. > In the old days you had to learn all about your graphics card We had OpenGL in the old days too. Pretty much straight from the beginning of the GPUs. > your printer, We had hardware PostScript back then. No drivers required. > Now everything is abstracted and easy to use There are piles of layers well above the device drivers now. With 90% of them being totally unnecessary.
- ryandrake 10y agoIf you think those layers are unnecessary, then don't use them. Create your application using assembly and syscalls. Don't forget though, version 1 needs to be done in 3 weeks...
- sklogic 10y agoGood luck bypassing the unnecessary layers if your code have to run in a browser. Which is exactly an example of such an unnecessary layer (dozens of layers, actually). And JVM is not any better.
- pjc50 10y agoNo, the browser is a very necessary layer; it provides very effective security isolation between the internet and the windowing system. The mainframe days assumed that software was installed by the privileged admin and that users were the threat. It's now the other way round: most computers have only one user, but need to run all sorts of software that needs to be kept isolated from the system and each other.
- sklogic 10y ago