3 ms·
Ad hominem is not a synonym for insult. It is used exclusively for when someone attacks the speaker, and not the speaker's arguments. In this case, there were n
by scott_s 17y ago
Ad hominem is not a synonym for insult. It is used exclusively for when someone attacks the speaker, and not the speaker's arguments. In this case, there were no arguments. The question was "Who is X?" Someone answered who X is. That answer was harsh, but also consistent with everything that I have seen.
I agree its civility is borderline. But it's not an ad hominem attack because no argument was being made.