5 ms·
> He could not have done anything at all to them if the cases were not meritorious. That's not true at all. One jury verdict (before appeals have been heard) p
by wpietri 10y ago
> He could not have done anything at all to them if the cases were not meritorious.
That's not true at all. One jury verdict (before appeals have been heard) plus a bunch of nascent suits is no proof of eventual merit. It could be that every single one of those cases eventually ends up getting dismissed, or being awarded negligible verdicts. But because Gawker may not be able to afford a full defense, they could well be out of business.
Long-time financial journalist Felix Salmon points out the issues here:
https://twitter.com/felixsalmon/status/735662530903826437 https://twitter.com/felixsalmon/status/735662530903826437
You also write like somebody who has never been on the receiving end of a lawsuit. They are a painful multi-year distraction and expense even if you win. My mom was on the receiving end of a lawsuit after a business deal gone bad. Eventually she won on all counts, and after he had finished reading his verdict, the judge gave both the plaintiff and the plaintiff's lawyer a royal dressing down for wasting the court's time. But the stress was incredible for the whole family, and we still had to pay the defense bills. It was not cheap.
And in Gawker's case, defending themselves against $10m worth of lawyering could well take them at least $10m no matter the outcome of the cases. News is not a business rolling in money; publishers go out of business every day even without being forced to burn unlimited millions. I can and will seriously argue that Gawker will be unable to afford defense lawyers long before Thiel will be unable afford lawyers playing offense.
- Natsu 10y ago> But because Gawker may not be able to afford a full defense, they could well be out of business. They had lawyers. They had their defense. They can appeal, but they have no one but themselves to blame for going to court and asserting the right to publish stolen sex tapes of anyone over 4... and for violating a court order. Inasmuch as there are problems here, they're with the legal system in general, not this suit specifically. Rather, it reminds me more of the McDonald's hot coffee thing, where if they had been reasonable, they wouldn't have been hit so hard.
- wpietri 10y ago> Inasmuch as there are problems here, they're with the legal system in general, not this suit specifically. To me that's like saying, "Inasmuch as there are problems with this massive data breach, they're with computer security in general, not the thief in specific." Sure, there's a broader problem. But that doesn't mean that people willing to take advantage of a problem aren't also a problem. When many factors contribute to a bad outcome, it's worth looking at every factor when trying to fix the problem.
- Natsu 10y agoIf that's the case, then everyone who presents a legitimate claim in court is part of the problem. It's not like there's some alternative to the legal system he could've used to address his grievances. Moreover, opting out of using the legal system does nothing to improve matters for others. This was not some meritless nuisance suit, as should be evident by the fact that he won. The broader problem is when people do things like spam settlement offers for less than the cost of defense, or the fact that the legal system is so expensive to operate to begin with. But none of these can rightfully be blamed on Bolea, so your analogy is simply faulty. There's no "abuse" here to begin with: he had a valid legal claim and won on the merits in court. It is telling that as much as you wax poetic about abusing the court system, you failed to acknowledge that Gawker is the one who violated a court order here. I mean, if winning a meritorious case is what you count as "abuse" of the legal system, exactly how do you rate that?
- wpietri 10y agoI don't have an issue with Bollea. I have an issue with Thiel. Thiel did not have a legitimate claim in court, but he is still using his billions to destroy a news organization he does not like. I should say again that I am not interested in defending Gawker here; I think Denton's an ass. I think Nazis are terrible too, but I think it's worth defending both their and Gawker's First Amendment rights.
- Natsu 10y agoRight, but you'd have to rule against Bolea, who was wronged, to get to Thiel. All Thiel did was help Bolea. So if Bolea did nothing wrong, then you have nothing left to accuse Thiel of. You may not like his motives, but he didn't actually do anything but help someone wronged seek justice. Inasmuch as this creates a chilling effect to keep people from publishing stolen sex tapes... oh well.
- anamoulous 10y agoHave you watched any of the depositions or testimony in this trial? I feel like the lawyers and Denton were the only people from Gawker who were taking this case seriously. Time and time again the hostility and outright contempt coming from the Gawker side only served to undermine their case. AJ Daulerio specifically, but even his subordinates and Gawker management were trying to out draw the lawyers every time they were questioned. They did not speak plainly and they were evasive. It's true that The Hulk had home field advantage here (and easily arguable that Gawker being from NYC hurt them even more than The Hulk being from Florida), but they did themselves no favors at all during the trial. It's like they gave up and sought to win in appeal.
- wpietri 10y agoPersonally, I am definitely not interested in defending most of Gawker's behavior here. I think Denton is a heel, a reprobate, and frequently a fool. What I do care about is that people recognize that using money to silence reporting, however lowbrow and however nettlesome, is a step on the road to oligarchy. The 1st Amendment is a cornerstone of our democracy. Thiel here isn't trying to litigate an issue of concern to him. His only goal is to destroy a publisher, regardless of the merits of plaintiffs' complaints. Now there are plenty here who are fine with a little oligarchy, and some who would like quite a lot. If they want to openly argue for that, great. And plenty of people, me included, have contempt for Denton, and who will enjoy his eventual comeuppance. But as much as I'd like to see that, I don't want to see it come with a major chilling effect on our already-mostly-toothless tech press.
- anamoulous 10y agoI'm not making a value judgement on the merits of the case... what I'm saying is they failed to defend themselves adequately. This was a winnable case and if they had done a better job we wouldn't be having this conversation.
- wpietri 10y agoAh, interesting. Sorry I misunderstood. Thanks for clarifying!
- cjbprime 10y agoYou're right that the lack of "loser pays" for legal fees in these cases is disturbing. But so far there's been precisely one case, and I subjectively claim (as have legal experts) that it raised important and non-frivolous legal questions that deserved to be answered, and my opinion is that the jury reached the correct verdict.