12 ms·
Everyone needs to shut the hell up about nuclear obsolescence. If we can just keep the politicians from noticing the need to "modernize" these terrible weapons
by ForHackernews 10y ago
Everyone needs to shut the hell up about nuclear obsolescence.
If we can just keep the politicians from noticing the need to "modernize" these terrible weapons, then in a few short decades we will have achieved a de facto global disarmament. Everyone can continue manning their silos filled with stale dud warheads, fingers hovering over buttons that no longer work. We'll have all the stratigic stabilizing influences of mutually-assured-destruction, with none of the actual threat-of-destruction.
But engineers and journalists need to shut up and not point out that the emperor's got no nukes.
- briarrose 10y agoIt's too late. The Obama administration has proposed a one trillion dollar budget to modernize the nuclear arsenal. The inclusion of low-yield nuclear devices is considered especially unnerving as it is believed their use would be easier to justify and could lean to a full nuclear exchange. http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/01/12/science/as-us-modernizes-nuclear-weapons-smaller-leaves-some-uneasy.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/01/12/science/as-us-modernize...
- saalweachter 10y agoTo be fair, Obama requesting the money is one of the best ways to ensure Congress does not appropriate it.
- dragonwriter 10y agoWhile true in general, with regard to military applications, Obama requesting money can be a way to get Congress to appropriate more.
- saalweachter 10y agoObama also unfortunately tends to act in good faith and with intent, so snark aside if he requested the funding for them he is probably OK with tactical nukes.
- IIAOPSW 10y agoNo, people that agree with you about nuclear disarmament need to stfu if they want the de facto win you suggest. Personally I don't think you can keep the stability benefits of MAD if secretly none of the buttons work. Eventually there will be a leak. You are literally suggesting security through obscurity. But irrespective of my disposition this I still think this is the wrong way to get a "win". If you want disarmament then you should go through the political process and vote for people. Getting "wins" outside of the proper political process is just a bad precedent in general.
- roywiggins 10y agoBut what if one side, realizing its weapons are getting stale, decide that the other side's weapons are staler, and thinks it can launch a first strike with relative impunity?