4 ms·
"The Telegraph's explanation is terrible: "with a special crystal structure in the glass they can bounce back the energy which is usually lost in heat, while st
by collyw 10y ago
"The Telegraph's explanation is terrible: "with a special crystal structure in the glass they can bounce back the energy which is usually lost in heat, while still allowing the light through."
The tungsten filament is sandwiched between two plates made up of layers of oxides, designed to selectively reflect infrared radiation and transmit visible light."
Whats terrible about that? Its the same as what you said using words that could be understood by a child.
- refurb 10y agoI was thinking the same thing. When I read the Telegraph explanation and was told it was terrible i thought "dam those reporters!". Then I read the actual scientific explanation and thought the Telegraph summary was pretty good.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- woodman 10y agoAsk the child to draw it, you'll notice the problem. One description makes me think that the glass has some new treatment, the other makes me think that there is a new structure within the bulb.
- andrepd 10y agoSplitting hairs. The point, as succinctly as possible is that: Incandescent bulbs are inefficient because they lose a lot of energy as heat instead of light. This counters that by introducing a crystal that selectively blocks the heat and lets the light through. Maybe the explanation is wrong in the minutiae but it gets the fundamental point across.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoI don't understand how that's supposed to make the bulb more efficient. If you're trying to keep the interior of the bulb hot, mission accomplished. But the problem we're trying to solve is that when we run a current through the filament, some of the energy we supply becomes visible light and some becomes infrared light. We want more of it to become visible light and less of it to become infrared light. How does preventing infrared light from leaving the bulb help with that?
- Someone 10y agoHere’s my take on this (corrections welcome): the thing you need to get light out is a hot filament. You use electricity to a) make it hot and b) keep it hot. Both are easier the better the filament is thermally isolated. Caveat: if that argument is correct, I would think a bulb with triple glazing would help, too. Has that been tried?
- mapt 10y agoThe thermal mirror needs to selectively reflect infrared while being transparent to visible light, and it needs to bounce radiation back and forth, which requires a certain geometry. The novelty of this paper is creating a big flat filament sandwiched between high-temperature plates that reflect infrared and can be deposited as layered coatings.
- eru 10y ago> Caveat: if that argument is correct, I would think a bulb with triple glazing would help, too. Has that been tried? The triple glazing is supposed to keep the infrared in (radiation losses), or supposed to keep losses from convection and conduction down?
- Hayleysaurus 10y agoThe reflected IR light will be absorbed by the filament, therefore requiring less energy over time to keep the filament at temperature. That thermal energy while lower than the input energy will create a baseline temperature, so now you only need Some of the new energy to output more photons, instead of All the energy.
- Laforet 10y agoBingo, this is how incadescence work: heating any solid material above a certain temperature will make it glow, all we need to worry about is finding a material that can withstand the temperature and make it into an efficient package. Gas mantles work pretty much the same way. A cage made of ceramic metal oxides (formed by firing a cotton bag dipped in thorium or yttrium nitrate, if thorium is used then every use will release a few microrems of radioactove radon gas) is heated by gas or oil fire to incadescence; because the temperature is much higher than a light bulb, gas lamps actually waste less heat as infrared.
- wycx 10y agoI also found the Telegraph's explanation lacking. Their explanation they give makes me think that the interior of the glass bulb has some coating or special composition. This impression is quite distinct from the reality of the filament between plates with alternating layers of SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3 or Ta2O5. The Telegraph could have at least said that the advance involved sandwiching the filament between layers of transparent material that transmit light by reflect IR. Not to mention conflating crystal structure and glass. (Glasses can be distinguished from crystals by a lack of repeating long range structure).