2 ms·
I've looked at it before, in the context of R/C aircraft (my hobby). The problem is the same one everyone else has named: airplanes need to maximize power-to-w
by paulmd 10y ago
I've looked at it before, in the context of R/C aircraft (my hobby). The problem is the same one everyone else has named: airplanes need to maximize power-to-weight ratio and hybrid-electric systems are heavier for a given power output.
My conclusion was that a battery-based system was a bad approach. Instead you would want to use a hybrid motor/generator approach - you can use a glow motor to spin an electric motor, and if you couple the electric motor to another identical motor they will spin lockstep. It's like a diesel-electric transmission on a ship or locomotive. And the funny thing is glow engines are actually a kind of diesel engine too.
https://youtu.be/6kgzrXFSDwA?t=13 https://youtu.be/6kgzrXFSDwA?t=13
This would be most advantageous for multi-engine setups because you would be able to use more energy-dense liquid fuels instead of batteries, use a single larger/more efficient motor as the prime mover, and avoid the complexity of multi-engine operation. With gas engines, you need to tune each engine to perform similarly, have a throttle servo with identical/aligned travel for each, independent fuel supplies (or at least header tanks), etc. Whereas electric motors are dead simple, but the problem is the batteries are hard to lift. So instead of batteries you have a prime mover - and on top of that you get liquid fuels too.
Ideally you'd probably want a single larger generator-motor attached to multiple small drive motors, but they would need to be chosen so that the electrical characteristics of the motors were appropriate for each other throughout the RPM range.
The downside is that it probably doesn't scale well to full-size aircraft - many small aircraft are relatively underpowered even with gas engines. And in both cases, having multiple independent power sources enhances safety, as this creates a single point-of-failure.