4 ms·
I grew up in the U.S. but in the past year, I've been able to spend a significant amount of time abroad, primarily in Europe and Japan. The single biggest thin
by keiferski 10y ago
I grew up in the U.S. but in the past year, I've been able to spend a significant amount of time abroad, primarily in Europe and Japan.
The single biggest thing I've noticed: there are virtually no overweight people. And yet, no one is on some kind of obscure no-meat/no-carbs/no-fruit diet. People just live, eat the local food (which often has a ton of butter, salt, fat, etc.) and somehow still look 100% better than Americans.
My conclusion: obesity is caused by some combination of excessive portion sizes + over-processed food. It's not that complicated.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> My conclusion: obesity is caused by some combination of excessive portion sizes + over-processed food. Don't forget lack of exercise from a car-centric transportation culture.
- justinlardinois 10y agoUnfortunately very true. So much of America is designed with the assumption that everyone has a car and there's no attempt to make anything pedestrian-accessible. I live in San Jose and I honestly miss walking. I mean sure, I can walk, but I can't use it to go anywhere other than the 7/11 near my apartment without taking an hour or more out of my day. That's not to say I don't like living here (I do) but I guess that's just something you deal with when you trade a comparatively small college town (Santa Cruz) for a huge, spread-out city.
- nickbauman 10y agoI believe the US has the highest car ownership per capita in the OECD.
- justinhj 10y agoI used to live in London (England) and walk and tube everywhere. My first trip to the US was LA. I parked at a cafe and bought a coffee. We saw a store across the street so crossed it. Even though traffic was light and it was easy to do so without causing it to slow down the cars honked us for doing so. Jaywalking. I'd never really thought of Jaywalking outside of movies. So we go in the store and afterwards make an effort to walk a couple of blocks down to the crossing so we don't get arrested or run down. When we get back to the car there's a tow truck trying to take it away because we were shopping across the street and no longer customers of this strip. It was pretty amazing to us. We spent the rest of the trip driving everywhere, no matter how small the journey.
- justinlardinois 10y ago> When we get back to the car there's a tow truck trying to take it away because we were shopping across the street and no longer customers of this strip. Does this not happen in other countries? It's not exactly common in the US, but you will see it dense areas sometimes where a) parking is limited and costs money and b) businesses provide parking free of charge to their own customers.
- namenotrequired 10y agoI'm European and have never heard of such a thing. It sounds bizarre to me.
- justinlardinois 10y agoWhen you think about it from a business's perspective it makes sense. If a bunch of people who aren't your customers fill up your lot, and there isn't nearby parking or it costs money, potential customers will arrive and might leave without patronizing your business because they can't find a place to park. Obviously it's annoying when it's enforced as overzealously as the above example.
- hoorayimhelping 10y agoObesity is almost completely dominated by diet. Moving to New York, ditching the car, and walking everywhere netted me maybe 150 calories in deficit over the most active days. That's a soda or a beer, or a typical American office snack. Exercise can't come close to making up for how calorie dense most of our 'convenient' packaged food is.
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoI don't buy it. I'm also a New York transplant, and even the folks here with unhealthy diets seem to be in massively better shape than those in car-centric American cities with similar diets. That also goes for folks in car-centric cities who have healthy diets but are still overweight. My working theory is that walking all the time ramps up the metabolism. Regardless, the notion of a 1:1 relationship between calories consumed and calories "retained" seems suspicious. [edit] regarding the "you can't outrun the fork" theory of weightloss (e.g. exercising at the gym won't offset a poor diet), I absolutely agree with you, but I think there's a difference between an hour or two of intense exercise every other day (a gym membership) vs a lifestyle of walking everywhere all the time.
- mod 10y agoDo you spend (far more than) an hour per day walking everywhere? If not, what's the difference in that and gym-exercise?
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoDefinitely. As to why I think it’s different, here's a possibly dumb analogy: my building has this rooftop garden, and for the past few years, someone would walk up to the rooftop and water it a couple times a day with a hose. So far, so good. Last year I decided it would be funny to install a drop irrigation system. Half a dozen times a day it trickles out water. Just drips, possibly less total water than the hose sprays. Our yield last year was simply bananas. Plants growing taller than me in little pots and 16"-deep crates. The local plant expert explained to me that when plants get sporadic water, they grow roots deep to find more; when they get constant water, even if not as much, they "assume" water will be around whenever they need it and grow up instead. I speculate that the human metabolism works in a similar way, and that ongoing, low levels of exercise is more beneficial to the metabolism than daily spurts of high intensity exercise. just a theory IANA scientist obviously
- Nadya 10y ago>My conclusion: obesity is caused by some combination of excessive portion sizes + over-processed food. I disagree on portion sizes, based on my experiences in Japan. In Japan - there is far less sugary products and they are less popular than in the states. (eg: soda). Even many of their "desserts" aren't that sugary (or tasty IMO...) I stayed with a family during my time there. During home cooked meals it wasn't uncommon to have several servings - often times totaling more food than I'd ever eat in the States! While I would politely decline past the second serving [0] on the grounds of being full, the family I was staying with would often have several servings each. It was so much food! It felt like instead of one "double-size" serving they would have six "half sized" servings (slightly exaggerating # of servings). I ate less than everyone in the family - they even commented on the fact many times! They were surprised I would always be full before they were and had expected an American to always be hungry (because of the "smaller portions" of Japan). I also ate with other families/visited other foreigners my family knew and it was always the same! Smaller portions but way more servings! Restaurant serving sizes were more or less equal to the States except the drinks which felt like the largest sizes were equivalent to a kid's cup or a water cup you'd get at a fast food joint in the states. I was perpetually thirsty in Japan. Also Japanese people walk/bike nearly everywhere as the public transport via trains is very practical and very convenient. The exercise certainly adds up. [0] Always have seconds if the cook offers!
- soundwave106 10y agoAmerica does have a "excessive portion size" problem per se, but "appropriate portion" should vary depending on what you are eating. In America, it often doesn't. It's pretty easy to Google 2500+ calorie monstrosities that are served as a dinner in American restaurants. We have pastas with rich sauces (lots of butter, oils, or sugar), dishes with excessive cheese, and large amounts of deep fried ingredients... and many places serve a heck of a lot of this when you go out to eat. Other countries have rich foods too, but my experience is that many cultures with very rich food often go light on the portion size (France comes to mind). Another set of countries have cuisine that normally is not very rich or excessively sweet (like you mention with Japan and the lack of sugary products). In many cases the food is flavored with spice instead of fats and sugars. For these type of foods, I bet you could easily match the portion size of one of those big American restaurant meals, and come nowhere near the calories. Another factor that probably doesn't help here is that America seems more soda oriented than many cultures, and that excessive use of sugar even applies to other drinks all down the chain (my impression is that other cultures use way less sugar on coffee, tea, alcoholic cocktails...). It all adds up.
- justsaysmthng 10y agoDon't be fooled by appearances, obesity is a problem in Europe, too! While the absolute numbers are lower in Europe versus the U.S., they're still very high. The numbers vary from 30% (UK) to 20+% in most other countries (vs ~35% in the US). The reason you don't see overweight people on the streets is because they're not going out as much and are traveling by cars or .. just sitting at home.