53 ms·
This is what I've been thinking for quite a while but what allot of people seem to ignore - the "AI revolution" can very well "only" hit developing nations whi
by dogma1138 10y ago
This is what I've been thinking for quite a while but what allot of people seem to ignore - the "AI revolution" can very well "only" hit developing nations while skipping the developed ones.
Better, smarter robots are a threat to Chinese workers, not so much to say Dutch or Canadian workers.
The west can afford and is willing to pay more even for less, just look at how many people are willing to pay 10 times the price for "Organic Fare Traded Tomatoes" or any other "artisan" goods.
The west is also not as much dependent on manufacturing and the manufacturing it does do is usually high tech, low(er) volume and highly specialized one where it both might not make sense to automate everything and where people are more than willing to pay the extra to know that something was "hand crafted".
But overall we've developed a consumer culture especially in the past decade that is pretty much focused on retro/old school craftsmanship, small scale production and "artisan" touches, it almost makes one wonder if the whole "hipster revolution" wasn't hand crafted by some cabal of shadowy figures that foresaw the "rise of the machines", because our willingness to pay 250$ for a hand crafted hemp bag on etsy is just might be the thing that would protect us from AI automation.
- artursapek 10y agoI think the point is that robots will do the shitty low-margin jobs like drive trucks, bag french fries, and change tires, and humans will get to do more enjoyable jobs like creating "artisan" goods as you refer to them.
- st3v3r 10y agoWith what money?
- artursapek 10y agoRobots are happy to work for free (minus operating costs) and there won't be enough work left to occupy all adults for 5 days a week. I think the economics of all this are the hardest question to answer right now.
- st3v3r 10y agoRobots work for free. They aren't developed, assembled, and maintained for free. So that brings us back to the original question: With what money is that former truck driver supposed to start their robot trucking business?
- anigbrowl 10y agoThe laws of supply and demand mean that the artisinal jobs will in turn become shitty and low margin because of the oversupply of cheap labor.
- artursapek 10y agoWell I'm also assuming people will also spend a lot less of their lives working. Otherwise you're correct, there will be a huge oversupply of labor.
- btbuildem 10y agoSelf-driving trucks will have a significant impact on North-American workforce. Something like 6% ppl in NA are employed in the trucking industry.
- throwawaykeno 10y agoIMO self-driving trucks won't displace humans behind the wheel. Trucks on public roads will be self-driving in the same way that planes are self-flying.
- steffan 10y ago> IMO self-driving trucks won't displace humans behind the wheel. Trucks on public roads will be self-driving in the same way that planes are self-flying. Not this year. Not next year. But they will.
- nsxwolf 10y agoSomething I never hear when discussing automated trucks is the 10% of truckers that are owner-operators. Won't they just slap automation onto their trucks, and continue to own (but no longer operate)? Won't displaced truck drivers become motivated to be owners themselves? It doesn't seem as bleak as everyone makes out. I don't really think most big companies want to own and maintain their own fleets of trucks.
- randallsquared 10y agoEconomies of scale seem like a large win, here. If you own a thousand trucks, your per-truck maintenance costs are less than if you own one truck. Companies that don't want to own and maintain a fleet of trucks will outsource to those who do, but it's simpler to deal with one external entity that can supply trucking than ten or a hundred such entities.
- kuschku 10y agoThat’s where cooperatives could come in – what if the owner-operating truckers would just start a cooperative and own the fleet together?
- dangerboysteve 10y agoNot just a threat to Chinese workers but also the Chinese government. Unemployment tends to foster civil unrest.
- LiweiZ 10y agoIn this connected world, top elites of the world have to figure out how to tax each territory, how to maximize the profit and how to be adaptable and sustainable. China in chaos seems not a decent option within the near future.
- epalmer 10y agoIt is not just manufacturing that is going to be replaced by AI and Robots and it will affect developing and developed countries. Already there are a lot of junior lawyers being replaced [0]. Check out what a former CEO of McDonald's said about robots and the fast food industry [1]. > “I was at the National Restaurant Show yesterday and if you look at the robotic devices that are coming into the restaurant industry – it’s cheaper to buy a $35,000 robotic arm than it is to hire an employee who’s inefficient making $15 an hour bagging french fries,” the former US chief executive Ed Rensi told Fox Business’ Maria Bartiromo. [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/05/science/05legal.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/05/science/05legal.html [1] http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/25/former-mcdonalds-ceo-threatens-replace-employees-robots http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/25/former-mcdona...
- Canada 10y agoI wonder where the senior lawyers will come from... [edit] then again, automation of software development tasks held back the software industry at all...
- dogma1138 10y agoYes things like legal discovery, medical history research and many other things can (and could be for the past 10+ years) and will be "replaced" or more like integrated with software / machine learning assist. Large firms that hire 30 new associates instead of 50 won't be a big blow to the economy, even McDonalds switching to more automation won't have that much of a negative impact McDonald's can and should be the "cheapest" option, but don't expect the local diner to automate at the same time, and don't forget that we are willing to pay more for a barista even tho when you use the same beans even 25 year old automated coffee machines produces a better and more consistent product than the vast majority of barista's out there. The Restaurant industry in the US overall employs about 15M people and that figure is expected to grow by 10% in the next 10 years even with automation.
- bksjdf 10y agoYou are overestimating the complexity and importance of the average job in developed nations. Most of these jobs, like the grunt workforce in banks, can be fairly easily automated. Automation is slowly hitting all sectors in developed nations as well, it is not as prominent because only parts of the required processes can be replaced at a time and these require training for the people that will be working with the new automated 'stack'. That being said, I think it will be 5 - 10 years in the West until most people really start feeling the effects of automation.
- laumars 10y agoThere are still applications for computerised "assistants" outside of manufacturing that can have a direct impact on jobs in the west. Eg self service checkouts at supermarkets, automated car washes, and we're increasingly seeing robots and drones being tested for delivery services. The problem isn't so much east vs west. The problem is technology is cheaper than people so unskilled labour is easily replaceable.
- gdudeman 10y agoThe robotics and machine revolution has already hit the US. Car manufacturing: We still build cars here, but we don't employ nearly as many people. Logging: contrary to popular belief, the spotted owl didn't destroy logging jobs. Machines that let 1 person replace 20 did. Manufacturing is the easiest, first place to replace workers, but AI will replace lots of people in America. It looks like trucking and taxis are on the short list - that's a few million workers - but fast food restaurants are up next (and those innovations will move up the chain to fancier restaurants). Over the last 200 years, there was almost always a new role for people when their job was automated, but over the last 20 years a lot of those new roles were lower paying service jobs. No way is our consumer culture actually based on small scale production and artisan touches - and not that many of those artisan touches are made by people or machines in China. That may be what you notice, but most of America's paycheck goes to the regular old normal stuff.
- dogma1138 10y agoBut this is what already happened, we talk about the next level of automation, generic automation, machine learning, and next generation robotics that could replicate the finesse and agility of humans and are flexible enough to be adapted for any task. The manufacturing in western nations in many cases is already as automated as it can get (yes there is always a room for more optimization but industries that have been automated since the 70's will and are already hitting diminishing returns), what has not been automated are mostly tasks that we choose not to automate for various reasons, many of which are cultural. And yes most of the stuff we buy is mass produced, generic, and already highly automated but it's also not made in the US, the US consumer doesn't care about Chinese workers or unemployment in China, and it won't buy a 250$ hand crafted anything in China unless they are caught drunk in a tourist trap. And that's exactly the point artisan crafting and manufacturing has been developing in the US and it is pretty much immune to threats from automation and the AI/Machine Learning revolution because we as consumers are making a conscious decision to buy it. And even when we do buy mass produced generic crap just look at how many products are marketed today by selling you the human story from shoes to coffee beans it's all the same.
- 10y ago
- mc32 10y agoIt'll affect developing countries more only because their labor force is dominated by low value added manual labor which is easiest to replace, so they will face the brunt of it. On the other hand, developed nations have been on this trajectory already, so the hit will be much more buffeted and gradual, but it will eat at the more automatable jobs like driving, harvesting, and jobs involving paperwork/discovery, fast food service, education, etc.
- bch 10y agoWhat about this[0] move by Adidas pulling Asian production back to Germany (but now completed by robots instead of humans). Clearly a loss for factories in Asia, but much of a win for anybody but Adidas ? [0] http://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/adidas-pulls-back-asia-robots-get-jobs-n579991 http://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/adidas-pulls-b...
- reality_hacker 10y agoThere is a win for Germany: - more opportunities for high skilled robotics engineers, so they can stay at home, and don't move to US - tax income for country, which can be spend wisely.
- Kadin 10y agoSure, it's great for Germany. Those robots don't maintain themselves.
- danvoell 10y agoThere are a lot of assumptions in your response as it relates to manufacturing and the "west". How can you say this will "skip" developed nations in light of current statistics about the US middle class. The US started moving in this direction a long time ago because labor cost more here. We are realizing the effects today and will continue to see worse effects in the long term. You don't see too many of these articles in the US because firing 60,000 people in favor of robots is not viewed as a badge of honor. FoxxConn is using this as a puff piece to appease foreign buyers.
- IkmoIkmo 10y agoI think you're overestimating the amount of high-skill jobs people do in the west to be honest. Like we've got a ton of truck drivers, who'll surely disappear within a few decades, which is just one at most two generations. In terms of policy planning this is a short-term timeframe. Same for most people who work in retail, from clothes shops to supermarkets. But even higher-level jobs will change massively. I highly doubt education will stay as labour-intensive. And I've got family members who are attorneys, and when I speak to them they'll tell me a ton of their workload is simply going through legal documents to look up stuff, and then preparing mostly template legal documents. A lot of this is manual work that'll disappear sooner than you'd think. We've already seen examples in this field with the automated bot that helps void parking tickets. The amount of people that work high-skilled labour is really small if you ask me. I think a decent first order approximation is to compare the amount of people that work at the Walmart or Amazon headquarters, versus their stores and warehouses. For Amazon I've seen numbers that it's roughly 24k vs 240k, and consider that this is a tech-oriented company that's already automated a lot. For walmart it'd likely be 1:1000. Take a Facebook with 12k employees, a leader in a high-skill industry, and it's the margin of error of the employee count of a leader in a low-skill industry, not in China, but right here in the west, like say Walmart (> 1m employees) or say a franchise like McDonalds. These are also Dutch or Canadian workers.
- muraiki 10y agoAn attorney friend of mine told me that discovery is being affected by this. Instead of having a team of higher level attorneys supervise a team of lower level attorneys (and maybe paralegals also) sorting through tons of papers in discovery, those high level attorneys train an algorithm on what documents are of particular interest from a small subset of them all (creating the training set) and then they let the algo do the work. An anesthesiologist friend of mine went back and got his MBA because he's certain that machines will dramatically reduce the amount of jobs for anesthesiologists; you'll have one anesthesiologist supervising X machines instead of X anesthesiologists.
- anigbrowl 10y agoQuite true; my wife works in e-discovery and much more of her work is in normalizing messy data sets than doing the discovery itself.
- elsewhen 10y agoi think this hipster revolution is happening in small circles in a few cities. to put the revolution in perspective, here are etsy's gross marketplace sales (GMS) compared to annual revenue of some mass-market retailers: etsy: $2.3B [0] target: $73B [1] williams sonoma: $5B [2] bed bath and beyond: $12B [3] [0] https://investors.etsy.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=253952&p=irol-newsArticle&ID=2142373 https://investors.etsy.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=253952&p=irol-new... [1] https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ATGT&fstype=ii&ei=ruNFV8n8IoOOmAHK1LP4DQ https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ATGT&fstype=ii&ei=ruN... [2] https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3AWSM&fstype=ii&ei=EORFV6nvHIPHmAH0sLWwAQ https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3AWSM&fstype=ii&ei=EOR... [3] https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ABBBY&fstype=ii&ei=2uNFV7HeBYaImAGM-7zIBQ https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ABBBY&fstype=ii&ei=...
- riskable 10y agoAnother figure to add to the hipster revolution: Youtubers and Twitch streamers. It could one of but a few ways to make money in the future (entertainment). I hope you like playing with Play Doh!