8 ms·
I was around when the takeover of Nokia R&D happened in Febuary 2011, I remember walking around the offices of Ruohulati in Helsinki and seeing a massive queue
by dijit 10y ago
I was around when the takeover of Nokia R&D happened in Febuary 2011, I remember walking around the offices of Ruohulati in Helsinki and seeing a massive queue to the IT room, previously linux laptops were being reformatted to run windows.
I asked one of the project managers: "why, will it really change that much for us, I mean, there's hope right?"
they responded: "This is a takeover, I've seen it before, they're just not calling it that- they'll kill MeeGO in it's crib.. and for us, it's adapt or die".
By the end of the second week (Elop did an eloquent speech about the future of Meego) all the really senior technical experts were working for Intel despite Elop saying "they just want to sell chips" and being generally derogatory to Intel), all the designers and senior management went to Jolla (which tried to enter a market which is fairly dominated already as a startup), myself, I was fired.. and everyone else is still running the ghost ship, I wasn't a large fan of microsofts products going in to Nokia, which is why I liked Maemo/MeeGO for the phone and I could use Linux at work- but this move cemented them as assholes in my mind.
Nothing they do nowadays for good PR is going to change my mind of how surreptitiously they took over nokia and sent it into it's death spiral. Microsoft really loves to own and eventually destroy Nordic companies. (skype, minecraft, nokia) - lets see what they do with TeacherGaming.
- BorgHunter 10y agoNokia was doomed before Elop took over. Kallasvuo was CEO when Apple released the first iPhone, and Kallasvuo was the one who decided that Nokia's existing offerings were good enough to compete, just keep minorly refining things every generation. By the time Elop came in, the ship was already sinking (or, if you prefer, the platform was already burning). Elop's decisions did not turn that around, but realistically, could he have?
- rospaya 10y agoI agree that Nokia was too slow to compete, but they had massive advantages over both Apple and Google and with good guidance could've survived successfully. Even years after the iPhone came out, Nokia outsold Apple, had a bigger R&D budget and a bigger foothold in practically every market except North America. Smartphones outsold feature (dumb) phones only in 2013, five years after the iPhone came out. When did Nokia slip to 3rd place by number of sold devices? Q1 2015. There was time, just no will.
- newjersey 10y agoI don't have any inside information but as an outsider the main thing that puts pressure on everyone is the margin that Apple commands on its products. People have repeatedly said that even when iPhone had 20% of the smartphones sold, they were taking in a much bigger slice of the pie when it came to profits. How do we tell potential shareholders "you can put your $1 on Apple or you can put your $1 on us but just so you know we have to ship n times as many phones as Apple does just to make the same amount of money that Apple does".
- biokoda 10y ago> Smartphones outsold feature (dumb) phones only in 2013, five years after the iPhone came out. Yes but who had higher profits? That's the real factor. Outselling by itself is meaningless if your margins are poor.
- nextos 10y ago> but they had massive advantages over both Apple and Google and with good guidance could've survived successfully. I can't agree more. Few people remember the Nokia 770 was released almost 2 years ahead of the iPhone. With a bit of polish it could have grown into a fantastic product line. In fact, the N9 was pretty much a masterpiece.
- nickik 10y agoI remember wanting to buy it. I didn't because back then it was to much money for me. I remember thinking that I defently want a future version of it. For some reason that I don't understand, they continued to push Symbian, and those phones were not good. I remember thinking, either push further on the MeeGo stuff or drop it and move to Android. They did neither and suffered for it.
- ptaipale 10y agoSymbian devices were actually very good phones. For making and receiving voice calls, they were better than Android has ever been. Of course, as a platform for Web browsing, and particularly for app development, Symbian was not good. But I still miss the phone functionality of my E71, or the Symbian devices I had before it.
- twblalock 10y agoIf Elop had bet on Android instead of Windows Phone, Nokia would probably be doing well.
- x0x0 10y agoAlmost certainly not. Have you seen the profit numbers at Samsung, Motorola, and HTC? They're getting destroyed by Android competitors like Xiaomi, Huawei, etc and Apple.
- twblalock 10y agoWhat makes you think Nokia would have ended up like Samsung/Motorola/HTC rather than Xiaomi/Huawei/etc? Nokia at least had a chance to be one of the profitable ones.
- godzillabrennus 10y agoThere are no profitable android makers. Apple has 94% of the profits in mobile: http://iphone.appleinsider.com/articles/15/11/16/apple-inc-now-inhaling-94-percent-of-global-smartphone-profits-selling-just-145-percent-of-total-volumes http://iphone.appleinsider.com/articles/15/11/16/apple-inc-n... We will never know for sure by Nokia shareholders might have gotten an amazing deal out of going Windows Mobile and getting acquired by Microsoft. As for the employees, this would have happened either way with how badly the company was prepared for smartphones.
- sytelus 10y agoRecent Samsung financial results say that their profit growth is fueled in part by Galaxy S7. So, no, there are fairly profitable android makers. http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/27/11523616/samsung-earnings-q1-2016-galaxy-s7-sales http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/27/11523616/samsung-earnings-...
- x0x0 10y agoBecause every android manufacturer will end with virtually no profit since they are producing a commodity. When you basically can't differentiate with your software except for which shitty skin you layered on top of Android, what makes a samsung better than an lg or any other android device?
- pjmlp 10y agoI too was there during those days, in Espoo. But to be honest we also had our share of alienating developers, it wasn't only MS fault. First the Symbian development was a mess with the Metrowerk tools and that Symbian C++ dialect, then came PIPS, followed by Carbide (Eclipse based). Followed by the whole mess of open sourcing Symbian and closing it again. Or the Symbian model moving from Symbian C++ / PIPS to Qt, also in the middle this process. Maemo was GTK, but then everyone should move to Qt. Better not lets also move the OS into Meego. I remember asking why the Nokia 770 didn't had a GSM modem and the team saying to me that wasn't the market they wanted to target. When they did the usual roadshow of upcoming devices. Nokia was already quite bad in terms of relationship with app developers before Elop came into the party, due to the internal politics. Of course, the famous burning platform memo was just the last way to alienate developers that were slowly accepting the new Qt based model for Symbian, after all the previous pain points.
- hellothere789 10y agothis yor folt
- mongol 10y agoWhat if Nokia 770 also was a phone? History could have been so radically different. I will never understand...
- honkhonkpants 10y agoIf the 770 was also a phone, it would have been a ghastly tablet with a phone inside.
- orbitingpluto 10y agoBut in 2007, the n800 would have been a ghastly tablet/phone with 2.5x the pixels, expandable storage to 64GB, and several different media players that sucked, but are still better than iTunes today. I'm still using the Canola media player on an n810.
- 10y ago
- facepalm 10y agoWhat would have happened to Nokia phones if MS hadn't taken over? They pretty much dug their own hole.
- smitherfield 10y agoYes, far from "destroying" Nokia, MS threw good money after bad to the tune of $billions trying to keep them afloat. Now they've given up on that fruitless endeavor.
- dnissley 10y agoThey could've been in Samsung's place if they hadn't bet the farm on Windows Phone.
- facepalm 10y agoThey were too proud to simply adopt Android. They were broken before they made deals with Microsoft. Shame - personally I think people would have bought a Nokia Android phone. They were renowned for their hardware.
- sirkneeland 10y ago3 possibilities (and probably many more): 1) go all-in with their own Symbian/Qt/MeeGo strategy 2) go all-in with Google Android 3) go all-in with a Nokia fork of Google Android (a nonstarter today, but back in 2011, with Nokia's considerable heft and before Google started rolling so much of Android into non-open Google Play Services, things could have played out differently) In terms of Nokia's performance as a phone company, it is more or less impossible for any of these options to have done any worse than Nokia did with Windows Phone. HOWEVER, for Nokia as a company, Windows Phone "worked out" in the sense that they had a willing buyer for an asset that was long-term uncompetitive against Asian players in a commodity market. (then again that too has a counter-argument that the phone division would have been worth more than $7 billion had it not dedicated itself to the losing proposition of Windows Phone)
- pjc50 10y agoMinecraft is very much not destroyed. Nokia .. well, the burning platform was while they were still an independent company. Like Blackberry they failed to adapt to smartphones, and failed to understand their own niche.
- danieldk 10y agoNokia .. well, the burning platform was while they were still an independent company. They were an independent company under control of a trusted general of Steve Ballmer. Nokia had a lot of goodwill in some regions, e.g. in Europe they were known for their excellent reliable and serviceable hardware. At the time the fear was that a switch to Android would reduce their margins, but I guess they'd still be around and pretty successful if they had switched to Android timely.
- pjmlp 10y agoA general that had a bonus clause on the contract offered by the Nokia board if he managed to sell the company. If you had such a bonus on your contract what would you do?
- unlinker 10y agoMinecraft is in a death spiral, but it's normal, since it's already an old and overplayed game for its target.
- rasjani 10y agoI was also in Ruoholahti at the time and while those where dreadful times, it wasn't as bad (Atleast for me) as you picture it. Yeah, MeeGo (well, it was Harmattan, there was nothing MeeGo except binary compatibility and using the name to please Intel). Formatting Linux laptops was more of a joke imho. And guys who started Jolla where really not high execs in the program - really good tech guys but not execs :) But yeah, I got myself a transfer inside Nokia after harmattan program was finished (still working on Linux stuff). Was away for few years and went back few months before Microsoft bought us, laid us off and our dept. spun off. During those times I didn't see any change on how things where handled from old Nokia days. So anyone who says that they didn't see this final layoff round coming is blind AF.
- hellothere789 10y agoRemember when they kicked out Ari Jaaksi (for one, I thought he was a GREAT leader). Then they brought in the son of the former Finnish president (Ahtisaari) and the guy stood in front of the entire program telling us how awesome he was and he was going to reshape the way people use mobile phones. Good times.
- hellothere789 10y agoI was also in Ruoholahti as well as Nokia House when they closed down Ruoholahti. Overnight Nokia turned into a cesspool of backstabbers who didn't add any real value, but managed to steal the credit from everyone else.
- mevile 10y ago> but managed to steal the credit from everyone else. Steal credit for what? What has come out of Microsoft's phone business since the Nokia purchase that anyone would want to take credit for?
- hellothere789 10y agoI said NOKIA turned into a cesspool, not Microsoft. As an example, Lumia 1020 had a lot of people working hard on it... but a very select few went out and took all the credit.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoThe flipside here is that Nokia was doomed anyway. Meego wasn't going to break the iOS/Android duopoly. Nokia was being destroyed by the success of the iPhone. It couldn't compete. >Microsoft really loves to own and eventually destroy Nordic companies. (skype, minecraft, nokia) Minecraft went from being neglected to even mismanaged to something that's alive again. Skype was originally Estonian, nor Nordic, and runs better than ever considering it doesn't rely on the charity of "supernodes" anymore. I can't remember the last time I had a dropped call or random quality drops. I do agree MS shouldn't have picked up Nokia. It was a walking corpse and didn't help either entity in the end, but this is just business as usual. Playing up this "wild linux hackers vs The Man(TM)" is pretty out there. If you want a paycheck, the entity that pays you needs to make money. If MS didn't fire you, Nokia would have. MS is profitable. Nokia isn't.
- dijit 10y agoWritten by Swedish people who registered the company in Estonia. (for tax reasons) I think Sweden counts as Nordic.
- jacquesm 10y agoIt's a real pity. I saw the writing on the wall and wrote this: http://jacquesmattheij.com/microsoft-just-bought-nokia-for-0 http://jacquesmattheij.com/microsoft-just-bought-nokia-for-0 And I very much wished I was wrong. They'll have to pry my impossible to destroy Nokia from my hands when I'm dead. Thanks!