4 ms·
The view that genetics control destiny results in weak people that don't respond well to adversity. If you look at people from fairly normal environments that
by CuriouslyC 10y ago
The view that genetics control destiny results in weak people that don't respond well to adversity. If you look at people from fairly normal environments that became highly successful, they basically all discount the value of talent fairly highly. On the other hand, if you look at people who significantly underachieve, belief in talent and destiny are extremely common.
Is this belief sufficient for great success? Of course not, you probably still need to be above average, talent wise, and be lucky. It is almost certainly necessary, however.
- akavi 10y agoIs it discounting talent that results in success? Or is it success results in discounting talent? Or a third (overlapping) possibility: Maybe believing in hard work results in "success", but only for a fraction of people. Is the expected value of the belief necessarily positive? Ie, take a simplified hypothetical universe where "success" is a binary possibility, with "utility" of 1, and where "hard work" is something that requires a utility investment of -0.1. Even if only those who choose "hard work" become successful regardless of talent or resources, if P("success"|"hard work" && $some_level_of_talent && $some_level_of_prior_resources) < 0.1, then it's still can be suboptimal to pursue "hard work" for the subset of the population with $some_level_of_talent and $some_level_of_prior_resources.
- themartorana 10y agoI think this comment is good at pointing out (if not directly) that there's an assumption often made - success may or may not be correlated with hard work, but failure is very often assumed to be the result of a lack of hard work. In fact I'd argue the hardest working people you'll ever meet are blue-collar, and often struggle continuously in life. "Grit" has nothing to do with it. Edit: I am not saying @akavi holds this belief. Don't know if that was clear.
- trishume 10y agoIt seems to me like that you could have the causality of that correlation reversed. People that don't have "talent" may consistently underperform those who do despite working hard and trying their best, causing them to realize that "talent" is an important factor.
- CuriouslyC 10y agoThe people I've met who fail at life tend to think they're working much harder than they are, and also have a tendency towards non-productive work. I don't care how fast you can run, if you're going in the wrong direction you're never going to win races. By the same token, I've met people who excel at pretty much everything they do because they understand that there is a process to mastery.