4 ms·
> Who needs Git? > Notably missing is support for merging So, it's almost like a car except it's missing its wheels No, it's not like Git
by raverbashing 10y ago
> Who needs Git?
> Notably missing is support for merging
So, it's almost like a car except it's missing its wheels
No, it's not like Git
- ultramancool 10y agoYeah, I think a better title would have been "ZFS for Git users".
- buserror 10y agoThat and the rather obvious 'sudo' in front of all the commands. I mean, it's a cool tool; I use it on my NAS (particularly like the ECC mode instead of dumb RAID), but the git-equivalence aspect looks a little bit like a flamebait ;-)
- Freaky 10y agozfs allow zef mount,create,destroy,snapshot,rollback,diff,clone,send,receive mypool/projects Now he doesn't need sudo in front of most of them.
- chungy 10y agoUnfortunately, it remains a feature only on Solaris/illumos and FreeBSD. The Linux and Mac ports still lack support for delegation.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y ago> Of course, I'm not seriously suggesting you'd ditch a "proper" version control system, but it gives a good sense of what's possible at the file system level. > Using ZFS as a replacement of Git for is probably not a good idea, but just to give you a sense of what ZFS supports at the file system level, let me go through a few typical git-like operations:
- pmarreck 10y agoI really don't think the article was seriously suggesting what you think it was; showing similarities between different types of tools (usually a more familiar one and a less familiar one) is meant to be illustrative
- Kurtz79 10y ago"I really don't think the article was seriously suggesting what you think it was" Then maybe it shouldn't have a purposefully click-baitingly title suggesting it does...
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoConsidering the audience I think it's fine. I don't think anyone on HN is going to see this title and think "oh the author is serious; this whatever thing that appears to be a file system by name can certainly replace git in its entirety!"
- combatentropy 10y ago>> I really don't think the article was seriously suggesting what you think it was > Then maybe it shouldn't have a purposefully click-baitingly title suggesting it does I normally hate clickbait, and yet I liked this article and its headline. Maybe because the tone was self-deprecating, like me getting on a bicycle and saying, "Look out, Tour de France!" Actually, it's like a fish getting on a bicycle and jokingly saying, "Look out, Tour de France." Maybe the fish isn't anywhere near good enough on a bike to compete in the Tour de France, but still, it's a fish on a bicycle. In the same way, Git will run circles around ZFS as a source-code version-control system. On the other hand, it's way cool that ZFS can even do some of these things, because after all it's just a filesystem.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoMaybe read the article before adding a snarky comment?