3 ms·
Be warned, this article has only a passing understanding of "system[s] of common law". The odd phraseology I put down to translation, but some of the specific
by sandworm101 10y ago
Be warned, this article has only a passing understanding of "system[s] of common law". The odd phraseology I put down to translation, but some of the specific statements are just wrong. I would say this is a wikipedia-level understanding of how systems of legal authority work.
For instance, in common law countries (ie those taking their traditions from the Brits) judges are not in fact obligated to follow rules of precedent. That's the sort of thing that a textbook might say, but the reality is that judges regularly bypass or ignore previous rulings on similar matters. Similarly, in Civil law jurisdictions (those that take traditions from the French) judges regularly rely on past rulings by respected judges. The process may not be formalized, but to say that judges no not regard previous decisions on similar matters is disingenuous. They write. They read each other;s work. They learn and share in much the same way as common law jurisdictions.
Speaking as someone working in common law jurisdictions, I'd say that the primary motivation for a judge to follow a previous ruling by a higher court is not some rule of precedent. Imho they are motivated by the likelihood of their ruling being turned on appeal. That gives them much more room in which to act. That is judicial discretion. That power is why we must respect judges and why they in turn must work to deserve our respect.
- Kell 10y ago> Similarly, in Civil law jurisdictions (those that take traditions from the French) judges regularly rely on past rulings by respected judges. You are indeed correct in most of your comment. But in France while it's true that judges read decisions by other judges, they will never ever quote another judge (except the ECHR). If for instance the Court de cassation (One of the French three (or four, or five, depends on how you count them) Supreme Courts) has said that "X has to be interpreted as Y". Lower judges will start using the sentence directly lifted from the Court de cassation decision "X should be interpreted as Y", but without quotation marks or any sort of attribution. It's a fiction that the judge came up with this interpretation by himself. Sometimes the judge will use some sort of caveat like "Il est constant que" ("It is always the case that") which is a way of saying that he is looking at precedent, without saying it explicitly. If a judge did quote directly the Court de cassation with attribution, his decision could be appealed and be overthrown by the Court de cassation itself. And if a judge disagrees with our Supreme Court, he will oftentimes without any hesitation "enter in resistance" (issuing decisions that go against the Court de cassation interpretation), the idea is that this is the way judges try to get the Supreme Court to change its opinion. This is also possible because he have more or less 90 judges in the Court de cassation, and turnover is quite high, so if a decision was only one or two votes in a direction (which no one knows because the votes are secret and the ratio of yays and nays also is secret), in a year, a judge or two at the court may change and the position could change. My conclusion would be that in France we do respect precedent most of the time... but only if the judge agree with it. Our judges have a natural inclination to ignore precedent. Meanwhile in Common law countries, there is a natural inclination ot respect it... but sometimes judges disagree. Caveat : In France, decisions by the Constitutional Council (the "Higher" Supreme Court... the Court of cassation would disagree on the "Higher" part) do create binding precedent... because those decision can change directly the text of the law. If the Council says that a sentence in a law is unconstitutional. Then the sentence is stripped out of the Code itself. Lower judges cannot therefore ignore it.