5 ms·
Is Gawker the root of the problem, or a symptom of a larger one? Perhaps the problem is that people will ingest and internalize information from anywhere, witho
by chatmasta 10y ago
Is Gawker the root of the problem, or a symptom of a larger one? Perhaps the problem is that people will ingest and internalize information from anywhere, without putting it through any sort of critical-thinking funnel. They let themselves become so convinced of something they read on gawker, that they actually try to convince other people it's true.
To put it another way: sure, good riddance to gawker. But what's to stop its successor? You may not like gawker, and your reasons may be valid, rational, or even altruistic. But you cannot dictate the will of its audience. What gives anyone, government or otherwise, the right to stop information at its source?
If you want to lessen the power of information, regardless of how "right" you think it is, the best way to invest your time or money is into teaching people how to think critically, and also why to think critically. Unfortunately it's quite difficult to teach on that subject when you're silencing an opinion from one side of your mouth, and preaching critical thinking from the other.
- analognoise 10y agoI think you can silence the opinion of fuckwits like Gawker without losing the ability to teach critical thinking. In fact, the silence might be better for studying.
- chatmasta 10y agoThe central tenet of critical thinking is to question everything. Why bother questioning anything, if you just saw your teacher shut down a source of information without giving you the opportunity to ask your own questions about its motives?
- analognoise 10y agoGawker is a "source of information" like chlamydia is to the common cold. Nothing is lost in the destruction of a source of bile about individuals and their private lives, it was zero-information content in the first place. To posit Gawker as a "worthwhile source" indicates a lack of critical thinking to begin with. Or, I reject one of your primary premises and think you're drawing a connection to "information being stifled" that is tenuous at best given the nature of the information and the behavior of Gawker as an organization. I also disagree with the implied slippery slope on the grounds that the content being "stifled" was bile about individuals in their personal lives and devoid of artistic, journalistic, or any other praise or protection. tldr: Fuck Gawker.
- jeffdavis 10y ago"What gives anyone, government or otherwise, the right to stop information at its source?" The overwhelming majority of the electorate who believe that information is powerful and that people should be held responsible for misusing it in certain limited situations.
- Vaskivo 10y agoI don't think anyone is silencing Gawker. Nobody is shutting it down. They did something illegal, so they must pay for it. The consequence of the lawsuit is a fine. Gawker shutting down may be a consequence of the fine, but it is not the lawsuit's objective.
- Goladus 10y ago> What gives anyone, government or otherwise, the right to stop information at its source? Defamatory falsehoods can sometimes be stopped by the government at its source. Protecting individual privacy is an increasingly serious issue in the age of mass communication and smartphones. Finally, the State routinely classifies information deemed sensitive to national security and foreign relations. (ps upvoted for presenting such a clear and reasonable argument for me to disagree with)