4 ms·
(Reposting here since I'm not sure which submission on new is going to "win") Sure does make this line in Thiel's Wikipedia page a bit awkward: "The Thiel Foun
by Analemma_ 10y ago
(Reposting here since I'm not sure which submission on new is going to "win")
Sure does make this line in Thiel's Wikipedia page a bit awkward: "The Thiel Foundation is also a supporter of the Committee to Protect Journalists, which promotes the right of journalists to report the news freely without fear of reprisal" Oh, but I'm sure this wasn't reprisal against Gawker (and specifically Valleywag, which was always extremely critical of libertarian VC techbros in general and Thiel in particular), he was just so moved by the plight of a pro wrestler suffering immensely from a leaked sex tape.
Look, I'll get out in front of people accusing me of bias and just say it: I've always hated Thiel. I hate his politics, the behavior of several of the companies he founded, and his smarmy "drop out of college!" advice. But even if you don't share my bile, you should be deeply disturbed by the fact that at least one Silicon Valley billionaire is talking about freedom and innovation with one side of his mouth, while using his money to try and destroy insufficiently sycophantic press outlets. We're moving ever-closer to a world where our industry leaders are not very distinguishable from 19th century robber barons (maybe not to you, but increasingly to the general public)
- FeepingCreature 10y agoLook, I sort of get where you're coming from but this wasn't exactly Snowden here.
- DKnoll 10y agoPlease do not equate publishing the sex tape of an unwitting victim with freedom of the press... or Gawker bloggers with journalists, for that matter. I don't agree or disagree with your statements about Thiel as I don't know enough about him to form an opinion, but Gawker seems to very clearly be in the wrong here. If Thiel in any way helped justice to be served here, for whatever motive, good on him.
- Analemma_ 10y ago> but Gawker seems to very clearly be in the wrong here That's not really relevant to my point. Even if Gawker was completely wrong to do what they did, why did Thiel pick that case to donate to? Plenty of people file lawsuits just as valid as Hulk Hogan's every day. Or why didn't he file an amicus curiae? This is clearly an attempt to destroy press he has a grudge against, which is alarming even if the specific lawsuit he picked was a valid one and the defendants were "Gawker bloggers". Look at the bigger picture.
- DKnoll 10y agoI am looking at the bigger picture, and what I see is that those who wield extraordinary power, whether it be financial, political or otherwise, rarely use it purely in defense of the 'greater good.' However, sometimes their pragmatism serves it by coincidence and I'm willing to celebrate when that happens.
- MrMullen 10y agoThe Hulk Hogan case must have hit a ratio of how much money would Thiel have put up vs probability of success and damage to Gawker. Having a sex tape made and leaked without permission is an easy win. And why would Thiel file an amicus curiae? He can pay for Hulk's lawyer and if the case is thrown out, Thiel does not get outed as Hulks sponsor. If he wins, he might get a portion of the money, which most likely will not happen, but most importantly he gets to crush an enemy.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoIt doesn't matter. You don't need logical certainty("If you violate the law, you will be punished"), just some statistical possibility("If you violate the law, there's a small chance you might be punished"). The small chance that someone somewhere might file a lawsuit against you could be enough to frighten future Gawkers, which protects even the small-time people who can't afford their own lawsuits. And if some Gawker executive says to himself, "Let's do a risk assessment on this person to see if he's likely to get outside support to fight back." Well, there's now the risk of leaving a paper trail demonstrating intent.
- Buge 10y agoYou're right that this lawsuit will have the positive effect of causing people to be less likely to publish sex tapes. But it will also have the negative effect of causing news companies to be constantly afraid of publish anything negative about a rich person, because that person might secretly fund lawsuits against them. Gawker is being sued for 2 other things besides this.
- vintermann 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- muglug 10y agoFrom a moral standpoint, I think they were wrong to do what they did. But, from a legal standpoint, many lawyers will tell you the ruling was a pretty terrible one. And when you look at the size of the judgement against Gawker ($140M) it's a bit of a stretch to say that justice was done.
- ManlyBread 10y agoThey have ignored a direct court order telling them to take down the article. You reap what you sow.
- tomc1985 10y agoI'm liking this argument that "gawker bloggers aren't journalists" so much that it seems to negate the contradiction of Thiel preaching press-freedom yet financing lawsuits against a press outlet. Of course, factoring out my biases, this is troubling. But who is foolish enough to think that this sort of thing doesn't happen in tech? Most of the big names got there through backstabbing
- dragonwriter 10y agoJournalists aren't a special class. Freedom of the press either belongs to everyone, or its a tool of tyranny and elite oppression rather than freedom. You can argue that what Gawker has done is outside the scope of press freedom, but not that there is some group of individuals to whom press freedom is unavailable.
- bronz 10y agoit might be awkward if gawker or valleywag staffed journalists.
- icelancer 10y agoYou understand Gawker outed Peter Thiel as gay about 9 years ago, right? What comes around, goes around.
- dingo_bat 10y agoA celebrity sex tape distributed without permission is not news.