6 ms·
Wait, what's the alternative to juries deciding whether or not someone is guilty of murder? Having a single judge do it? Seems to me that it's pretty damned im
by rconti 10y ago
Wait, what's the alternative to juries deciding whether or not someone is guilty of murder? Having a single judge do it?
Seems to me that it's pretty damned important to be sure that someone is guilty before you lock them up for life. But that just might be my american bias showing through.
- Retric 10y agoDo you think random Jury's are more skilled than a small panel of judges? The US uses Juries because as a check on government power. The whole point is jury nullification not factual accuracy.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The US uses Juries because as a check on government power. The whole point is jury nullification not fact accuracy. Nullification is not the whole point (but not insignificant), and factual accuracy is important -- but accountability to the citizenry at large (represented by a jury drawn from the citizenry, rather than professional government officers whose accountability to the public is distant at best) for that factual accuracy is just as important.
- Retric 10y agoNM
- dragonwriter 10y agoYou do not have a right to forego criminal jury trial in the US. Even if you want to waive jury trial, you may not be allowed to avoid it -- e.g., in the federal system, both the prosecution and court must also agree in order for a trial to a bench trial rather than a jury trial.
- walshemj 10y agoNope it descends from magna carta and UK common law
- Retric 10y agoTrial by jury showed up around then for land disputes. But, it was trial by ordeal that fell off not Judges in the 1200's. Also, we are talking ~500 years after the fact so there is a lot of back and forth involved.
- soneil 10y agoAlso interesting that when the Magna Carta was first penned, we had an entirely different idea of who a freeman's peers were.
- allendoerfer 10y agoThe alternative is to use several professional judges. In Germany for example a murderer is judged by 3 professional judges and 2 semi-professional juryman.
- DanBC 10y ago> Wait, what's the alternative to juries deciding whether or not someone is guilty of murder? Having a single judge do it? A panel of 3 judges. Or properly randomly selected juries. The US system, with a mix of weirdly selected judges and bizarre jury selection seems to be sub-optimal.