8 ms·
I bought the original Pebble on Kickstarter. I jumped on the Time on Kickstarter when it was announced. I changed my order to the Time Steel when it was made av
by mikestew 10y ago
I bought the original Pebble on Kickstarter. I jumped on the Time on Kickstarter when it was announced. I changed my order to the Time Steel when it was made available. I bought an original one for the wife, I bought her a Time as well.
And I'm going to wait on this one. If they're going to delve into the fitness category, I'll be looking at Garmins (of which I have several, albeit older ones with no smart watchy stuff) which are more durable (my $DEITY, does the Pebble get scratched up), go forever on a charge, and I'm willing to bet just plain do the job better because Garmin has been at it for a while.
Given the hurdles on iOS that Pebble can't seem to overcome (for which they are not entirely, if at all, to blame), I'll also wait and see what Apple has on tap. Apple has some shortcomings to eliminate, maybe they'll do that next round.
It's not because I'm unhappy with my Pebbles, I love my current Time Steel. But if I'm going to spend money on a watch that does what Pebble is currently advertising, my options open up to include established competitors in that space. I'm not willing to bet real money that Pebble can outdo those competitors right out of the gate. So I'll wait until it hits retail, see what it really does and what the experiences of others are. Maybe I'll get one, but it's not guaranteed like it was for previous versions.
- jdeibele 10y agoMy wife bought a Garmin Vivofit because it was water-proof and runs for months on a battery. I ended up buying the Vivofit 2 which has a better clasp, a backlight, and is supposed to sync automatically with my phone. When I wore a watch, I would take it off as soon as I could because it got in the way. I'm really happy with the Vivofit 2 - I haven't taken it off in (literally) months because it doesn't need to be charged and does just fine in the shower or swimming. I've been disappointed with the automatic syncing not working. Other than that, it's a great product. PS: my parents-in-law were given Fitbit devices with HR monitors which they had me set up for them. I'd like the HR monitoring but not at the cost of having a thicker device and having to deal with a proprietary charge connection (one end is standard USB).
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoHeart rate and GPS take significant amounts of power, unlike MEMS accelerometers, Bluetooth low-energy, and watch displays. A thin, non-rechargeable battery is a possibility for watches without these features. For watches with these features, it needs a rechargeable battery and a very thin water-proof connection to that battery.
- Brakenshire 10y agoThe Vivofit looks really good in the sense that you don't really need to sync it with a smartphone to get the relevant information, it's just there on your wrist. You want something that will tell you at a glance how many steps you've done, and whether you really should be moving around now. I don't think the long-term stuff is so effective. It's a shame it's a bit obtrusive though, I'd prefer if it had the same indicators, but looked like a watch.
- amargherio 10y agoNot sure if it's of any interest (or if you've already seen it), but Garmin does have something comparable in an analog watch form with their recent Vivomove tracker. https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/into-sports/health-fitness/vivomove-/prod532348.html https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/into-sports/health-fitness/v...
- Brakenshire 10y agoI hadn't seen that, thanks!
- nbb 10y ago> I haven't taken it off in (literally) months Your wrist must smell great.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoProbably, if he showers regularly and doesn't wear the device to tight. :P. Waterproof is great.
- spoinkaroo 10y agoI have a garmin forerunner 235 which is perfect for running, and functions as my everyday smartwatch with all day heartrate monitoring and basic notifications from my iphone. Do you still wear your pebbles?
- mikestew 10y agoDo you still wear your pebbles? Wearing it as I type right now. But that's because all of my Garmin watches (610 and 910, IIRC) are old enough to not have the smart watch stuff. If I had a 920, I'd ditch the Pebble. I just can't yet justify the $400 simply to aggregate my wrist-worn devices.
- marricks 10y agoWhat's the battery life like? I heard it's not quite as good as reported and honestly it's a bit hard to believe a device without an e-ink display would fair as well.
- xirdstl 10y agoI'd guess it depends a lot on how much you use the GPS. I've had mine for about six weeks, and I charge it once per week.
- mjlee 10y agoIt's decent, but using it in outdoor running mode (the only exercise mode I've tried) depletes the battery quite fast. I enable the optional GLONASS, I'm not sure how much effect that has. Big handfuls, you'll get about 8 days out of it, less a day for every 30 minutes of running. Garmin have released a few firmware updates for the watch which may account for the difference between my findings and those of early adopters.
- DiabloD3 10y agoGLONASS on most devices that speak both is enabled only when GPS signal quality is poor enough, and it just uses it to improve the accuracy of your position. It uses more battery life, but in a lot of cases it's the difference between accurate positioning and not. So, yeah, I'd try doing same day runs on clear days, with GLONASS on and off, and compare drain rate.
- bad_user 10y ago> Given the hurdles on iOS that Pebble can't seem to overcome (for which they are not entirely, if at all, to blame) That says more about iOS than about Pebble. Get an Android. The experience is much better.
- untog 10y agoBut that requires changing your $600 piece of hardware in order to better serve your $200 one - let alone the other disruption changing platforms would bring. Don't get me wrong, Android is the clear answer here but it's still difficult to justify switching. It would be great if Apple just opened up their smartwatch functionality, but alas...
- mikestew 10y agoGet an Android. The experience is much better. Believe it or not, I actually went that route. My Pebble experience was better, but there's a reason I'm back on iOS. In retrospect, it was incredibly stupid to change my mobile OS just to support a watch. Shoulda just bought a different watch.
- bad_user 10y agoThe only watch iOS gets along with is Apple's Watch. And that's the point. It locks you into Apple's ecosystem, being defective by design.
- kbd 10y agoIf you already have a Time Steel, you should wait on this one. Your watch is less than a year old and the new ones are an evolutionary upgrade.
- sundvor 10y agoTrue, yet as someone who went from the Steel to the Time Steel (and had his Steel stolen), the display readability was a big downgrade;the old Steel was simply far easier to read. The new Time 2 fixes this, from what I can see, in addition to making the display bigger (two sides of the same coin, but still worth the distinction). Adding the HRM feature, and the fact that I love everything else about my Time Steel (the readability being the exception), I buddied up for a 2x order. It's worth mentioning that the Pebble team have been doing some fantastic work on the OS on the past few months; the continuous updates are great. Also I still get 9+ days from each charge with my always on display; nothing else in the smart watch market comes close.
- nl 10y agoI think Garmin is way underrated as a (hardware) technology company. Given that they were a GPS company that people wrote off as being irrelevant in the age of smartphones and Google Maps they have done a great job carving out multiple niches in sports devices (and that ignores their "Smart Glass" airplane business). I have 2 Edge cycling computers and a Garmin running watch and love them all. The Edge 520 is the type of device that I'd see the specs of and expect to be a half-implemented heap of junk (connects to my phone to receive notifications while I ride? Automatically uploads rides when I finish them? This will never work). And yet it really is rather good.
- pantulis 10y agoIMO it's not that Garmin's hardware is that great, it's that Garmin always got software right, in comparison with rivals like TomTom.
- aerique 10y agoMaybe in the US. In Europe I found their offerings underwhelming.
- Matthias247 10y agoUnfortunately I can't second that. I own an Edge cycling computer with which I'm happy in general, but which already had multiple severe bugs (like simply displaying "memory full" and not resetting itself in a loop) which required either hard resets or even reflashing the firmware to recover. Things which the average consumer might not be able to do.
- hauget 10y ago"I think Garmin is way underrated as a (hardware) technology company." Can't agree more! I just wish they had a decent SDK so we could have apps on Garmin devices just like Pebble OS.
- infecto 10y agoAgreed. I am glad they conceded that people use Strava. If I am going to upload and track results somewhere I would rather use Strava then their implementation.