3 ms·
He should have cited the woman who spilled hot coffee on her. The legal precedent being set by the court was "if it's hot enough to hurt someone label it that
by dsfyu404ed 10y ago
He should have cited the woman who spilled hot coffee on her. The legal precedent being set by the court was "if it's hot enough to hurt someone label it that way" and to do that they had to award punitive (you screwed up and we're punishing you) damages. If they just ordered the company to pay based on medical costs it would have basically said "this is your fault and you should pay for her medical care" but by awarding punitive damages the court was trying (and succeeded) to send a message about what is and is not acceptable.
- kbenson 10y agoAre you referring to the McDonalds hot coffee incident? That one is generally more interesting[1] than widely known or believed. The details may not change your opinion on whether the outcome was warranted, but they may change whether you think the case itself was worth having (from the details, I don't think it was frivolous). > by awarding punitive damages the court was trying (and succeeded) to send a message about what is and is not acceptable. The jury decides whether the lawsuit is warranted and how much to award. The court can alter this to try to make a statement (and in the case I referenced, the court reduced damages in each judgement). 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restaurants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restau...
- lavezzi 10y agoThat coffee wasn't just hot, it was well beyond expected temperature and gave her third degree burns as a result. "Liebeck sought to settle with McDonald's for $20,000 to cover her actual and anticipated expenses. Her past medical expenses were $10,500; her anticipated future medical expenses were approximately $2,500; and her daughter's loss of income was approximately $5,000 for a total of approximately $18,000. Instead, the company offered only $800. When McDonald's refused to raise its offer, Liebeck retained Texas attorney Reed Morgan. Morgan filed suit in New Mexico District Court accusing McDonald's of "gross negligence" for selling coffee that was "unreasonably dangerous" and "defectively manufactured". McDonald's refused Morgan's offer to settle for $90,000. Morgan offered to settle for $300,000, and a mediator suggested $225,000 just before trial, but McDonald's refused these final pre-trial attempts to settle."
- ballooney 10y agoI'd expect it to be up to 100 celcius at sea level pressure, because it had just been boiled. If it's hotter than that it wouldn't be a liquid. How can less-than-boiling be 'well beyond' the expected temperature of just-made tea or coffee? Your accusation is totally absurd. Maybe I'm just being too European.
- CydeWeys 10y agoYou are being too European. Not serving scalding-hot coffee is a very reasonable safety precaution. Not only can it cause third-degree burns, but it can cause severe damage to the inside of your mouth. Note that McDonalds was heating up its coffee to be higher a higher temperature than it would be straight from brewing (during which a lot of heat energy is lost). Every coffee you've ever had in your life was a lower temperature than what McDonald's was serving up. They were serving super-heated coffee that is hotter and thus more dangerous than what you would make at home. A typical temperature for coffee is 75C -- that's the temperature it'll come out as from your standard automatic drip coffee maker. McDonald's was serving it at 95C, which required serious post-brewing heating to achieve. They admitted that this was wrong and stopped doing it, and to really drive that point home, no one else serves coffee that dangerously hot. You could burn a layer off your tongue in one ill-conceived first sip. The only reason you think this isn't a big deal is because you haven't been exposed to it.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> Every coffee you've ever had in your life was a lower temperature than what McDonald's was serving up. This is a pretty sketchy assertion. Instant coffee is generally made from water you just boiled yourself.
- rrdharan 10y agoAnd yet it's true. https://www.caoc.org/?pg=facts https://www.caoc.org/?pg=facts "McDonald’s operations manual required the franchisee to hold its coffee at 180 to 190 degrees Fahrenheit. Coffee at that temperature, if spilled, causes third-degree burns in three to seven seconds." I also highly recommend watching this movie which was a very interesting look at the erosion of consumer rights driven by a coordinate corporate PR campaign/agenda: http://www.hotcoffeethemovie.com/Default.asp http://www.hotcoffeethemovie.com/Default.asp