4 ms·
And if you turn off automatic updates, you become the biggest threat to your machine's security. What is a bigger threat to your machine's security than not be
by Silhouette 10y ago
And if you turn off automatic updates, you become the biggest threat to your machine's security.
What is a bigger threat to your machine's security than not being able to use it at all?
Our standard policy for a long time was not to auto-install any Windows updates, and just to manually install security ones each month.
Our standard policy today is not to install any update, no matter what Microsoft labels it with, unless we've identified a specific need for it. We do a quick pass down the usual sources after patch day and install any security updates that are potentially relevant and haven't been causing problems.
Given that Windows 7 is a relatively mature OS today and obviously we also have a variety of other security measures in place, we consider the risk of overlooking a minor security fix that actually matters to be much, much lower than the risk of 2016's Microsoft breaking something by pushing an update we didn't want.
If you don't like Windows 10, the answer isn't "run Windows 7 forever"
Yes. Yes, it is, at least for now. An operating system is just a tool you use to get work done. Windows 7 works just fine on our hardware, and it runs the software we need. If it ain't broke, don't let anyone break it, and spend your time on actually useful things.
We're essentially betting that either Nadella and co will have got the boot before Windows 7 support ends and a desperate Microsoft will have significantly reversed course and offered a viable alternative by that time, or someone else will have stepped up to offer serious business software on another platform that we can migrate to by then.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>Windows 7 works just fine on our hardware, and it runs the software we need. If it ain't broke, don't let anyone break it, and spend your time on actually useful things. The problem is that it is broken, in a way: it has security vulnerabilities, just like any OS, and if it's connected to the internet has to be patched to protect it. A deprecated OS is not going to get those security updates. Win7 won't be supported forever. Of course, if your Win7 machine is not networked, then this doesn't apply to you and you can run it forever, just like some industrial machines still run MS-DOS. >We're essentially betting that either Nadella and co will have got the boot before Windows 7 support ends and a desperate Microsoft will have significantly reversed course and offered a viable alternative by that time, or someone else will have stepped up to offer serious business software on another platform that we can migrate to by then. Why would Nadella get the boot? Look at their stock price since he's taken over: the company is doing great, much better than under Ballmer. All these actions are good and correct: they make the company more money. Customers may not like them, but too bad. Why should MS care about what its customers want? It's not like they're going to abandon MS and Windows any time soon, so MS is right to screw them over for more profit.
- Silhouette 10y agoA deprecated OS is not going to get those security updates. Win7 won't be supported forever. But Windows 7 isn't deprecated. Microsoft have committed to supporting it until 2020, and their customers will expect them to honour that commitment. That is four years away. In a fast-paced industry like IT, the entire landscape could be different by then. Why would Nadella get the boot? Look at their stock price since he's taken over: the company is doing great, much better than under Ballmer. You and I seem to be looking at very different stock charts. In the one I'm looking at[1], MSFT had pretty respectable growth through 2013-2014 when they were doing a lot of talking about Windows 10 and the new vision, but their stock price looks much less happy since around the start of 2015 as the reality became known. In a few months, if Windows 10 is still far less established than Windows 7 and it becomes undeniable that the campaign to get everyone onto Windows 10 didn't succeed even with literally giving it away and underhand tricks like the one we're talking about, executives like Nadella and Myerson are going to be under a lot of pressure to present a more realistic vision of what happens next and to turn the stock price back to a steady pattern of growth or their positions are going to be under threat. [1] https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=MSFT#symbol=MSFT https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=MSFT#symbol=MSFT Why should MS care about what its customers want? It's not like they're going to abandon MS and Windows any time soon Perhaps not. I suspect they've probably got until about 14 January 2020 before things get really bad. But by that time, anything could have happened. Apple could have started competing more aggressively for desktop/laptop/server markets. Less and less business software could be locally hosted, making a range of different devices that can access web apps more attractive. In more than three years, even a major new player entering the market or a shift in strategy from some other tech giant isn't out of the question. Screwing your customers for profit looks good at the next quarterly earnings call, but not so much two years or five years down the line when your customers and competitors have had time to react.
- ryanl0l 10y ago>What is a bigger threat to your machine's security than not being able to use it at all? What kind of a threat is that? Is your computer worth more than the contents of your bank account?
- Silhouette 10y agoAnything that really does compromise my bank account has got through a lot more than Windows' security, and almost certainly entered my system through a vulnerability that Windows updates wouldn't have fixed anyway. Also, it's not one computer I'm worried about so much as the cost per day of downtime for everyone in my company if a Windows update were to break all our general use PCs.
- ryanl0l 10y agoPerhaps you should be running the LTS version then?
- Silhouette 10y agoWhat LTS version? If you mean LTSB for Windows 10, that's only available with Enterprise, which means it's not an option for the kind of power users or small businesses who would have used Pro with 7 or 8.x. In any case, the idea that you should have to jump through all the hoops involved in running Windows Enterprise just to maintain a reasonable degree of control over your own computers is patently absurd, and like many others, I and my businesses will treat it with the contempt it deserves.
- ryanlol 10y agoIf you're worried about the cost per day of downtime, you should certainly consider investing in Enterprise. >In any case, the idea that you should have to jump through all the hoops involved in running Windows Enterprise just to maintain a reasonable degree of control over your own computers is patently absurd, and like many others, I and my businesses will treat it with the contempt it deserves. Well, I certainly hope you've got a very competent security team to assess and control the risks caused by avoiding updates.