4 ms·
Can we just get rid of the TSA? Current estimates are that hundreds of people die each year in car accidents because they chose to drive rather than deal with
by btilly 10y ago
Can we just get rid of the TSA?
Current estimates are that hundreds of people die each year in car accidents because they chose to drive rather than deal with TSA lines. This means that every few years the TSA manages to inflict more casualties than 9/11 did. In addition to inconvenience, economic inefficiency, and a demonstrably ineffective screening process that weapons can easily get through. (As many have shown.)
Security theater is a dangerously bad idea no matter how you look at it. Can we do something saner?
- exacube 10y agohow do they estimate this stuff?
- ThomPete 10y agoPost/pre 9-11 I think
- btilly 10y agoYou estimate from survey data how many more people are taking several hundred mile road trips instead of flying, then apply known traffic fatality statistics how many wound up dead from that decision. See https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/09/excess_automobi.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/09/excess_automo... for a reference.
- marze 10y agoThis is naive. Why would you assume the same number of successful attacks on air travel would occur without the security? You can't argue that the current system hasn't done well, it has performed fantastically, based on the number of successful attacks within the US. That said, they need a lot more screeners, and to be much more polite. And get rid of incompetent management.
- chickenbane 10y agoI think it's a safe assumption, because if the TSA actually found a terrorist through its screening process they would parade this achievement in front of every news organization it could. On the other hand, there have been numerous documented cases where people have deliberately snuck banned items through the TSA security checks. Of course, you had to qualify statement that the TSA "has performed fantastically" with the number of _successful_ attacks. There have been terrorists that have attempted attacks, such as the underwear bomber and the shoe bomber, but those were all stopped by the passengers. To me, this should have warranted a congratulations to our fellow citizens for being vigilant - and maybe even a relaxation of some of the rules. As you know, the opposite occurred, and now we have to take our shoes off and can only take small amounts of liquid. Who's being naive?
- laxatives 10y agoBy that logic, I've done a fantastic job getting the sun to rise every morning. Where is my taxpayer money?
- basseq 10y agoHow many attacks were stopped by the TSA? Directly: 0. Hell, they're 0/2 on known attempts (the Shoe Bomber in 2001 and Northwest Airlines Flight 253 in 2009), both thwarted instead by passengers and crew. Indirectly? (E.g., how many attacks weren't planned because of the TSA that would have been planned and executed otherwise?) Very hard to say. Have law enforcement officials seen an uptick in other terror channels that would indicate terrorist plots are avoiding air travel? Are any would-be terrorists abandoning their terror plans altogether because of the TSA? Surely not. So all the TSA is doing is shifting attacks from air travel to other channels. That's a net zero. And finally, at what cost?
- drdeca 10y agoShifting attacks from one method to another is not necessarily useless. If what would have been the most effective method is reduced in its effectiveness, and as a result, another less effective method becomes the most effective one, and the used one, that reduces the effectiveness of attacks. That wording was convoluted. What I mean is, if they would have done plane attacks because of plane attacks working best for them, then making plane attacks not work as well, and therefore making them shift to something else, means that whatever they are doing for attacks wouldn't work as well for attacks as the plane attacks would have, which is a benefit. That's not to say that the TSA is beneficial, or that it does really reduce the effectiveness of adversaries. I'm just saying that, assuming that it is true that adversaries shift their attacks from air travel to other methods as a result of the TSA , that would suggest that adversaries are restricted by the TSA , and made somewhat less effective (assuming that adversaries weren't overestimating the effectiveness of air travel attacks originally).
- basseq 10y agoFair point. I think we're both struggling with how to quantify the value of deterrence, and how to model (mentally or otherwise) things like "effectiveness shifting". It's hard! But I think we're notoriously bad as human being and a populace at having real conversations about cost-benefit analysis.
- marze 10y ago
- thisargisARGH23 10y agoHow many attacks were there pre-9/11 (and thus TSA)? We went quite a good long while without it and things were fine. This is fear-mongering bullshit, used to line pockets of politicians and lobbyists, pure and simple. I don't see how anyone can claim otherwise when the guy in charge of "Homeland Security" (a name that sounds a bit too much like things you'd read about in fascist countries like the former USSR or one of the Axis powers, but I'm getting off script) at the time starts installing x-ray scanners and... OH LOOK AT THAT he has a huge ownership stake in the company that makes them. And really the best way to "get rid of incompetent management" would be to shut it down. Otherwise it'll just be a revolving door of incompetent managers.
- coldpie 10y agoI've got this tiger repelling rock to sell you. Only $2B per year!
- nas 10y agoAdd up the hours spent by people waiting in security lines and divide by the number of hours in an average life. How many person lives have been wasted by this bullshit?
- cynoclast 10y agoLet's not forget that every single warrantless search is a violation of the 4th amendment. Every. Single. One. Yet we let them do this, because they're holding our ability to move freely about the country hostage.
- cheald 10y ago> Current estimates are that hundreds of people die each year in car accidents because they chose to drive rather than deal with TSA lines. This means that every few years the TSA manages to inflict more casualties than 9/11 did. I don't have a link, but at one point, someone did the math on the backscatter machines (the ones that emitted ionizing radiation, which have since been replaced) and the number of people going through them and concluded that statistically, the TSA will kill more people through scanner-induced cancer than the hijackers did on 9/11.
- CaptSpify 10y agoDo we actually have numbers on this? Last I heard, the scanners were never externally audited, so we have no idea how much radiation they are using
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 10y agoI believe those were the old machines (the ones made by Michael Chertoff's company), which are no longer in use. I have heard they might be at smaller airports, but I haven't seen them in a long time.
- sehutson 10y agoNo tally should forget the effective lives and productivity lost because people now have to get to the airport so early, either. Millions of people surrendering millions of extra hours every day = entire lifespans wasted because you have to get there so early to make sure the TSA doesn't cause you to miss your flight.