3 ms·
Structuring laws are highly controversial and have caused huge amounts of pain for innocent people who were just legitimately trying to reduce their paperwork b
by mike_hearn 10y ago
Structuring laws are highly controversial and have caused huge amounts of pain for innocent people who were just legitimately trying to reduce their paperwork burden. They're bad laws.
- Bartweiss 10y agoYeah, I don't mean to endorse them, especially not as-written. Any time you make laws like "it is illegal to circumvent the law" you're inviting exponential amounts of red tape. Add that to laws that were already high-burden on small businesses, and it's a recipe for real trouble (made even worse by the fact that a remarkable amount of banking still isn't digital). I know that the specific case I mentioned has been fairly useful in fighting money laundering and large-scale drug-dealing, though. There's something to be said for making it hard to move large amounts of money through banks without being observed, but as always there's no good way to do that without interfering with legitimate commerce.
- omni 10y agoDo you have any other examples which you think are bad? The $19,999 example seems pretty reasonable to me.
- wl 10y agoThe example he gives is of someone clearly trying to evade the reporting requirements. People get caught up in these laws even when they don't intend to avoid them by virtue of doing business in cash with daily deposits just under the reporting limit[1]. [1] http://reason.com/blog/2016/02/04/after-finally-returning-the-money-they-s http://reason.com/blog/2016/02/04/after-finally-returning-th...
- gnopgnip 10y agoThe laws only apply to cash deposits, not money orders, checks, or any electronic transfers. What is a better alternative to stop money laundering?
- toast0 10y agoReduce the impact of the reporting. Many of the stories I read had a component of "big weekly deposits took a long time because someone would have to fill out a report" or "banks closed my account because they didn't want to fill out the reports" which lead people to do more frequent deposits or split their banking between multiple banks or pay expenses in cash. I don't think the amount triggering reporting is linked to inflation either. I don't know what's on the form, but of you fill out once a week, there should be a way to be quick about it.