9 ms·
For example, as an Irish company, you can open a subsidiary in France to do business in France. The whole point of the EU single market is that you do not have
by mike_hearn 10y ago
For example, as an Irish company, you can open a subsidiary in France to do business in France.
The whole point of the EU single market is that you do not have to do that. You can set up shop in Ireland and sell to the French market until the cows come home. You only owe Irish taxes (modulo the recent completely crazy VAT changes).
Laws that say "forget the law, anything we think is unreasonable is illegal" are a growing problem in Europe. It makes the EU look like fools to the rest of the world when something as basic as the rule of law becomes flaky and unpredictable. France is not just causing itself problems with this kind of action, their greed will create a bad impression of the whole of the EU.
- tomp 10y ago> "forget the law, anything we think is unreasonable is illegal" That's basically how all Anglo-Saxon (including the US) law, i.e. case law, looks like.
- ctrlalt_g 10y agoMy moment of epiphany and shock in law school was on realizing that right and wrong don't exist. As my professor used to say, "It's all theater."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- MengerSponge 10y agoIt's both a little more subtle than that and exactly that simple. You can't legislate "right and wrong" (although we try), but that doesn't mean they can't be defined by and imposed by a society. (the sanctions will generally be different from what the state could impose) For the amount of love Hayek gets in these circles, I'm surprised there isn't more focus on Law, Legislation and Liberty
- eropple 10y agoYup. A lot of people, not limited but often expressed in the tech rule, seem to think that laws are strict-matching constructs. But laws are intended to be fuzzily matched, and the judiciary exists to do that fuzzy matching.
- mike_hearn 10y agoNot exactly. The degree to which judges should be allowed to creatively interpret laws is a controversial issue that has long split down left/right lines. I mean that's basically the entire cause of the split in the Supreme Court between strict literalists and those who believe in a living constitution. Obviously judges have to apply some degree of common sense because English is inherently vague, but the amount that they do it can still trigger political bun fights.
- evgen 10y agoNot exactly. You have to look no further than the right's cherished paragon of literalism Antonin Scalia to see a judge contorting himself into knots to try to present his interpretive opinion on the law and meaning of the text as though it was clearly spelled out in either. There are no literalists, especially when their pet political ideals are threatened in some way. If you think the split is literalist/interpretive then you have not been paying attention.
- btilly 10y agoTo be fair, it is harder for us to notice that interpretations are creative when they lead to the conclusions that we thought were obvious. Take, for instance, the establishment in Heller of the right to bear arms as an individual right. Most conservatives believed that to be the case all along, and think it is clear from the wording. However liberal observers were more likely to notice that this interpretation had not appeared in 2 centuries of jurisprudence, and societies of professional historians had long reached the opposite conclusion about original intent. For another, look at Citizens United which established that corporations had a right to free speech, and therefore could not be restricted from spending on political speech. Conservatives saw this as a straightforward issue of, "I have no actual freedom of speech if I cannot spend money to broadcast it." Liberals noted that this overturned several previous precedents, and the Constitution had never intended corporations to be considered people. In these and other cases, conservatives don't recognize the creativity of interpretation because the result seems natural and right to them. Liberals do notice. The same is true going the other way. But liberals do not object to noticing that they have been creative, so are less likely to fail to notice when they have been.
- rayiner 10y agoBut "unreasonable" means something closer to its literal meaning in U.S. law. It means a conclusion that a rational person would not reach. So "unreasonable" is a pretty strong safeguard. It's hard to reach an "unreasonable" conclusion about your legal obligations by accident. In the criminal context, we also have the rule of leniety, which holds that ambiguities in criminal laws are resolved in favor of the defendant. It's unusual to encounter a situation where the law is clear but someone is punished based on vague case law interpretation of the law. I rarely see a situation where I think "the Court just botched interpreting this statute." Almost always, it's "Congress or the agency botched writing this statute or regulation." And in a civil system it's much harder for the courts to fix such problems. We do have a problem with laws that are themselves unclear, but the Supreme Court has done some weed cleaning in that area. For example, Jeffrey Skilling got a reduced sentence because the Supreme Court found that the honest services fraud statute was unconstitutionally vague unless limited to strict "bribery and kickbacks" theory. In the area of fraud on the government, courts have held that defendants can only be punished for making incorrect statements to the government (for e.g. Medicaire claims) if the falsity of their statements is based on an unreasonable and not merely incorrect interpretation of the underlying regulations. We also generally have a strong separation between civil suits and criminal suits. People lament that not enough people go to prison in the white collar world, but in my opinion it's a good thing we're not sending people to prison for misunderstanding Treasury or Fed regulations.
- tomp 10y ago> It means a conclusion that a rational person would not reach. So "unreasonable" is a pretty strong safeguard. This is all nice in theory, but in practice, it's happened multiple times that the (Supreme Court's) interpretation of the same law has changed. Granted, this has happened over decades (or even generations), but this implies that (1) either the definition of what is "reasonable" has changed (I find this unlikely, or else the concept itself has little sense), or (2) there is more wiggle room when interpreting laws...
- jdmichal 10y agoJudges are not infallible, and they are not isolated from the zeitgeist of their time. See Schenck v. United States, where the original ruling was overly broad and later refined. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States#Subsequent_jurisprudence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States#Subse...
- bambax 10y agoYou don't have to but you can; and apparently it's good politics too. Google made a big deal of its new office space in the center of Paris when they opened two years ago. Edit: of course, the right for an Irish company to do business anywhere in Europe is also one that can be abused. Separate companies are not needed for rights to be abused and offices to be raided.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoCan only French companies open offices in the centre of Paris? Couldn't an Irish company rent office space just as easily?
- eloisant 10y agoAn Irish company could probably rent office space, but to have employees under a French contract you need a French company. Not only workers hired in France wouldn't want an Irish contract, but you can only have "posted workers" for a temporary period. http://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=471&langId=en http://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=471&langId=en
- DrJokepu 10y agoActually, an EU company can employ workers in other EU member states without local subsidiaries, but will need to register with the government of the country where the employment will take place; the actual process varies by member state, e.g. in the UK the employer would have to register with HMRC and set up PAYE.
- raverbashing 10y agoHummm not really. Or better saying, as much as the US look like with some judicial decisions of theirs Like password vs fingerprint
- allendoerfer 10y ago>Laws that say "forget the law, anything we think is unreasonable is illegal" are a growing problem in Europe. It makes the EU look like fools Not trying to start a flamewar here, but the common German/European perspective on the US legal system consists of corporations owning it (because of huge costs), consumers abusing it ("cat in microwave/washing machine/toaster", unreasonable compensations, class action lawsuits) and agencies outright ignoring it. Edit: Remembered one more: Juries deciding whether murderers are guilty or not. Simply unthinkable over here. Ironically the horror of this scenario is fuelled by the US/Hollywood itself. Edit 2: War on drugs / world's highest prison population / racial profiling / death sentence. The longer I think about it, the worse it gets. I think I made my point. The image is really, really bad.
- Nadya 10y ago>cat in microwave How oddly specific....were you referencing this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMH8Tof69SE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMH8Tof69SE I do agree the U.S has a problem with rather frivulious lawsuits over "not following the letter of the law" or "wasn't mentioned in the safety manual to not do this thing that should have been common sense". It seems when people think "American legal system" things like this come to mind: http://i.imgur.com/D7aP2bT.png http://i.imgur.com/D7aP2bT.png If I remember correctly though, the silliness of the above is actually due to a law about packaging must contain allergen information for certain common allergies. This means even peanuts must contain the label in order to comply with the law. Rather than list exceptions and complicate the law, it applies broadly to everything. IANAL, I may not be remembering this fact 100% correctly.
- arcticfox 10y agoThe peanuts picture is funny, but it's 100% the simple. logical, and safe way to do it.
- Nadya 10y agoI was defending it ;) I find it absolutely hilarious whenever I see it - but simple laws with "silly consequences" are better than complex laws that are difficult to follow, let alone enforce. Not to mention having to come up with and define products that would fit into the exceptions list, and investigating whether or not the product actually - blah blah blah. Bunch of overhead. Better use of tax payer money to say "if it contains one of these allergens, say so on the packaging" and be done with it. No questions asked and it doesn't complicate the law to avoid saying something silly like "peanuts may contain peanuts".
- ihsw 10y ago> Laws that say "forget the law, anything we think is unreasonable is illegal" are a growing problem in Europe. This has been occurring in European law since time immemorial -- giving the judicial branch maximum discretion is viewed as democratizing. It is hardly growing rather than being slowly exposed.
- metaphorm 10y ago> Laws that say "forget the law, anything we think is unreasonable is illegal" are a growing problem in Europe. I think you have an unsophisticated view of legal systems. Law consists of more than just what is written into the text of legislation. It is a historical practice done by people working in courts and in law enforcement. It interacts with the people as they serve on juries. Law is a living thing bound in tradition and culture.
- kenko 10y agoThe above scenario was an example illustrating the concept of abuse de droit. No need to get hung up ont he precise specifics. > Laws that say "forget the law, anything we think is unreasonable is illegal" Don't look up Scotland's declaratory power if this bothers you. It strikes me as totally reasonable.
- Shivetya 10y agoUnlike the US, countries in the EU do not appear to be able to compete by offering favorable conditions to corporations and this especially concerns taxes. which is a big design fault that hampers the EU especially as nations facing debt problems will use it to shore their finances up which keeps up and coming countries from doing that, being up and coming.
- rurban 10y agoUnfortunately this is not true anymore. With the raise of US/UK style neoliberalism various states like Luxembourg, Slovakia, Lichtenstein, Germany, Austria, Ireland ... try to outcompete each other in offering less taxes, less union influence, less labor costs for more jobs and companies regularly blackmail the EU states for more favorable conditions. E.g. Germany can only hold its current EU stronghold by outcompeting France with much lower labor costs.