4 ms·
Exactly. Here in the Netherlands people grow tired of the ever growing lust for EU power and the ever increasing amount of EU laws and rules. When we do get a
by teekert 10y ago
Exactly.
Here in the Netherlands people grow tired of the ever growing lust for EU power and the ever increasing amount of EU laws and rules. When we do get a chance to speak out like in the recent referendum about associating with the Ukraine, people's "No" vote is just ignored (like the vote about the EU constitution was ignored). Most people I know don't like the sanctions against Russia because they impact our economy, they don't like doing business with Erdogan, they don't like TTIP. But people are ignored by the politicians in the middle. So people start voting for less traditional, more polarized right or left (here that would be Geert Wilders, very anti EU) and Partij voor de Dieren (Party for the Animals (oh yes we have that), who are very anti TTIP, bio-industry and globalization.) It just feels like those lefties and righties are better at listening to us and the middle parties are listining to the every growing group of bureaucrats from the EU. Maybe because the "extreme" left and right have much less affiliations and friends in the EU and in large corporations.
To me, the EU adds a lot of politicians who are not chosen democratically, and are thus beyond the reach of normal citizens. They are however nicely within the reach of lobbyists.
- niccolop 10y agoDemagogues will always find fertile ground when bashing the EU. It's been a long time since anyone has come out and defended it in a positivist way e.g. guarantor of democracy, free movement of labor, etc. In the current British debate leading up to the referendum, major campaigners in the 'Stay In' campaign rarely defend the EU, and rather take the line that the UK should stay in the EU despite all it's problems. What was the turnout at the referendum in the Netherlands?
- jules 10y agoHow is the EU a guarantor of democracy? Our national governments are far more democratic than the EU. Free movement of labour isn't necessarily something that's good for working people, particularly at the lower end of the income distribution, as that means competition from people who are willing to work for much lower wages.
- realityking 10y agoYou know that goes both ways? You're also free to move to a different country where you get paid better. Now you might not want to do that, because you want your kinds to grow up in $country or some other valid reason but it's wrong to paint this as something singularly bad for the working class.
- jules 10y agoRealistically, how does the ability to move to Poland help the person working in a local car repair shop? Is that hypothetical worth the risk of getting fired in favour of a cheaper worker? What about the job prospects of his/her kids? Free movement of labour helps the owner of the repair shop, not so much the workers.
- realityking 10y agoGo work in a car repair shop in France if they pay better, that's how you profit. Thousands of Polish people moved to the UK and took jobs there.
- jules 10y agoImagine a conversation between a pro-EU politician and this car mechanic. P: Vote for me! Free movement of labour is great. C: Why? Then I will face competition from people who are willing to work for very low wages, and so will my kids. P: Yea, but then you can move to France with your family! C: Ok but I don't want to move to France. I don't speak the language. My friends and family are here. My kids go to school here. And why would wages be better in France, anyway? I'll face the same competition there. Can you see why this may not be very convincing? On the other hand, imagine a conversation with the owner of the shop: P: Vote for me! Free movement of labour is great. O: Indeed, I'll be able to hire cheaper workers.
- realityking 10y agoAt this point your appealing to emotion, not reason. Even if individual car repair man is not leaving for France, if many leave to take better paying jobs in France supply is lowering in his home country, which should lead to higher prices (or lower unemployment) I think the better counter argument is brain drain, it's certainly not advantageous for a country if many of its most skilled citizens leave. Personally, I think it's just wrong to build berries of any sort for your citizens to leave the country.
- varjag 10y ago32.3%
- vidarh 10y agoPart of the problem is that a lot of the reasons that those who are most pro-EU have for wanting to stay are at the same time a bit icky. E.g. the EU has for a long time acted as a better guarantor for human rights in the UK than the UK parliaments. But going out and saying people should vote to remain in the EU because it ensures EU law will overrule the elected UK governments on human rights isn't going to help win a majority to remain. It's a bad situation to be in where you have to choose between more devolved power and protection of human rights. Similarly, free movement of labor isn't big selling point to those who aren't already convinced. Those who aren't already convinced aren't seeing this as an opportunity for them to go out and work elsewhere in Europe, but as an opportunity for people from poorer parts of Europe to come to the UK and take their jobs.
- Redoubts 10y ago> E.g. the EU has for a long time acted as a better guarantor for human rights in the UK than the UK parliaments. Genuinely curious, when has this come up in the recent past?
- danmaz74 10y agoThe EU should actually be more democratic, giving more direct power to the people, but have you ever wondered why it isn't? The main reason is that national governments WANT the "government" of the EU (the Commission) to be an intergovernmental entity, IE a bureaucracy they can control, and not a government that responds directly to the people of Europe. The solution should be pretty obvious: let the people of the EU choose the commission directly with their vote.