3 ms·

Question: usually we create 2D models of sw: powerpoint, visio, a sketch on the whiteboard. Has anyone tried lego or some other 3D construction set? Did it wor

by Pamar 10y ago

Question: usually we create 2D models of sw: powerpoint, visio, a sketch on the whiteboard. Has anyone tried lego or some other 3D construction set? Did it work? Is there anything particularly suitable to build "architecture"?

andrei_says_ 10y ago
I was wondering about the same. I'm also ok with being amongst the first to try.
- Pamar 10y ago
  I wonder if I should try a "Ask HN:" post and hope to get more answers about this.
jitl 10y ago
I have a feeling that legos are too "low-res" for sketching out software design. However, I use them sometimes before attempting a more detailed 3D model or illustration, to build a sort of sketch reference. I use this most when thinking about perspective, sight-lines, etc. It helps me avoid getting stuck in the minutia of my digital tools (Sketchup or Illustrator), where I can get distracted trying to make the tool do what I want.
- gene-h 10y ago
  Well if you include Lego technic, Lego is in fact Turing complete[0][1]. This means one could not only do software design, but development on Lego. [0] http://rubens.ens-lyon.fr/fr/gallery/ http://rubens.ens-lyon.fr/fr/gallery/ [1] http://www.nico71.fr/lego-computer-digicomp/ http://www.nico71.fr/lego-computer-digicomp/
drb311 10y ago
It's a long time, but isn't this the software they build in the novel Microserfs? If so the idea's been around a long while, so I guess it just doesn't work in real life. It's a great geek novel anyway.
- Pamar 10y ago
  From what I remember the sw they were working on in the novel was more like a Virtual Reality lego. I.e. something like what they use in Second Life, or possibly Minecraft, but I don't remember it being aimed at modelling sw architecture. Also, by using a 3D sw you would lose the physical manipulation part, which seems to be important, according to the article linked above.
kenshi 10y ago
I have definitely read about a project where they made a physical model to represent/show the complexity of a software system to their clients. IIRC the project involved doing a re-write of an existing system. Unfortunately, I can't remember exactly where I read this. Perhaps someone else here knows the details? Sorry I can't be more specific.
Corvus 10y ago
Moshe Safdie used “All the Lego in Montreal” to design his Habitat complex http://www.dezeen.com/2014/12/19/moshe-safdie-movie-interview-habitat-67/ http://www.dezeen.com/2014/12/19/moshe-safdie-movie-intervie....

by Pamar 10y ago

andrei_says_ 10y ago

I was wondering about the same. I'm also ok with being amongst the first to try.

Pamar 10y ago
I wonder if I should try a "Ask HN:" post and hope to get more answers about this.

jitl 10y ago

I have a feeling that legos are too "low-res" for sketching out software design. However, I use them sometimes before attempting a more detailed 3D model or illustration, to build a sort of sketch reference. I use this most when thinking about perspective, sight-lines, etc. It helps me avoid getting stuck in the minutia of my digital tools (Sketchup or Illustrator), where I can get distracted trying to make the tool do what I want.

gene-h 10y ago
Well if you include Lego technic, Lego is in fact Turing complete[0][1]. This means one could not only do software design, but development on Lego. [0] http://rubens.ens-lyon.fr/fr/gallery/ http://rubens.ens-lyon.fr/fr/gallery/ [1] http://www.nico71.fr/lego-computer-digicomp/ http://www.nico71.fr/lego-computer-digicomp/

drb311 10y ago

It's a long time, but isn't this the software they build in the novel Microserfs? If so the idea's been around a long while, so I guess it just doesn't work in real life. It's a great geek novel anyway.

Pamar 10y ago
From what I remember the sw they were working on in the novel was more like a Virtual Reality lego. I.e. something like what they use in Second Life, or possibly Minecraft, but I don't remember it being aimed at modelling sw architecture. Also, by using a 3D sw you would lose the physical manipulation part, which seems to be important, according to the article linked above.

kenshi 10y ago

I have definitely read about a project where they made a physical model to represent/show the complexity of a software system to their clients. IIRC the project involved doing a re-write of an existing system. Unfortunately, I can't remember exactly where I read this. Perhaps someone else here knows the details? Sorry I can't be more specific.

Corvus 10y ago

Moshe Safdie used “All the Lego in Montreal” to design his Habitat complex http://www.dezeen.com/2014/12/19/moshe-safdie-movie-interview-habitat-67/ http://www.dezeen.com/2014/12/19/moshe-safdie-movie-intervie....