6 ms·
About 1 in 4 adults experience some level of mental illness in a given year. > "I started having thoughts like, 'Let me take over you,' combined with confusion
by CharlesW 10y ago
About 1 in 4 adults experience some level of mental illness in a given year.
> "I started having thoughts like, 'Let me take over you,' combined with confusion and tons of terror," says David, a polite, articulate 27-year-old who arrived at Britton’s Cheetah House in 2013. "I had a vision of death with a scythe and a hood, and the thought 'Kill yourself' over and over again."
That's not an effect of meditation, that's a symptom of a mental illness. Meditation probably helped him discover it earlier than he otherwise would have.
I mean, the words "mental" and "illness" don't even appear in the article.
- ChrisClark 10y agoYeah, they didn't mention "mental" or "illness", instead the article used the words "psychotic break" and "worsen symptoms in people who have certain psychiatric problems". So, yes the article did cover what you wanted them to. Someone who has an underlying problem may not have a good experience when he digs deep and explores his own thoughts.
- CharlesW 10y ago> So, yes the article did cover what you wanted them to. Not as I read it. In the article, "psychotic break" was used in the context of being caused by meditation instead of by an underlying mental illness. The second example gets closer to addressing the point I was making, but it's still just listing a possible risk for people who already have psychiatric problems. What I wanted the article to cover is the far more likely explanation: That 1 in 4 people who meditate will experience some level of mental illness in any given year — but not because of meditation. Of course, "meditation madness" is a much sexier premise.
- near_how_far 10y agoThis is as if to say that meditation is anything other than thinking for thought's sake. And so, to stretch further, this paraphrasing of what meditation actually IS, at the end of the day... Is it possible for a person to simply "think" themselves into a certain states or flavors of insanity, or rather the more proper term, mental illness?
- winfred 10y ago>Is it possible for a person to simply "think" themselves into a certain states or flavors of insanity, or rather the more proper term, mental illness? Of course it is possible to think yourself mentally ill. Paranoia, various phobias require nothing more than negative thought spirals (not to mention eating disorders).
- jddjdbdbd3 10y agoYup. We are taught ao thoroughly that our thoughts are distinct from reality, that we have trouble grasping thier power over our bodies. While you cannot move objects with your mind, in the domain of your body and mind, the mind itself is king.
- near_how_far 10y agoIs rhetorical not in the dictionary?
- reitanqild 10y agoWhat do you mean?
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> Is it possible for a person to simply "think" themselves into a certain states or flavors of insanity That's basically the premise of the people at https://www.reddit.com/r/Tulpas https://www.reddit.com/r/Tulpas
- askldfhjkasfhd 10y agoMy understanding and experience is that it's more accurate to call it meta-thinking, rather than just thinking. Perhaps semantics, and the lines are not at all clear, but it's helping me find balance in my life. That isn't to say it didn't hurt OP.
- scott_s 10y agoAlso, "psychotic break" is an extreme mental condition that is, I think, rare. Depression and anxiety disorders are much more common, and neither was brought up in the article.
- near_how_far 10y agoExcept meditation is sold (yes, sold) even to the mentally ill as if it were a completely benign cure-all, suitable for use in preventing or attenuating exactly that kind of mental disturbance. After all, leaving someone alone with their own thoughts... what harm could that do? And who could be blamed for such problems, except the individual? It's almost like prescribing absolutely nothing. So, when someone tells you this will surely ease your pain, but, rather than cure, or even do nothing at all (the general assumption a naive individual might make), it greatly amplifies one's problems, as if one were given a service animal only to be viciously attacked by it, such a result is probably going to surprise you.
- acjohnson55 10y agoBut mental illness can have all sorts of causes. I don't think it's crazy to suggest that meditation itself could in rare cases be one of them. Or suppose the person never meditated and lived and died with a latent mental illness that never actually manifested. Could they be said to have a mental illness at all?
- Aelinsaar 10y agoIf you want to suggest that and not sound crazy, cite something suggesting the possibility.
- near_how_far 10y agoThe article in question doesn't state that meditation was a cause of their problems, but pretty obviously details that people coming to meditation looking for ways to improve their lifestyle, instead began down a road to a much worse place. While it might be unsurprising that meditation did not provide direct benefits to mind or body, it also failed to insulate or deflect these people away from new misery. It's interesting to learn that the people described in the article had uncovered unsettling realities about themselves while meditating. Knowing what I know about many people, uncompromising introspection is not something everyone would be comfortable with. Some people are jerks. Some people have their head in the clouds. Grinding one's life to a halt, and taking a hard look in the mirror, is bound to derail an unrealistic world view now and again. But if, on the other side of an unceremonious introduction to cold reality, awaits absolutely no way to fix profound disappointment... What then?
- Aelinsaar 10y agoI'm not convinced that time didn't do the uncovering, and meditation happened to be what they were doing at the time. Correlation != Causation and all of that, you know.
- kordless 10y agoCrazy is making blaming statements at others because they can see beyond the truth of the matter at hand.
- Alex3917 10y ago> Meditation probably helped him discover it earlier than he otherwise would have. Religious or Spiritual Problems is it's own section in the DSM-IV. While that particular issue isn't especially exciting, a lot of the symptoms that can manifest don't correspond with any other mental illness.
- lgas 10y agoThere's no indication in the article that David was having religious or spiritual problems.
- Alex3917 10y agoThe whole article is about how, as the result of a religious experience, he started having visions of a religious figure telling him to kill himself. That seems like a pretty clear-cut case to me...
- RobertoG 10y agoWe are all vulnerable to mental illness. The question is if we can avoid it with the proper knowledge. Maybe avoiding meditation in some cases. I'm speaking of memory, it has been a while since I read about those things, but in some of the classic texts of Zen and Chan there are warnings about this kind of thing. I think there are even advice in how to deal with it. Somebody should go to the sources instead of just forget about all that accumulated experience.