33 ms·
TSA's Head of Security 'Removed' from Office
- Shivetya 10y agoLets be honest, every damn supervisor and management position within the TSA airport security apparatus should be on those lines until its fixed. Got to love the stories where the TSA backdoor lobbies the Congress to prevent reform.
- appleflaxen 10y agoThe most galling aspect is the $90,000 bonus, broken up into $10,000 increments to escape scrutiny. Who is running the TSA circus?
- davidsong 10y agoIs that what you call a structured bonus?
- jkot 10y agoI find this ridiculous. TSA employs 55k people and has budged $8B. Sure its director should be pay reasonably. At the same time Yahoo CEO gets over $150M and people applaud it. I get private versus public organization difference, but TSA is bigger than Yahoo.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoReasonable pay is fine, but why would he receive a bonus when the organization is not performing well? Furthermore, why would that bonus be paid explicitly in a surreptitious way?
- milesokeefe 10y agoHe should be paid reasonably, but he shouldn't be given bonuses for underperforming.
- snarfy 10y agoCongress cut the TSA budget 15% at the same time there is a 15% increase in traffic. Sure, blame 'that guy'.
- chris_wot 10y agoYeah, and given how badly it seems to be run then it sounds like it had been a complete disaster!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coldpie 10y agoGood start! Only 85% to go!
- ttraub 10y agoEliminate the TSA and give the $8B to Nasa. A much better investment.
- dimino 10y agoThe TSA provides value, security theater has its place.
- zentiggr 10y agoKeep the sheeple thinking that something is being done while providing low wage jobs for what is being promoted as critical safety personnel? Orwell would just look at this, shrug and say "I was trying to say..."
- dimino 10y agoYou've lost when you start saying words like "sheeple" and "Orwell" in these conversations, you realize that right?
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoLet's close down the TSA instead. Use intelligent profiling and random searches instead of universal scanning. Let anyone go to the gates, not just ticket holders. Allow liquids, yogurt containers, etc. Allow knives. Allow people to "congregate" near the front lavatory. Try it for one year and I can almost guarantee, flights will be every bit as secure. Security theatre is not security.
- marcus_holmes 10y agohas the TSA stopped a single credible plot since it started doing all this theatre?
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoThey boast of all the knives and guns they've confiscated. I wonder though, whether we'd not be more secure if everyone carried guns on board. A hijacker wouldn't stand a chance. Of course, there might also be some bloody air rage incidents as well. But at the same time, maybe people would act more civil if everyone around them is packing, or at least the flight attendants....
- jimcsharp 10y agoMaybe this is the movies I've watched, but isn't firing a gun structurally dangerous to the airplane?
- deelowe 10y agoConsidering one plane flew and successfully landed with half the top missing, I think movies might exaggerate the risk a bit. Shocking, I know...
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe plane you're referencing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloha_Airlines_Flight_243 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloha_Airlines_Flight_243 And no, folks, "half the top missing" isn't hyperbole.
- smoyer 10y agoI predict that security problems will be solved at airports once they fire the rest of the TSA.
- anonymousDan 10y agoThe airport security in most of the American airports I've seen in the last few years is just a complete shambles in terms of efficiency. It takes forever in comparison to most of the busy European airports I've been through. And I doubt the security is any better. For example, London Gatwick has a really fast system where they have a set of packing bays before you get to the scanners/pat downs. This massively reduces delays caused by someone in the queue ahead of you faffing around putting their stuff into trays. It's like no-one is even bothering to think about that kind of stuff in American airports. Or maybe it's just for international travellers?
- mayukh 10y agoDomestic travelers too. Congress wouldn't care as much if newspapers weren't reporting record wait times ahead of the summer travel months. It's a mess. And they'll pretend they've done something by firing this guy and not allocating any more funds (Or let airports charge more..) Its not going to be free.
- ts330 10y agothe key here is that more than one person is filling their tray at a time. so if one person is taking their time, other people can jump past them. obviously it helps to have motivated and efficient operators, but in my experience, it's almost always some dithering idiot that holds things up. as as we all know, serial processing of a queue is not efficient when you end up waiting on IO :)
- mr_spothawk 10y agoI fly frequently through a limited set of airports. I rarely see the millimeter scanner at less than max throughput. That said I regularly do what I can to slow things down, and sometimes take the pat down in favor of hassling the staff. Attrition is damned right. The TSA scam is awful, and I hope we can get rid of it soon.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoMy personal experience is just the opposite. I always see the nudie scanners languishing for 30 seconds or more between people. The delay seems to be the baggage x-ray. If that's true, then some other things fit neatly into place. The airline escalation of baggage check fees has driven people to carrying more stuff. That, in turn, means that more stuff needs to go through the x-ray conveyor, which slows down that process.
- rbcgerard 10y agoThe most ridiculous thing is that you'd think it was surprise when these people show up at the airport - it's not as if all these people had bought tickets days in advance with a time that indicated when they were going to show up
- ck2 10y agoCan't believe I am saying this but whatever Israel does in their airports, do it here and problem solved. In fact whatever company does it in Israel should be hired to do it here, if it is a government thing, borrow their people to train ours, we give them enough for that loan.
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoWhy can't you believe you're saying this? Many others have also suggested it. I remember reading that a former head of Israel's airport security told Homeland Security that he could smuggle a bomb through American airport security, and he offered to show them how. I don't know whether they ever took him up on it.
- brians 10y agoThey have one international airport; you can use different moves when you don't have to scale. They have broad social consciousness of active attack. Most Americans do not experience terrorism as a realistic threat. Others differences in the acceptability and prediction strength of profiling based on apparent race and sex also matter. In short, we've tried and their model doesn't port over cleanly.
- ivraatiems 10y agoThe way Israel achieves their efficacy is blatant racial profiling. I've been to Israel several times, and because I am a white Jewish American, I have no problems. If I had brown skin, or was Muslim, or wasn't from the US, there's a good chance I'd just not be let in. Now, it works extremely well. Can't deny that. And it's legal under Israeli law. But it would be blatantly illegal here.
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoIsraeli profiling is far more sophisticated than "blatant racial profiling" as the above commenter baselessly claims. For one thing, many Jews in Israel are of Middle Eastern origin and appear identical to Muslim Arabs. The Israelis use several layers of profiling: a preliminary sweep as you are checking in, which assigns you a particular "risk level" based on your country of origin, profession, behavior, and other details (probably if you're wearing Muslim attire, that's taken into account as well). You then have to undergo several more levels of scrutiny from very well educated, highly intelligent and intensely trained specialists. They can and will frisk, pat down, and strip search if needed. They can open all of your luggage and check every inch of it if they're suspicious. Or they can wave you through if they're satisfied of your innocence. Here's one journalist's impression of the Israeli system: http://www.businessinsider.com/israels-ben-gurion-airport-security-uses-secret-sticker-system-2015-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/israels-ben-gurion-airport-se... For the Americans to adopt the Israeli system would mean recruiting some very sharp cookies, training them very well and compensating them commensurately. The U.S. government's track record of such achievements is not that great, unfortunately. Certain groups like the Navy SEALs, certainly, but to hire, say, 100,000 such people to operate the 5,000+ airports in the U.S. is dauntingly beyond reasonable contemplation. EDIT: also worth mentioning that Israel is 20% Muslim. They wouldn't just "not let in" Muslims; on the contrary, they have to accommodate many different ethnicities and religions every day. It's an extremely diverse country.
- ianhawes 10y agoOne of the most irritating aspects of the TSA inefficiencies is that they know the demand at each airport in advance. Because all airlines submit passenger information to the TSA as its booked (often months or weeks in advance), the TSA can shift resources. While I'm all for blaming the TSA, the head of the TSA's union was on NPR this morning and pointed out that Congress diverted funds collected from the "9/11 Tax" (per-ticket fixed fee used to fund TSA) to other parts of the government budget. The union is requesting emergency funding for 8,000 additional TSOs, which would only bring it back to 2011 staffing levels. There are quite a few other issues at play as well. The TSA has the highest turnover rate of any government agency. This is, in large part, due to the fact that they're mostly part-time and underpaid. Their public image isn't respected either. I do think we should replace/get rid of the TSA, but the neo-conservative method of government excision where you cut off the cash flow and wait for everyone to get pissed off ("starve the beast") is incredibly unpopular. But thats exactly whats happening.
- mindcrime 10y agoI do think we should replace/get rid of the TSA, but the neo-conservative method of government excision where you cut off the cash flow and wait for everyone to get pissed off ("starve the beast") is incredibly unpopular. I'm not sure that's even in play here. Neo-conservatives talk about "small government" but it's mostly lip service, especially when it comes to anything related to the military/industrial/espionage/security/prison complex. Cutting the budget for the TSA doesn't sound in harmony with the normal neo-con agenda.
- ttraub 10y agoHere's what the Tea party website has to say: http://teaparty.org/tsa-misconduct-highest-levels-160893/ http://teaparty.org/tsa-misconduct-highest-levels-160893/ There are many other articles on conservative channels ripping the TSA as a big government boondoggle.
- greeneggs 10y agoNote that teaparty.org is definitely not "the Tea Party website." It is just one of many Tea Party organizations, and not a major one. The Tea Party is a decentralized movement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Party_movement#Composition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Party_movement#Composition
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoI've been to the DMV yesterday. You wait in line for 40 minutes in the sun just to get a number and then wait some more. Once you get a number, you're counted in the official wait time statistics published on their website, so the extra 40 minutes are shaved off for free. Who ever though it was going to be different when the TSA was created?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoI've been driving for 26 years in 6 different states and hardly ever have had any kind of serious wait.
- dimino 10y agoYeah, ironically DMV wait times are for people who aren't patient enough to wait for a low-traffic period of time, or to find a DMV that isn't busy.
- chrisper 10y agoIn CA you can make an appointment. I made one and was in and out in 20 minutes.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoBut appointments are available only two weeks from now. Sometimes people have urgent issues that they cannot prepare for two weeks ahead. And even if it's their own fault, why should they be punished for it?
- rocky1138 10y agoThe danger of the TSA is that the employees truly believe they are doing good and important work. The brainwashing is so strong that it almost reaches a religious level.
- ceejayoz 10y agoI flew through Charlotte a few weeks ago and got stuck at TSA (the sniffer threw up a bright red "EXPLOSIVES DETECTED!" banner, upon which the other passengers at the checkpoint started giving me dirty looks and edging away... Thanks for that, TSA. You'd think it'd say something like "ERROR 5930" instead...). There were hundreds of people at the checkpoint, TSA was moving very slowly. Someone else's laptop got flagged, they asked why, and the TSA staffer said "the molecular weight of the laptop was off". She (rightly) said that didn't make sense, complained that they'd made her miss her flight, and said "I work for the government, we're on the same side, but WTF?". Response to her was "don't you want to be safe?" followed by a good five minutes of the entire TSA staff mocking her after she'd gone. They mocked her for saying she worked for the government, saying "if she worked for the government she'd know that already" (ignoring for a moment that their explanation was massively incorrect, why would a non-TSA staffer know anything about the spectrophotometer workings?) etc. Meanwhile, when they get tested, they miss 95% of test weapons/bombs. http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/investigation-breaches-us-airports-allowed-weapons-through-n367851 http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/investigation-breaches-u...
- leesalminen 10y agoA TSA employee was whining about a lack of pay increases to me recently. I smiled, then turned to my friend and started discussing how naive they are and the negligible amount of value these people provide to society. She turned beet red and didn't say another word.
- steele 10y ago"Security"
- TDL 10y agoTea Party conservatives are not necessarily neo-cons.
- jtuente 10y agoWasn't the Tea Party movement started because of their disgust with neo-cons?
- TDL 10y agoThe movement coalesced around the bank bailouts. There was growing dissatisfaction with the Bush neo-cons, more around economic policies then foreign invasions (I would characterize the Tea Party as confident in American power, but ambivalent to slightly negative on foreign invasions.) I imagine that those who identified with the Tea Party are now disgusted with the neo-cons, but I don't believe there was a clear (or at least well articulated) aversion to them at the beginning.
- MrMullen 10y agoNo, it was started because a Black Guy got into the White House. Don't fool yourself, the Tea Party is simply a racist reaction to non-White person being in the White House. Budget wise, Bush was much worse than Obama and there was no Tea Party telling him not to invade Iraq and blow 2 trillion dollars on pointless wars. The Tea Party only came about when Obama took office.
- astine 10y agoEx post hoc ergo propter hoc.
- TDL 10y agoThis is absolutely false. The Tea Party coalesced after the bank bailouts.
- MrMullen 10y agoReally? http://www.britannica.com/topic/Tea-Party-movement http://www.britannica.com/topic/Tea-Party-movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Party_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Party_movement There might have been some reactions to the Bush Bailouts, but what is the Tea Party does not come into being until Obama is sworn in. Don't fool yourself, if Obama was White, there would be no Tea Party.
- btilly 10y agoCan we just get rid of the TSA? Current estimates are that hundreds of people die each year in car accidents because they chose to drive rather than deal with TSA lines. This means that every few years the TSA manages to inflict more casualties than 9/11 did. In addition to inconvenience, economic inefficiency, and a demonstrably ineffective screening process that weapons can easily get through. (As many have shown.) Security theater is a dangerously bad idea no matter how you look at it. Can we do something saner?
- exacube 10y agohow do they estimate this stuff?
- ThomPete 10y agoPost/pre 9-11 I think
- btilly 10y agoYou estimate from survey data how many more people are taking several hundred mile road trips instead of flying, then apply known traffic fatality statistics how many wound up dead from that decision. See https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/09/excess_automobi.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/09/excess_automo... for a reference.
- marze 10y agoThis is naive. Why would you assume the same number of successful attacks on air travel would occur without the security? You can't argue that the current system hasn't done well, it has performed fantastically, based on the number of successful attacks within the US. That said, they need a lot more screeners, and to be much more polite. And get rid of incompetent management.
- chickenbane 10y agoI think it's a safe assumption, because if the TSA actually found a terrorist through its screening process they would parade this achievement in front of every news organization it could. On the other hand, there have been numerous documented cases where people have deliberately snuck banned items through the TSA security checks. Of course, you had to qualify statement that the TSA "has performed fantastically" with the number of _successful_ attacks. There have been terrorists that have attempted attacks, such as the underwear bomber and the shoe bomber, but those were all stopped by the passengers. To me, this should have warranted a congratulations to our fellow citizens for being vigilant - and maybe even a relaxation of some of the rules. As you know, the opposite occurred, and now we have to take our shoes off and can only take small amounts of liquid. Who's being naive?
- bingeboy 10y agoSame thing happened to me with a video camera.
- ryan606 10y agoSecurity has been privatized at a few airports, like San Francisco and Kansas City. How does security screening effectiveness, efficiency, and cost compare at those two airports relative to all other TSA-operated US airport security? I haven't seen any side by side comparisons -- does anyone know if any reputable journalists or researchers have tried to compare?
- jessaustin 10y agoComparisons with the Kansas City airport will probably mislead. It has a very different architecture than most other airports: it's aggressively anti-hub. That is to say, although it nominally has three terminals, each of those effectively has four or five separate secured areas. This actually works fairly well for trips starting or ending in Kansas City, not least because it means that no security wait will reach the ridiculous lengths you see in many other airports. It also means that screening personnel have to operate 15 different security lines rather than two or three. That may be why TSA left?
- relevant_thing 10y ago~850 million US-based passenger * flights per year ~15 minutes in TSA waiting per passenger per flight ~80 years in a life 850,000,000 passengers per year * 15 minutes = 12,750,000,000 minutes of passenger time per year ≈ 24,241 years of passenger time per year 24,241 years of passenger time per year / 80 years per life ≈ 303 passenger lives per year. The TSA effectively kills ~300 people per year just by wasting our time.