4 ms·
This whole thing is making fun of asking fizz-buzz to a senior programmer, but yet I've found it to be one of the best phone screen questions possible. For som
by jedberg 11y ago
This whole thing is making fun of asking fizz-buzz to a senior programmer, but yet I've found it to be one of the best phone screen questions possible.
For someone who is truly a senior programmer, they knock it out in about 30 seconds and we move on. For the ones who pretend to be senior programmers on their resume, it trips them up and I know right away that their resume is either a pack of lies or their previous coworkers were helping them a lot more than they let on.
If I had actually had this person, I would have probably laughed as soon as he did the imports, said, "clearly you think this is a silly question" and then explained why I ask that question. Hopefully we could have moved on from there.
- bstrand 11y agoIt's just a jape, not to be taken seriously, made in the great comic tradition of FizzBuzz Enterprise Edition: https://github.com/EnterpriseQualityCoding/FizzBuzzEnterpriseEdition https://github.com/EnterpriseQualityCoding/FizzBuzzEnterpris...
- ergothus 11y agoJoking aside, this example does a great job to show one of my complaints with common (edit: enterprise) Java practices - Where is the logic?
- vonmoltke 11y agoCommon enterprise OO problems. It is neither confined to Java nor representative of Java as used outside enterprise development.
- ci5er 11y ago> nor representative of Java as used outside enterprise development. It isn't? I've turned down a couple of sweet gigs, at times when I really needed the comfort of work-group structure and maybe even a pay check, because I assumed that (based on my reading) it was all like that. I knew from history, back in the days when it was called Oak that it was a pretty delightful language. Then WS-* and Enterprise OO happened, and I assumed that's where it all went...
- vonmoltke 11y agoI write NLP software in Java and we don't have any of that crap. We have had a couple devs pass through from that world, but we have largely avoided any of the architecture astronaut crap that plagues enterprise development. It's a shame that the name "Java" has become synonymous with it, since it really isn't a bad language (as of Java 7, at least).
- SZJX 10y agoWhy is Java 8 even worse though? It supposedly introduces several mechanisms to reduce redundancy?
- shawndumas 11y agoravioli-code
- anysz 11y agoSenior programmer? ... Shouldn't a junior programmer be able to solve fizzbuzz? I'm light years away from being senior, but I can write functions like fizzbuzz in 10 seconds and can't find a junior job
- jedberg 11y ago> Shouldn't a junior programmer be able to solve fizz buzz? Yes, which is why when I would ask it of a someone who calls themselves a senior programmer I was dumbfounded at how many could not answer the question.
- th0ma5 11y agoFWIW, please be mindful of your biases. I recently had an interviewer with a major bank conglomerate who had some silly puzzle. I outlined a system for solving it in algorithmic notation, and the interviewer had no idea that such a response was appropriate and said sorry, that they were looking for someone with programming experience, not specific, just "many languages" ... Not saying you do this, but what if someone provided Fizz Buzz in COQ or Elixir, or some kind of rule based solver? Honestly a lot of that may look like gibberish to me if I was looking just for a way to dismiss people. Or what if they never heard of Fizz Buzz? Anyway... my brain starts to fixate on all of these corner case scenarios in hiring where you're screwed because something "easy" never does solve the hard problem of hiring. What if the person couldn't do it because they think you're trying to trick them? Anyway... best of luck in your hiring.
- xxpor 11y agoIf someone answered FizzBuzz in Coq, I'd question their judgement. On the other hand, usually in situations like that I'd ask the interviewee to explain their solution. If they can explain it well, that's fine.
- couldwejust 11y ago> what if someone provided Fizz Buzz in COQ or Elixir Wie waere es fuer dich, wenn ich in einer Sprache antworte, die du wahrscheinlich nicht verstehst?
- jc4p 11y agoI do warm-up problems like this even when starting hour long code interviews. I don't like FizzBuzz though, I like to use same difficulty questions that can be expanded onto other tasks, a point-in-rect sample question can turn into a real bounding box question.
- ubernostrum 11y agoThe thing is, there are a lot of people whose ability to code can be verified pretty easily without wasting the time of multiple people in your company. So why not do that?