4 ms·
This is the kind of thing that sounds right but makes absolutely no sense at all Exactly because the sense of hunger is not correlated with the exact need to e
by raverbashing 11y ago
This is the kind of thing that sounds right but makes absolutely no sense at all
Exactly because the sense of hunger is not correlated with the exact need to eat is that we have obesity.
Eating only when hungry sounds like a good idea but then you get (usually fat) people complaining they are hungry all the time.
An average adult will spend around 12h (and probably more) physiologically fine without food, until its glycogen reserves are depleted.
- dhimes 11y agoFirst you must distinguish between hunger and appetite. Hunger is usually accompanied by a "growling" stomach. Appetite is simply the desire for food.
- Drdrdrq 11y agoI think you missed the point - the way I understood parent, he tried to point out that many of the articles about "healthy" food consumption are financed by food industry and should be more or less ignored.
- PaulHoule 11y agoIn the case of "eat" you may be right, if you want to seriously lose weight you should probably adopt a structured eating plan. In terms of "consume" in general, there is an intense commercial pressure to get you to "consume" more. Oddly you don't see ads pressuring you to eat lunch or eat dinner, although Taco Bell used to advertise "fourthmeal" for a while.
- pc2g4d 11y agoI think they meant "Don't eat when you aren't hungry" rather than "Always eat when you're hungry". The first seems obviously true, while the second is something that I don't think anybody argues. The disconnect between hunger and the need to eat may be an artifact of the separation of flavor from nutrition in modern, engineered "foods". To me it seems that hunger must have evolved as a fundamental signal to do or not do exactly what it's about (eat) but that it's been disrupted by modern developments.
- scotty79 11y agoI'd argue both. "Don't eat when you aren't hungry" is very often violated because eating is social activity. I also don't see why would everybody agree on "Always eat when you're hungry". I think it's better to drink a glass of water (or tea) or milk when you are hungry or do something else instead like going somewhere where you should be, doing something you should do or just playing a game.
- pizza 11y agoWhat does depletion of glycogen have to do with hunger/being "physiologically fine"? People who are ketotic after about 1 or 2 days, or people who have just hit "the wall" during an ultra-long workout, don't have much glycogen to go on, but still get hungry just fine.
- coldtea 11y ago>Eating only when hungry sounds like a good idea but then you get (usually fat) people complaining they are hungry all the time. Those people have no idea what is like to be actually hungry -- in the literal, haven't eater for 2 days sense. They just have cravings.