3 ms·
The Surprisingly Sudden Demise of the Anti-GMO Movement
- pklausler 10y agoI disagree that a wave of rationality has come from somewhere and boosted everybody's critical thinking skills -- it doesn't seem to have affected e.g. the anti-vaxxers yet. The OP might want to consider some alternative explanations as well as the original hypothesis.
- ktRolster 10y agoMaybe it can be explained by the rise of apathy.... To be anti-GMO, you have to do something, get out there, check labels to avoid foods, whatever. Whereas vaccination is something that forces itself into your attention when you have kids.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThere are some folks that won't be swayed. I find a thread in the anti-gmo's that equate Monsanto is bad, therefore GMOs must be bad as well. There is a similar line with the "organic" produce folks... organic methods can be bad for the environment yet they are thinking it is better practices. However, in this case, folks have to read carefully and do stuff. In addition, it seems government and health organizations are no longer backing up the anti-gmo stuff as much as they were. Which is a victory in rationality.
- Qantourisc 10y ago"were causing significant environmental" -> Links to an article not even mentioning "significant". And they mention burning leaves of. How about not doing that at all ? Is this propaganda ? Or did I not read deep enough ?
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoIn addition to the burning, there are the effects of planting fields with non-gmo sugar beets. I don't think we can have the sugar production without sugar beets, and the old version either requires hand-weeding or more chemicals to be able to have a good harvest. Often those chemicals do more environmental harm than good. The problem with telling folks not to burn the fields is the same problem the sugar beet folks run into when told to hand weed the fields. It costs more and is harder work.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoI don't think the movement has collapsed, rather the movement was successful on the labeling front. It's not that people are inherently anti-GMO, but rather people simply want GMO foods labeled. After the defeat of the Roberts bill in the US Senate to preempt the Vermont mandatory labeling law, the whole issue has gone silent. I don't exactly see people marching for GMOs. This article is awfully skewed and misses the bigger point of the GMO movement.
- xbmcuser 10y agoI personally don't like gmo because of the patents system.