2 ms·
Insider trading, as it is actually enforced in real life, only rarely inconveniences true insiders like CFOs and board members. Rather, the public's prosecutors
by jessaustin 11y ago
Insider trading, as it is actually enforced in real life, only rarely inconveniences true insiders like CFOs and board members. Rather, the public's prosecutors typically concentrate on "outside insiders" like celebrity homemakers and golf buddies of golf buddies. One could speculate on what motivates this preference of prosecutors.
Informed trading is a prisoners' dilemma, in which loyalty to "the pact" distorts markets while defections from it make information public. As you observe, C-suite reptiles benefit most from informed trading. Please note, however, that insider trading laws actually increase the benefits they receive, by punishing "outside insider" defectors. Eliminating this ill-conceived and inconsistently-enforced law would actually decrease the advantage that management takes of owners of public stock.
- tptacek 11y agoMy impression of this is that, like most issues of prosecutorial equity, this simply traces to the difficulty of making a case versus the rewards (yes, primarily to the prosecutor, but in theory also to the public in the form of deterrence) of actually winning the case. We also tend to forget that prosecutors are only supposed to be bringing cases that they are certain they can win. Criminal prosecutions aren't speculative. Finally, people like to point at the Martha Stewart case as evidence that prosecutors are celebrity obsessed. But Stewart was swept up in the earlier prosecution of several other people associated with ImClone.
- jessaustin 11y agoFor other crimes, we accept various imperfections in the judicial system. After all, murder is really bad, and the facts that some murders go unsolved while others are pinned on innocents don't cause us to reconsider our laws against murder. The imperfections don't make the problems posed by murder worse for everyone than would not enforcing the laws at all. (Convicted innocents are an important exception, but let's set them aside in this discussion.) I consider insider trading laws to be of a different nature. As mentioned above, these laws create a situation in which naive investors suffer more harm and self-serving executives reap more gain than they would in the absence of these laws. Without insider trading laws, new "inside" information would set off a race on the part of all knowledgeable insiders to profit from that information, thereby quickly informing the broader market. The positions of public firms would be much clearer, to every investor. Investors could still gain or lose money in the market, but executives could no longer structure their investments and incentive packages over the medium term so as to profit most directly from their inside knowledge. In this new more permissive regime, I'm sure some executives would attempt some straight-up shareholder robbery. But the speed required to succeed at such schemes would make their actions obvious to the investing public, to prosecutors interested in charging more prosaic crimes like fraud, and to tort lawyers interested in breach of contract. After a time we'd have at least some executives who had been incentivized toward honesty enough to actually become generally honest.
- yuhong 11y agoI have been thinking of anti-discrimination laws. Not all kinds of discrimination leave evidence. I have a feeling that they should be restricted to certain job categories. Similarly, sexual harassment leave evidence more often, but this don't mean they are worth the costs. I have been thinking of this Ask HN for example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11666857 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11666857