4 ms·
How do you know that enabling people who happen to have resources in one of the current political regimes to edit their embryos will reduce suffering? It could
by zepto 10y ago
How do you know that enabling people who happen to have resources in one of the current political regimes to edit their embryos will reduce suffering? It could just as easily increase it.
- Kalium 10y agoDo you know what Tay-Sachs is?
- zepto 10y agoHow is that relevant?
- Kalium 10y agoIt's a source of suffering that can be solved through genetic engineering of embryos that some group of people with resources will be inclined to address. It is relevant because it precisely fits your criteria.
- zepto 10y agoSure but my point is that technology that empowers a small group of powerful people to reduce their suffering may end up increasing suffering overall.
- Kalium 10y agoYes. This is possible. You are completely correct. Of course, this is in fact true for all values of $TOOL in "Given $TOOL, a bad thing may happen".
- zepto 10y agoSure - but the risks vary from tool. Rich people editing their babies seems like it's more risky for society than most tools.
- Kalium 10y agoIt's also a tool that can literally save real, countable lives otherwise factually known to be doomed to horrific suffering and very early death. If I understand it correctly, your objection is that it may be possible for some group of people to use this to increase suffering in an abstract way.
- zepto 10y ago"If I understand it correctly, your objection is that it may be possible for some group of people to use this to increase suffering in an abstract way" This is true of most objections to things that have a social impact. Reserving health to the wealthy in a feedback loop of relative advantage does not seem very abstract - it seems dystopian.
- simonh 10y agoIt's not a matter of enabling this at the regime level. Regimes get to make their own laws. We in the west may not be able to stop clearly unethical embry editing, so whether we can do that or not is completely orthogonal to whether we should consider some uses of the technique to be ethical and allowable.