3 ms·
I'm Greek but live and work in the UK. I'm an immigrant, I guess. I've done well for myself here. If the Brexit happens, I'll be in a tough spot, possibly force
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
I'm Greek but live and work in the UK. I'm an immigrant, I guess. I've done well for myself here. If the Brexit happens, I'll be in a tough spot, possibly forced to leave. To go where? Back home! That would be a bit of a disaster for me.
And yet- I think the UK should leave.
From living with the British it seems to me that they really, really want to go. They want it for absurd, idiotic reasons. They 're motivated by nationalism, xenophobia, a ridiculous belief that if they kick all the foreigners off their island everything broken with the UK will magically fix itself... In short, the worse, most stupid sentiments that could ever inform such a serious decision.
And yet- they seem to want it. What's more, while they're in they're constantly disruptive and reactionary, digging in their heels and protesting every effort to bring the rest of the continent closer _as the rest of the continent wants it_. They are the grumpy man of Europe and proud of it.
So let them have their little moment. Let them wave two fingers in our collective faces. And let them get out just like they want it.
That's what they want. Let them have it.
- alexbilbie 11y agoYou are evidently a positive net contributor to the UK, why would you be forced out? I find it completely unimaginable that you would be forcibly removed.
- gpderetta 11y agoIt is one thing living as a EU citizen, another as an immigrant with considerably less rights, though. If GB leaves, me and my family might consider leaving the country as well. The alternative is applying for citizenship, of course. edit: living/leaving
- soneil 11y agoI have exactly the same problem. I'm British. I live in the EU. This is a vote to potentially take away my right to live & work here, and I don't even get to vote in it. (And I'm not eligible for citizenship; I move too much. I have to have 5 years behind me and intent to make this my home. I have neither.)
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> I find it completely unimaginable that you would be forcibly removed. The only reason I'm allowed to live and work in the UK is that I'm an EU citizen. If there's a Brexit (or a Grexit for that matter) I'll have to get a working Visa, or possibly apply for a residency. Neither is certain, and I'll be at the mercy of whoever examines my application. That's not a good place to be. And I'm worried that in a post-Brexit Britain, people will feel justified to act on xenophobic sentiment. There will also probably be many other things that change- for instance, as an EU citizen I was eligible for a tuition fee loan for my university degree (I'm still repaying it) and I paid less for my Masters than overseas students. So there may be financial consequences also.
- UK-AL 11y agoUnfortunately politicians on the brexit side are using immigration issues to pander to the masses. You also have to remember brexit is also opportunity to be even more open then we are now. I'm looking at Switzerland or Hong Kong for future possibilities.
- parenthephobia 11y agoI'm British and I live in the UK, and I am not like this. I'm not a xenophobic nationalist, and I don't believe that purifying the motherland will magically fix everything. Outside of unbalanced right-wing newspapers and their vitriolic online comments sections, polls show Remain with an, admittedly unsafe, majority. We are not all foaming at the mouth screaming at foreigners for ruining everything.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "That's what they want. Let them have it." That's not what all of us want. Speaking as someone born and raised in the UK, I recognise that the attitude you speak of is prominent in our culture, but it's not what all of us want. I for one recognise that immigration has (for the most part) been a net benefit for the UK economically (and culturally, IMO). On the economic side: http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/nov/05/eu-migrants-uk-gains-20bn-ucl-study http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/nov/05/eu-migrants-u... http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/immigration/11913927/Theresa-Mays-immigration-speech-is-dangerous-and-factually-wrong.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/immigration/11913927/... Immigrants are being used as a scapegoat, there's no excuse for it but at least some of us recognise it for what it is. What I find funny is if you look at the nonsense that surrounds immigration the stories aren't cohesive. You'll hear people saying that immigrants are lazy and just here to collect benefits, and you'll also hear people saying that immigrants are taking people's jobs because they're hard working and prepared to work for less. If people are going to be prejudiced, at least be consistent! I recognise there are some issues around immigration that centre on religious differences, and those are more problematic than the economic issues, but for the most part the issues around immigration are overblown. As an aside, I've come to realise that a lot of the problems in the UK stem from our frequently toxic mainstream news media. It's really sad to hear friends and family repeat back soundbites from the news media, with seemingly little to no awareness that those soundbites are there to reinforce prejudice rather than provide insight. I'm sure that the limited access to grown up news coverage and respectful debate lies at the core of our difficulties, everything else that's an issue stems from the lack of good quality information and an unengaged populace.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> I'm sure that the limited access to grown up news coverage and respectful debate lies at the core of our difficulties, everything else that's an issue stems from the lack of good quality information and an unengaged populace. This goes to parenthepobia also. I understand not everyone in the UK is a raging xenophobe, and I'm sorry if my comment lumps everyone together with those guys. But the truth is that the UK society has indulged in this sort of attitude for a long time. Like you say, ZenoArrow, the mainstream press is constantly banging on that drum and people don't just tolerate it, they actively support it. Some challenge it, sure- but the Sun is still the paper with the highest circulation and the Mail is the second. And now there's a referendum. It's not just a few people in the pub being a bit rude after a couple of pints. The country is officially thinking of embracing its isolationist tendencies. I know there's good people in the UK- in fact, regardless of their love for populist rhetoric I think the majority of Brits are decent folk and I owe the country a big part of my own culture if you like. But it seems in this issue, somehow, the nasty ones have won and they'll have their way. And that's because nobody else stepped in to stop them. That's political apathy, as you say. So maybe a Brexit will be a bit of a wake up call, or make people think again about stuff. Probably not, but in any case I really believe what I said: if this is what the majority really-really wants, they should have it. I'm sorry the rest of you must suffer it also.
- NetStrikeForce 11y agoYou know the problem I have with that? That I know a lot of young (and not so young), clever, entrepreneurial and hard-working British people that do not want that... And I don't want that for them. I've got it easy as an EU citizen: I'll move back home or maybe another EU country if I feel like to. I'll might even buy a house in the coast from a British immigrant in Spain. I'm sure they'll start going for cheap in case of Brexit. They, my British friends, won't have that chance. They will be stranded in an island with their careers and prospects crippled because, even if the long term is beneficial for the UK (something that no one has been able to support with decent arguments), the current generations are screwed. At least they will get their borders (back?), so Boris Johnson, Rupert Murdoch and the dude from Wetherspoons can have free reign over the country. Well, that's why I'm vocal about the issue. Is not so much about me, but more about my friends. I owe them this.