17 ms·
IT certifications are no longer optional
- morisy 17y agoCertifications are about as optional as they've always been: Some IT positions they're helpful for, particularly going into government work, but they're not a guaranteed path to success. A consultant I've worked with (as a journalist) in the past actually tracks real wages for certifications vs. wages for area expertise and experience, and experience and real-world practice win out almost every time. Source: http://www.footepartners.com/ http://www.footepartners.com/
- mburney 17y agoCertificates are relevant to non-hackers that want to build a career in IT. The companies that care about certificates are most likely companies that hackers wouldn't want to work for. Also it is interesting how the attitude conveyed in this article is based on fear. "If I don't have X certification, I won't get a job".
- jcromartie 17y agoI got an A+ cert in high school. It helped me get exactly one job: a tech at Best Buy (while still in HS). In the 9 years since then, the issue of certification has never come up again. I know there are more serious certs out there, but I can't help imagining that they are all a lot like my A+ was: memorizing facts that are fairly orthogonal to actually being able to perform your job.
- gacba 17y agoCertifications are only valuable if employers value them in return. Historically, that's been a dicey proposition with only a few exceptions in specific IT admin areas like Cisco and Microsoft server admin. The rest of the certifications are more or less crap.
- jacquesm 17y agoInteresting, I've never asked an employee for any 'certificates', since most of the certificates are too narrow in scope to be of much use, unless you happen to need that exact skill. This of course means that you need lots of certificates if you're going to use them which is money in the bank for the parties issuing them. How about the other employers here, do you ask for certification ? Would you reject an applicant if he or she did not have a certain certificate but had multiple years of relevant experience vs someone that does have the certificate but lacks the experience ?
- kleinsch 17y agoI'm sure there are exceptions, but for the most part certifications are useful when applying to bigger companies who use certifications in order to have more uniform hiring standards. For startups, choice of early employees is critical, so certifications usually play a very minor role. Usually personal connections, references, and experience trump everything else.
- nailer 17y agoIt depends - if you're employing someone to manage Red Hat or Cisco devices the lab-exam based RHCE or CCIE tests are pretty good measures of skill (the RHCE exam has a 55% failure rate - disclosure, I worked for Red Hat). In the case of RHCE, having taught a few hundred I actually think they're a lot broader than most people expect. A guy who knows NFS might lack experience in SMB or disk quotas. A guy might know Postfix, Apache and TCPIP incredibly well but has never had to handle unbootable OSs. Since leaving RH I've worked with professional Unix admins on about $USD 1300 a day who haven't used rescue mode (or any alternative). There are people on the market know whose last piece of significant learning was Solaris 8. I never require a cert on a CV for an infrastructure job, but if the cert is well known in the area, I don't see the prob is saying 'X or equivalent experience'. If they don't have the cert, but can verify they have all the skills encompassed in it, then fine. If they find they don;t have the skills, they won;t apply and waste their and my time.
- timwiseman 17y agoI have never asked for a certification in an interview nor rejected someone for not having them. They are however useful as an indicator of interest and willingness to work and very basic knowledge of the subject for someone who is just starting in IT. They mean almost nothing on the resume of a seasoned, experienced professional, but they can help distinguish one person just starting out from another, especially if staring at a stack of 20 resumes and only having time to interview 5. I would never hire someone on the strength of a certification alone, but I have personally used them as an indicator of who was worth interviewing for entry level positions between candidates with no experience too speak of. On the flip side, when I was transitioning from the military to civilian work, I got database certifications and more than one interviewer told me directly that the certification helped convince them to interview me. Another, though this only happened once, told me that I could have gotten a higher salary offer if I got a higher level certification. Also, some jobs in large organizations actively require them. Whether or not you are willing to work in a large organization is a matter of taste, of course.
- chaosmachine 17y agoMost certificates are a joke. Google "brain dump". Anyone with a decent memory can download a brain dump, study it for a couple days and pass. The only certs I would trust are supervised, lab-based certs, like the higher-end Cisco certifications.
- tptacek 17y agoTalent doesn't need or benefit from certifications. If a prospective employer is pushy about them, you don't want to work there. Pretty simple.
- jrockway 17y agoWith so many job seekers to choose from, employers need to quickly identify those who have the skills they seek. What world is this from? As far as I know, there is a massive shortage of employable programmers.
- yardie 17y agoThe only places I've ever seen certificates be an issue is government and government contractors. Maybe there are some big companies that also require them. But they are outsourcing there IT departments more and more so who has them isn't there problem anymore. I do notice a dogfood pattern for places that require certificates they will pay for their employees to acquire them. One company I temped at wanted a bond to pay for you to get them (work for us for 3 years after getting your MCSE). A lot of the older guys were really excited about this (job security I guess), but the younger ones just shrugged at the offer. We were resume building so being tied to one company for 3 years was definitely not something to look forward to.
- abalashov 17y agoNo, they're completely useless now.
- philk 17y agoTo be honest, if someone had a whole lot of certifications I'd be worried that they needed them to cover for their lack of talent. Also if certifications play a meaningful role in your hiring process you're probably doing it wrong.
- boredguy8 17y agoPunishing someone for having certs is about as silly as rewarding someone for having them when it's not central to their job. I get a cert every year because work pays me more to get one and they pay for the test.
- philk 17y agoI'm not saying that there aren't good people out there with certs [1], I'm just saying that personally it'd make me wonder why someone had so many of them. It's more that when I visualise really sharp technical people I don't see them having a load of certs. [1] And some of the Cisco things, for instance, look pretty rigorous...
- motters 17y agoYears ago people recommended that I acquire some MSCE qualifications. I'm so glad I didn't do them now. For me, it would have been a huge waste of time and money. If you're going to take IT skills related courses (and here I don't mean degrees or PhDs) be careful about your choice and spend some time verifying whether employers really are looking for those qualifications in new recruits. My impression of most of the IT skills courses is that they're just money making mechanisms for a few training companies.
- philk 17y agoProbably the most important part of the article is: Bart Perkins is managing partner at Louisville, Ky.-based Leverage Partners Inc., which helps organizations invest well in IT. Contact him at BartPerkins@LeveragePartners.com. Leverage Partners, according to it's website helps organizations maximize their IT investment through Technology Portfolio Management It's not anything more than marketing, aimed at the kind of middle managers who find the idea of technical resources being fungible and certified appealing.
- va_coder 17y agoCertifications are as about as relevant as ComputerWorld magazine
- heresy 17y agoI've noticed something interesting about certifications. At least on forums I come across when Googling things in the Microsoft space, people with certs tend to add them to their signature, along with their little MVP badge. e.g. Jon Williams MCTS, MCPD, MSCE, MVP As if it lends their post more credence. I have two degrees, and ~15 years experience in the industry , but I don't sign off with B.Sc, B.Sc(Hons), M.Sc 15 Years Experience It adds no value...In my opinion, it's a negative indicator. Some of the best programmers I have ever worked with did not have any degrees or certifications, they got the job on the strength of their interview and ability to think.