4 ms·
"Today, numerous modern studies show that in randomized trials, meticulous hand-washing, when coupled with other infection control measures like surgical drapin
by jessriedel 17y ago
"Today, numerous modern studies show that in randomized trials, meticulous hand-washing, when coupled with other infection control measures like surgical draping and universal gloving, reduce the rate of life-threatening infections during surgery and intensive care unit stays.
But in hospitals, outside of these clinical trials, just half of doctors and nurses regularly clean their hands before patient care, despite widespread publicity."
This is a silly comparison. During surgery (when people are literally split open) and in ICUs (when their body is profoundly damaged), the human body is unnaturally and incredibly sensitive to infection. If you've ever witnessed a surgery, you'd know that surgeons are insanely, mind-bogglingly obsessive-compulsive about washing their hands and keeping a sterile operating room.
But 99% of people in the hospital or doctor's offices are not so compromised, so it's not surprising that doctors and nurses aren't religious about hand washing "before patient care".
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoI've talked to doctors about this, and they point out that if they actually sanitized every time they come into contact with a patient their hands would get so dry the knuckles would start bleeding when they bent their fingers.
- jrockway 17y agoI hear there is this stuff called "moisturizer", which restores the moisture and oils that have been washed away by soap.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoOf course, given that the moisturizer is unsanitary, the doctors and nurses would immediately have to wash it off again. :/
- lotharbot 17y agoThe hospital where my wife gave birth had "moisturizing hand sanitizer".
- jrockway 17y agoSounds like a problem that could be solved. It's not all bacteria and viruses that need to be killed completely, it's mostly MRSA that is the problem. That probably doesn't live in moisturizing lotions; and once you've removed it from your hands, it's not going to come back until your touch it again. Also, what about just wearing rubber gloves?
- aasarava 17y agoAtul Gawande, a surgeon and medical writer, notes in his book "Better" that hand sanitizers like Purell have not been found to have a drying effect, despite fears of the contrary.
- andrewvc 17y agoTrue, for the the OR, but the New Yorker had a great article about how in many of the places in a hospital outside the OR cleanliness is often a problem, and statistically leads to a significantly higher amount of patient sickness and mortality. Despite the clear statistics the doctor writing the piece wrote that efforts to increase hospital sanitation were met with quite a bit of skepticism, and consequently, were not followed (a sentiment echoed in this slate piece). I wish I could link to the article, but I can't find it on the New Yorker site.
- dmlorenzetti 17y agoPossibly you mean this Atul Gawande article on the power of checklists: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/12/10/071210fa_fact_gawande http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/12/10/071210fa_fact_...
- jessriedel 17y agoI assume you mean the checklist article that dmlorenzetti found, which I've read. That article is about people in the ICU--not merely outside the OR--where it is indeed paramount to take all measures possible to reduce the risk of infection. If checklists are effective in reducing mortality in the ICU, then great; doctors and nurses should be insistently prodded to use them. But this shouldn't be confused with a mandate to go hand-washing crazy for all hospitals and doctor's offices. ICU patients make up a tiny percentage of all patients. (As an aside, I am a bit skeptical of these pieces written in the popular press by experts in a certain field which criticize their colleagues. Sometimes, it's a case where the field really has settled into a bad equilibrium, and the contrarian must go outside the fold to right the situation. But often, it's simply an outlet for the contrarian to preach to an audience which doesn't have the expertise and experience to assess his claims.)