42 ms·
Idea monopolies are hardly new; they're called patents. I'm gonna say that if software counts as technology that can be patented, then patents on APIs are equa
by dTal 10y ago
Idea monopolies are hardly new; they're called patents.
I'm gonna say that if software counts as technology that can be patented, then patents on APIs are equally valid. It takes effort to design a good API, just as it takes effort to write good software.
Of course the whole notion is a terrible idea and should be scrapped.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoBut effort doesn't decide whether something is patentable. It needs (at least in theory) to be non-obvious. An API is a lot of work, well designed, but... non-obvious? I don't buy it.
- esbranson 10y agoIsn't "takes effort" opposite "obvious"?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoNo. Almost all of my programming takes effort, but most of it is obvious. (Some of it is obvious after a week's thought. But even then, there's usually nothing novel at the end of the week - just an architecture that thousands of people could have come up with. That's not patentable.) As an illustration, any patented algorithm may take a fair amount of effort to implement. That doesn't mean that implementing it gives me a new patent, though. Or say I write a novel. It takes a lot of work. I can copyright the novel, but not patent it, no matter how much work it took. "Takes effort" does not equal "non-obvious".