3 ms·
Long articles are not bad in the right context, but when publishing online authors need to get to the point right away. They should make their main case in the
by ams6110 10y ago
Long articles are not bad in the right context, but when publishing online authors need to get to the point right away. They should make their main case in the opening paragraph or two, and then fill in the details. The whole opening anecdote about kicking the hornet nest was useless and should be eliminated.
- snookca 10y agoNot sure why publishing online necessitates getting to the point. It's long form and follows a very common story telling format. The world has room for different ways to tell a story.
- wmeredith 10y agoThis is journalism 101. Inverted triangle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid
- msl09 10y agoI want to take a moment to ask my fellow non-americans, do you also hate the american style of storytelling in news articles? It's obnoxious, useless and recently, counter productive because we are overloaded with information and need to skim quickly over many different news.
- kristiandupont 10y ago..it doesn't strike me as particularly American? I could easily see a Danish article written in this style. I don't dislike it but I do agree that the point should be at the top. Trying to build a crescendo seems to build on the assumption that your reader is fascinated by your writing already. It might be true if you have a following. Maybe this author does, I am not sure.
- jessriedel 10y agoNot sure it makes sense to say this is American vs non-American. Normal American newspaper stories adhere pretty well to the inverted pyramid structure, and the wiki article even suggests it first became prominent in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid It's really about news vs. human interest pieces, and many outlets (like the NY Times) feature both. Seems possible to me that American outlets produce more of these, but it'd be hard to disentangle this from the general dominance of American outlets on the English-speaking internet, such that non-American pieces are more likely to be directly local and, so, news rather than human interest.
- jessriedel 10y agoThe solution to this problem is well known: an abstract. It's clear that many news outlets see their job as entertainment rather than delivery of information, and it's also clear from comment's like snookca's that some people like this. (I hate it, but to each his own.) So this is never going to be solved by complaining to the author or to your fellow readers. What could effectively solve this is if HN attached a short abstract to each article, written and updated by user submission. (The initial version could/should be provided by the submitter.) Maybe minimal GitHub-like version control with pull requests accepted by vote. This could be useful not just to save time, but also to keep article quality higher, if submitters are required to justify the intellectual value of the submission. The abstract would be more valuable than normal comments, so accepted modifications could get extra karma. This would have similarities to summaries on slashdot (which are written by moderators and so not very scalable) and the "submission statement" required in certain subreddits. https://www.reddit.com/r/geopolitics/comments/3yh1ll/introducing_submission_statements_for_news_and/?sort=new https://www.reddit.com/r/geopolitics/comments/3yh1ll/introdu... https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueReddit/comments/1p4gqg/new_policy_for_truereddit_submission_statements/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueReddit/comments/1p4gqg/new_poli...
- WalterSear 10y agoAfter a few minutes of that article, I scrolled to the bottom and read the paragraphs in reverse order until I got to the actual point. :)
- alexandercrohde 10y agoI do this too with these types of articles. So much fluff. A real problem in my opinion.
- mattlutze 10y agoThe author simply used a rhetorical approach for having an extended conversation about a scientific topic with laymen. Long-form science writing isn't inferior to news briefs or press release-style articles you're looking for; it can be a very effective method for engaging a reader and introducing them to a topic which they don't have detailed knowledge on (or which they just want to read about).
- fixermark 10y agoRecently learned about the 3-30-300 rule of article writing online: "People will read 3 words to decide if the topic is interesting. If they think it's worth their time, you have thirty words to hook them. If they take the hook, you can probably get them to read 300 words unless they have a focused interest in the topic." It is, unfortunately, tied to much evil online (the quick-list ad blog ecosystem is basically application of 3-30-300 writ large), but useful for creating general-consumption articles.
- stcredzero 10y agoThis is why we'll go extinct. We don't have brains that can handle concepts that take 5 sentences to accurately summarize.
- dsego 10y agoNope, this is why we thrive.
- stcredzero 10y agoOne can thrive in the short term, but still go extinct in the long term.
- waylandsmithers 10y agoWell, it's really a feature about Medzhitov when you were expecting the typical "A New study says!" type of article.