7 ms·
Yes. What if the data plainly presented show that the stimulus plan was plainly a waste of money? P.S. How many of you, when you hear announcements of how many
by tokenadult 17y ago
Yes. What if the data plainly presented show that the stimulus plan was plainly a waste of money?
P.S. How many of you, when you hear announcements of how many jobs have been saved by the stimulus plan, immediately do the mental arithmetic to figure out how many dollars of taxpayer funds were spent to save each job? I think I could do better in my family in keeping us all actively employed in work helpful to society with the same number of dollars per employable person.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoBefore you do that math, make sure you're not counting raises, theoretical jobs from as-yet-un-funded projects, etc. Here's a nice map of where all the fake saved-jobs are: http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/maps/Bogus-jobs-created-or-saved-by-the-Stimulus.html http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/maps/Bogus-jobs-created-or... Although you have to adjust upward: faking the existence of tens of thousands of jobs is obviously difficult work, and I bet more than one person is working full-time on the faking.
- tdoggette 17y agoEzra Klein of the Washington Post deals with this claim (that the stimulus was ineffective because of how much money it spent per job created). http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2010/02/bad_stimulus_math.html http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2010/02/bad_stim... Tax credits, Pell grants, unemployment support: it's not all jobs. But you have to blame the administration for this [perception], at least in part: They sold the stimulus in terms of job creation, rather than simple economic growth.
- anigbrowl 17y agoWell, you can see where the money goes here: http://www.wallstats.com/deathandtaxes/ http://www.wallstats.com/deathandtaxes/
- mos1 17y agoHow many of you, when you hear announcements of how many jobs have been saved by the stimulus plan, immediately do the mental arithmetic to figure out how many dollars of taxpayer funds were spent to save each job? I do not, because that is a fool's calculation. The value created is not one year's salary, it's the difference in the present value of an individual without a job and the present value of an individual with a job, including all estimable secondary effects (both positive and negative.) If you simply divide it and compare it to a year's salary, you'll sit there and go 'HURRR THAT IS DUMB', but in reality, you're proving only that you don't really understand policy analysis. ---- I'm reminded of a situation that occurred many years ago in my career, when I was still working in a corporate setting. My team hit a seemingly intractable combinatorial explosion problem while trying to create a tool for the sales force. It was incredibly difficult, and quickly blew through the allocated budget (which we'd told them right from the gate, was inadequate). The management just assumed we were lying... that we weren't up to this task, or we were just lobbying for more money and man-power for our group (I was trying to make a very specific high-end hire to help, and I had already purchased some serious iron). In fact, they were so convinced that this couldn't be this difficult to accurately analyze that they started shopping consultancies, and most agreed with us, that this would be difficult and expensive... but one did not. One said "yes, we can build it, no problem." A year later, the consultancy had burned through a pile of money, and had nothing to show for it. Only then did management recognize that maybe this seemingly simple configuration problem was not, in fact, as simple as they imagined. And perhaps we weren't just lying or waving our hands when we said "this shit is not as simple as you think it is." (and even then, they didn't admit it outright. I had an all-day meeting which consisted solely of them asking me stupid question after stupid question, as to why various simple approaches wouldn't work... and me having to draw out specific examples on a whiteboard, indicating the business and technical problems with these simple approaches.) It's sad, but common, for people to assume that other people's jobs are easier than they really are. Even very smart people fall into that trap... but generally speaking if intelligent, hard-working people are advocating something that seems stupid to you, it's probably because you don't understand the problem or the solution.
- anamax 17y ago> The value created is not one year's salary, it's the difference in the present value of an individual without a job and the present value of an individual with a job, including all estimable secondary effects (both positive and negative.) If you simply divide it and compare it to a year's salary, you'll sit there and go 'HURRR THAT IS DUMB', but in reality, you're proving only that you don't really understand policy analysis. You're assuming that the job will last beyond the year and that we couldn't simply send that person $X dollars and produce most of the same benefits.
- jacobolus 17y agoIf you think it's controversial among fiscal conservatives to do job promoting stimulus programs, just wait until you suggest just sending poor people full-time salaries worth of extra cash for nothing. Good luck with that.
- jbooth 17y agoYour comment, particularly the part where you talk about "simply send that person $X and produce most of the same benefits" underscores your complete and utter lack of comprehension of his post. Try reading it again.
- mos1 17y agoThank you for saying this for me. I knew he was off the rails as soon as he indicated that my claims were based on an assumption of duration of employment. That statement only makes sense if you use the same model that the parent used, in which the only value captured is the worker's salary.
- pg 17y agoIt would be better if you explained in a neutral way what you thought was the source of the misunderstanding.
- jbooth 17y ago