3 ms·
But, AFAICT, the best autonomous racecars (scale or full size) are still far from beating a human. What kind of race car are the humans driving? Does it have e
by chongli 10y ago
But, AFAICT, the best autonomous racecars (scale or full size) are still far from beating a human.
What kind of race car are the humans driving? Does it have electronic stability control? Anti-lock breaks? Power steering? Automatic transmission? These are just a few of the many innovations that make it easier for a human to drive more easily at a high level of performance. The line between autonomous and human-operated cars is blurry.
- Bromskloss 10y agoIt's common for race cars not to have any of those.
- guscost 10y agoAnd if I'm not mistaken professional race drivers are faster without autonomous stability systems running, because consumer-grade traction control "plays it safe" so to speak. Could a traction control/autonomous steering system be designed to push the envelope and risk losing traction as effectively as (or far more effectively than) a pro driver? Almost certainly, but I'm not sure how hard of a problem that will be.
- glaberficken 10y agoThat's true about consumer grade stability systems which are engineered with great margins for safety. As you can see by looking at the F1 active suspension ban in the 90s, when tuned for performance, these systems provided a real edge to even the best pro-drivers.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoBut the active suspension system etc. isn't actually in the "autonomous driving" category, it's an aerodynamics/grip improvement. What it does (maintain perfect ride height) isn't something humans do anyway.
- glaberficken 10y agoyeah good point, what about brakes and accelerators that actuate via electronics/cpu instead of mechanically like in the old days? Humans press brake/accelerate pedals...
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoIf you take ESP/ABS and other driver assists out of the picture, there's no real difference between drive-by-wire and hydraulic couplings (servos etc.). And if you want a fully non-servo car, it's early 1960's for you.
- glaberficken 10y agoThis is a really interesting question to think about. Remember the Active Suspension ban in F1 in the 90s? (they are debating bringing it back for the 2017 season) A purely mechanical car (no electronics to help control any car functions at all) driven by a human most probably wont be able to match an AI controlled car (steering, accelerator, brake, gear, suspension).