4 ms·
This should be an easy job. Just photoshop an image of a black hole with a giant pile of nearly a trillion dollars falling into it.
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
This should be an easy job. Just photoshop an image of a black hole with a giant pile of nearly a trillion dollars falling into it.
- jrockway 17y agoThat's what the military spending visualization czar should do, anyway.
- hga 17y agoAlso funny, but it would be a challenge for someone like Tufte to go beyond that fantastic chart about Napoleon's campaign in Russia to show us less easily quantifiable things like: What it means every time a jihadist in Pakistan is notified that "You've got missile." The benefits of keeping the sea lanes open and free. Bonus points for tracking the historical effects of more and less vigorous suppression of piracy. How beneficial it has been to keep Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, etc. free in the post-WWII era. Bonus points for comparing their respective increases in economic and political freedom with their climbs up the value chain. A special study of Singapore could be fascinating ("Disneyland with the death penalty"). Etc.
- jamesbritt 17y ago'The benefits of keeping the sea lanes open and free. Bonus points for tracking the historical effects of more and less vigorous suppression of piracy.' 'How beneficial it has been to keep Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, etc. free in the post-WWII era. Bonus points for comparing their respective increases in economic and political freedom with their climbs up the value chain. A special study of Singapore could be fascinating ("Disneyland with the death penalty").' These are terrific, difficult, and important questions. Are there freely available Web sites, perhaps along the lines of Wikipedia[0], for articles that try to explain correlation and side-effects of assorted facts and events? [0] I have mixed thoughts on Wikipedia. I've read enough articles with unsubstantiated opinion pushing either a commercial or ideological point view to be deeply skeptical of the site. But the general idea of having some quasi-moderated place for deeper observations beyond fact-reporting is appealing.
- hga 17y agoVery funny, but if Tufte wants to avoid destroying the brand he's built for the 78% of the American population who don't self-identify as liberals, he'll need to clearly present things like: How much of the stimulus went to temporarily prop up state government budgets and how it permanently increased the budgets of the states that accepted it. Bonus points for explaining how Texas is so successful while refusing this temporary windfall. ADDED: The above effect on future state budgets could be illustrated as being caused by synchrotron radiation coming from the dollar bills falling in at relativistic speeds. How "the most shovel ready" project of weatherizing houses became the slowest because the Department of Labor has to make Davis-Bacon "prevailing wage" calculations for 30,000 localities (still not finished...). Etc. I fear he'll either show us that he's a fool or what his price is.
- jbooth 17y agoAnswers: How much went to temporarily prop up state govt budgets? Zero, even though preventing a teacher layoff would've been about the most efficient use of stimulus dollars possible. The twins from Maine held the bill hostage until no money was given to state government. (If you're wondering how much went to tax cuts, that figure is around 40%). How was texas so successful while refusing this temporary windfall? I don't know, but they definitely didn't refuse anything. Rick Perry made a bunch of noise, got his headlines, convinced you that he's a true believer and then took the money. The weatherization project you got about right, although those studies finished on schedule a month ago or so.. that was a stupid provision and they should have eliminated it, they probably didn't realize it would lead to a bureaucratic snafu. Hopefully, what Mr. Tufte will show us, are some very compelling and illustrative graphs that do a good job of explaining where the money went. There seems to be some confusion abounding, especially on the tax cut part. EDIT: A further hope I have is that people who normally respect things like statistics, figures and Mr Tufte don't immediately do a 180 and disown the guy if he doesn't produce a pie chart of the stimulus money that says "100% = SOCIALISM"
- hga 17y agoWhile the details of the $44.5 billion for local education aid were indeed changed by "the twins from Maine" (although I'm not sure to the degree you claim), you're not counting the $40 billion for unemployment benefits (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestment_Act_of_2009#Aid_to_low_income_workers.2C_unemployed_and_retirees_.28including_job_training.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestm...) and the required changes in state law to get that money, or the $86.6 billion for Medicaid (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestment_Act_of_2009#Healthcare http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestm..., "More than 11% of the total bill is allocated to help states with Medicaid"; I can't remember if there were eligibility changes required there). For you to be right about no state aid and there being no strings attached, you'd need to explain why there was all that furor about the governors of Texas and one of the Carolinas (I think) refusing the aid, and the provision in law to bypass a governor, and how the governor of Florida's figurative and literal embrace of Obama is helping to destroy his campaign for Senator. WRT to tax cuts, putting the annual relief ($70 billion this year) for the not inflation indexed Alternative Minimum Tax into the stimulus was pure political theater. And I just can't see how Perry "took" the Texas share of the remaining $167 billion in individual tax cuts (perhaps he should have instituted a state income tax to capture that "windfall" for the state???) or how he "took" the Texas share of $51 billion in business tax cuts, but I don't know anything about Texas business taxes. Anyway, I don't need to see graphs to get a rough idea from the listed breakdowns at Wikipedia or any of the other zillions of sites.
- uuilly 17y agoI wonder if Obama is going to like the result. I also wonder whether Tufte will visually tell the truth. It's heady stuff getting called in by the president and I could see him not wanting to make Obama look bad. Either way the result will be interesting.
- warfangle 17y agoI would feel as if I were held to an even higher standard than usual if I were called in by the President to do something like this. I can be reasonably assured that no such thing will happen to me, so all I can hope for is that Tufte holds himself to the same ideal.
- uuilly 17y agoI hope so too, and from what I know about Tufte, he will be true to the numbers. I would be less worried if the headline read, "Bi-partisan Commission Appoints Tufte etc..." From what I know about the stimulus, it's not something I'd want to brag about. Did Obama just hire a very talented propagandist, or a guy who deftly presents the bill's inadequacies? I guess we'll find out. Either way, his presentation will certainly be the anchor point of the stimulus debate.
- jbooth 17y ago"... a very talented propagandist, or a guy who deftly presents the bill's inadequacies?..." Why's it have to be either/or? My side/your side? I'd hope, and I bet this is what Obama's hoping too, that the guy will produce some stuff that is very reflective of WHAT'S IN THE DAMN BILL. Obama stands to gain politically from public understanding of the bill because frankly, as long as the graphic doesn't consist of "$$$ -> (hammer&sickle)", it'll be better press than the thing's gotten so far. The truth is worth something.
- uuilly 17y agoYou're right that it's not a binary thing. Those seem like the two most likely outcomes to me.
- 100k 17y agoAs Kenyes would point out, as long as someone got paid to dig that hole it was worth it.