3 ms·
This is more than a year old. I've been told that btrfs has improved greatly in that time.
by ars 10y ago
This is more than a year old. I've been told that btrfs has improved greatly in that time.
- SXX 10y agoI found it just recently when upgraded my VM images storage and BTRFS was still significally slower on HDDs using Ubuntu 16.04. Though I only compared it to EXT4 on LVM with QCOW2 + backing files. Any idea if there was newer performance comparison for VM storage?
- ryao 10y agoZFS has not stood still during that time either.
- tux1968 10y agoBut it had a lot less low-hanging-fruit to pick during that time.
- ryao 10y agoI could argue otherwise, but that is beside the point on enterprise distributions where these tests were done. The latest ZFS code is always avaliable on those while the btrfs code is stagnant there. The btrfs developers delegate responsibility of backporting their changes to distribution developers, who never do any backports. Consequently, the newer btrfs code is not very relevant as far as benchmarks on RHEL and others are concerned.
- MertsA 10y agoThis is more than a year old and the hardware this was tested on wasn't even that exceptional when it was released 7 years ago. I'm kind of assuming that the tester did something strange for BTRFS in particular because his results disagree with every other benchmark out there. Using BTRFS on top of software RAID 10 is also inappropriate as this should be done by creating a filesystem containing all four devices. That being said I'd love to see more benchmarks of BTRFS compared to other filesystems and on hardware that isn't so archaic. I think it's safe to say that this article is not representative of reality as Phoronix has tons of benchmarks that all don't have nearly this big of difference between BTRFS and Ext4. Here's an article that's even more outdated than the parent and it still shows BTRFS performing acceptably across the board. https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=linux_raid_fs4 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=linux_ra...