6 ms·
Overall a good intro and exploration that I'll let others discuss as I don't study this part of history as much. I will counter and clarify one point: "These m
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Overall a good intro and exploration that I'll let others discuss as I don't study this part of history as much. I will counter and clarify one point:
"These machines [analog computers] were not following instructions as they computed, and so the concept of a program... does not apply to them."
Not true: it just shifts to mean something different. Now, if device was fixed in function, as many were, then the author is right that they're essentially dedicated hardware without a program. Yet, there are both configurable and general-purpose analog systems. The configuration of one or partly input into the other constitute the program in these machines. It's not same as digital computers but non-fixed-function, analog computers are still programmed. Examples below of some.
http://comdyna.com/gp6intro.htm http://comdyna.com/gp6intro.htm
Note: Program above is the number and placement of wires you plug into its holes. One could represent that on paper as a program. That can even be automated further.
http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1167814 http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1167814
Note: The configuration of that would be the program.
http://www.artificialbrains.com/brainscales http://www.artificialbrains.com/brainscales
Note: The brain is likely an analog or mixed-signal computer. The program in an analog NN is probably the synapses, weights, and such.
So, general and semi-general computers in analog domain have programs. They just direct behavior of simple, real components operating on real things instead of instructions for abstract machines operating on 1's and 0's.
- hcs 11y agoThe part you left out of the ellipses is pretty important to the meaning: "according to which devices carry out a sequence of different operations over time". The article is about transfer of control, which is why it focuses on looping and branches. edit: Maybe sequencing mechanisms on analog computers could have been examined more closely. It's my understanding that Claude Shannon's master's thesis on Boolean logic in hardware came out of his work with Vannevar Bush's differential analyzer at MIT, so things must have been very complex.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"The article is about transfer of control, which is why it focuses on looping and branches." Perhaps my comment has less application for that reason. Early analog systems either computed functions or were used in control systems. They have looping mechanisms for sure. They can emulate branches as that's just a series of functions with some decision code choosing which to execute. Given these can be configurable, I could still see programs in computers that used analog model with features you describe. " It's my understanding that Claude Shannon's master's thesis on Boolean logic in hardware came out of his work with Vannevar Bush's differential analyzer at MIT" Smart observation. Claude Shannon invented the first model for general-purpose, analog computers modeling the differential analyzer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_purpose_analog_computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_purpose_analog_compute... To get you up to speed, this is a nice, short write-up on the history of analog computers and some of their advantages. You'll also see the difficulties in here vs throwing some Verilog together on Boolean. http://www.ieeeghn.org/wiki/images/1/1a/Bissell-2004.pdf http://www.ieeeghn.org/wiki/images/1/1a/Bissell-2004.pdf They have a lot of untapped potential. It's why I'm looking into them. So, I try to correct any misinformation about them as I discover the truth through my digging. They certainly have drawbacks and issues but also remarkable traits that make them a competitive advantage to this day. Today, they call them "mixed-signal ASIC's" which use analog in places it's best and digital for rest. Still mostly done by hand, though, despite advances in synthesis.