4 ms·
This is how things get approved since states want funding and jobs. That said the SLS has a lift capability twice the size of a Falcon heavy which hasn't been l
by dogma1138 11y ago
This is how things get approved since states want funding and jobs.
That said the SLS has a lift capability twice the size of a Falcon heavy which hasn't been launched yet, so no I'm not sure that it's a waste since if we want to get to Europa quickly it's probably the best rocket we got atm.
SLS is also our best current candidate for serious human space flight past LEO, SLS brings up back to Energia and Saturn V launch capacity and while it is the usual cross state designed by a committee project it's good to have it since we do need it.
- greglindahl 11y agoIt's hard to know what's "best" when you're looking at a development program being run by an agency which has a not-so-good record of designing and building rockets. An alternative would be to use multiple, much-cheaper launches, and rendezvous in orbit. Even though the spacecraft needs to be more complicated, the rocket tech will be much more proven. And on-orbit refuel is an active area of R&D in the commercial sector.
- dogma1138 11y agoThe alternative is something we've never really attempted to do before. The rocket tech is already proven both SLS and ULA launch platforms are more proven and reliable than the Falcon.
- greglindahl 11y agoNever attempted? No, done many times: ISS assembly and resupply. And the commercial satellite rendezvous and refueling market will probably be well on its way by 2020. p.s. I'm confused by your mention of ULA vs Falcon reliability -- given that I didn't mention either! Did you read something into my comment?
- dogma1138 11y agoThe ISS was assembled when we had the shuttle, we never had reassembly and relaunch in orbit. Commercial satellite refueling market won't be viable by 2020, we might have a handful of attempts. And I didn't read anything into your comment since there isn't much beyond ULA (Delta, Atlas) and Falcon to launch the damn thing to begin with. And I'm sorry that I don't want to bet on technology that isn't there yet in any shape and form to start planning for a mission that is supposed to launch in 7-8 years with a limited launch window and a failure that would set you back a decade + and not insurance payout + 18 months like if it was a commercial launch to LEO. And again you are missing the point we need big rockets it's not even a question, and SLS is the only big rocket anyone is currently building, if Space X comes up with a Falcon Heavy Plus capable of competing against the SLS on both payload mass and reliability there would be a room to talk. We need NASA, and the US need cross state national projects because they are industry incubators, yes they are inefficient at times but you get plenty for them. If going to Europa also means that the US is back at building Saturn V class rockets it's a huge plus regardless the costs.
- greglindahl 11y agoOh, so the modules launched by the Russians, and all of the supply vehicles, somehow don't count? I'm afraid that you're coming at this argument with a very different and impossible-to-understand worldview.
- jacoblambda 11y agoDepending on the design, the craft could be assembled at off one of the docks for the ISS. Assembly would be little different than the actual construction of the ISS and could be launched with cheaper and less bureaucratically constricted launch systems.
- dogma1138 11y agoAgain no one currently does this atm, and there are no "cheaper and less bureaucratically constricted launch systems" atm to launch these things. SpaceX isn't ready for these kinds of launches it's not proven enough. ULA is just a " bureaucratically constricted" as the SLS. I don't understand why people are proposing to play around with projects that are already insanely risky and hard to approve, we get to send a probe to Europa, which on it's own is complicated enough and now you want to build a whole orbital launch platform around it? Let the industry do it, blow up some stuff in orbit till they make it work, blow up some more stuff in transit till they get things sorted and then lets use it to launch billion dollar probes to Jupiter.
- Eridrus 11y agoIsn't trying something we've never done before the whole point of research funding? I am much more interested in advances in space technology than whatever we'll find on Europa.
- Eridrus 11y agoThere isn't exactly a rush to go to Europa, why not wait until cheaper rocketry is developed?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI guess because its projects like the Europa mission that make rocketry cheaper.
- Eridrus 10y agoI don't see how we're going to make launching cheaper by doing 2 launches on a well understood but expensive platform.
- ohyes 11y agoEuropa doesn't have any clear commercial applications. Taking the "let's just wait for someone else to do it" approach seems like a recipe for it never happening.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]