2 ms·
This kind of thing is hardly unknown, particularly when discussing out-of-date weaponry. A more recent example is cap-and-ball revolvers; the early designs from
by mcguire 11y ago
This kind of thing is hardly unknown, particularly when discussing out-of-date weaponry. A more recent example is cap-and-ball revolvers; the early designs from Colt lacked a top-strap on the frame, making the frame weaker. (Seriously; it at least some models, the only thing attaching the barrel and the front of the frame to the grip, back, and bottom of the frame is the wedge through the cylinder pin.)
The claimed advantage of this design is that it makes removing and replacing the cylinder easier and a user could reload by removing the spent cylinder and replacing it with a previously-loaded cylinder.
There are plenty of reasons why this seems unlikely in reality. It's faster than reloading a cylinder, but it's still not all that fast. On some models, at least, removing the cylinder requires hammering out the wedge from the frame and cylinder pin---something you don't want loose while firing. Dropping any of the parts would be a bad idea. But the major unfortunate problem with the theory is that there is no record of Colt manufacturing large numbers of spare cylinders. Nor, during the American Civil War, are there any records of the United States government ordering any large numbers of spare cylinders.
This isn't to claim that no one ever did it. That would be ridiculous; someone would certainly have thought about the idea anyway. But there's no evidence that anyone was ever trained to do it, or that large numbers of anyones ever had the materials necessary.
- sandworm101 11y agoPerhaps the faster-loading of extra cylinders was just marketing, something the salesman would say. You buy the gun thinking that one day you might improve on the purchase by getting second cylinder, but it never happens once you realize the issues. I'm thinking of those BMWs that were once "wired for a CD changer" mounted in the trunk, but nobody who bought a car without the changer ever installed one later.