4 ms·
I like smart replies. They are not quite the exact words I would normally use, but they're close, so I kind of enjoy selecting them as a sort of novelty. In t
by jrockway 11y ago
I like smart replies. They are not quite the exact words I would normally use, but they're close, so I kind of enjoy selecting them as a sort of novelty. In that sense, it's kind of like spellcheck (which tells me I just misspelled spellcheck). If I was replying to those texts, it would have gone something like that:
> What are you up to?
>> Work.
or
> Want to hang out?
>> Sure.
The suggestions Google provides are a little bit more upbeat and amusing to me.
> What are you up to?
>> I am working!
or
> Want to hang out?
>> I'd love to.
I especially like how it inverts how I'd normally use exclamation marks and periods. "I'm working." "I'd love to!" etc.
Anyway, neat feature. The author doesn't like it, I do, so she can not use the feature and I can use it :P
- mrmondo 11y agoSo you'd rather Google uses the world 'love' than you?
- jrockway 11y agoI'm not really bothered by the distinction. When you repeat someone's words, you're taking on the responsibility of having used them, so to me, the meaning is the same whether you press letter-shaped screen widgets or press word-shaped screen widgets. I don't think anyone is going to think "I'm not really sure if I love my partner, but Google says I do, so I guess I do." I also don't think people are using mobile apps to have the deep types of conversations where this would matter. Like I said, I see it as a more interesting spellcheck. I usually say things like "yup", Google offers more amusing suggestions that I enjoy.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mcbits 11y agoI know for a fact that you can't spell spellcheck. You didn't even type that yourself, did you? Do you still love me? Tell me you still love me. (Looking forward to the day that that sort of reply can be generated. I'm sure it would be far more fun than "wanna hang?" "ya")
- ACow_Adonis 11y agoPerhaps its the smartarse Australian larrikin in me, but these kinds of automated responses depress me, because I can see them working like corporate new-speak: they're going to push us to limit our communication down to a bunch of canned responses, emotions and interactions. Sometimes I think AI isn't advancing at all, its just that we're all working more and more to fall in line like good automatons... I love sarcasm, dead-pan, violently black-humour...and I'm watching it all slowly disappear and we all become pidgeonholed, public, on-show, quantised and sanitised. I'd much rather bring back: >What are you up to? >> In middle of school shooting. Cops on way. Call you back in 5? >Want to hang out? >> I'm in the bathroom, so in a way, I already am... > sends through that picture of child holding flower >> Sometimes that shark, he looks right into you. Right into your eyes. You know the thing about a shark, he's got... lifeless eyes, black eyes, like a doll's eye. When he comes at ya, doesn't seem to be livin'. Until he bites ya and those black eyes roll over white. And then, ah... Oh, but the two are unrelated you say... Well no. I'm not certain that they are...
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> >What are you up to? >> In middle of school shooting. Cops on way. Call you back in 5? These days, that sounds like something that would make SWAT invite themselves into your house, through a window. The responses are sure cute and creative. I seriously doubt whoever writes like this today will change their ways because of "smart replies". Most people don't write stuff like that, definitely not during most of the conversations. I don't really have a formed view yet. I think getting outraged over someone using augmented software to respond faster is wrong, and only a problem with the person who gets outraged. On the other hand I do appreciate the effect of limiting the potential conversation space if people get too dependent those reply suggestions. It is also true though that a lot of conversations one has over e-mail or IMs follow so common patterns that there were many times I wished I could just automate it away, to have a bot reply to them without the other side knowing. Maybe I'm just antisocial? But I tend to differentiate between requests for information from requests for personal attention, and wouldn't mind having my bot handle all of the former. (Then again, I wouldn't accept anything except a bot I wrote myself, so maybe I'm not that antisocial - since I'd be just spawning a part of myself as an external process. That's also one reason why I'm so pissed about all the modern bot / AI tech from Google, et al., which has zero configurability, zero ways to plug your own stuff in yourself.)
- Gys 11y agoYour examples are exactly the reason why I do not like Smart Replies: it says a lot about a person what he/she is writing. The choice in words (or lack of) is very important. Typing already misses a lot of non-verbal information. That's how we got smiley icons. Smart Replies makes the replies even less informing. Conversions will become more predictable and shallow then they already are.
- shubhamjain 11y agoI haven't used the app, so I am curious. Does the feature also suggest responses for different sentiments? Like, > Want to Hang out? >> I'd love to! >> Nah, I am busy. In that case, I don't think anyone should have a problem.