2 ms·
Oh, and even the stuff that was true was completely misinterpreted. For example, he cited a study of students as showing there was no "math talent", only dilig
by mpweiher 11y ago
Oh, and even the stuff that was true was completely misinterpreted. For example, he cited a study of students as showing there was no "math talent", only diligence. The setup actually was quite interesting: there was an additional informational questionnaire that wasn't about skills at all, and there was a correlation with conscientiously filling out that questionnaire and scoring high on the actual skills test.
However.
The effect only appeared in 2 grade levels and only in some years, so extremely weak evidence. But that's only a small detail. The big one was that the effect was only evident at the national level. So yes, there are no nations that are more talented at math than others. In other news, water still wet. However, the data, even if the flimsy bits are taken at face value, simply do not show at all that there is no math talent at the level of individuals, and in fact showed the exact opposite.
Details.