4 ms·
Quantum Nonlocality, and the End of Classical Spacetime [pdf]
- kordless 11y agoBuild a virtual reality world on blockchain technologies from the ground up. Make it procedural, in spots, so the storage costs of pretty things aren't crazy high. Take changes enabled by the observer's causality and write them out as updates where there is consensus available. At the end of "time", you have a stored reality you can replay and enjoy, or even create sidechains of favorite events and share them with others.
- tetrep 11y agoThat is more or less how video game replays work, as well as netcode in multiplayer games. They store the series of events that lead to a given state; you don't need to waste resources on a block-chain. There's no technological reason as to why you couldn't arbitrarily interrupt a replay and take control from that point forward, effectively forking the replay, but I don't know if any games allow you to do that. Multiplayer servers essentially keeps forks of reality for short durations to do lag compensation as it reconciles the actions that clients send it to create one timeline that is pushed to all clients.
- SimonPStevens 11y agoMany modern racing games (Forza for example) have a rewind feature which is essentially a replay of the last 30 or so seconds where you can take over at some point and continue driving as if you hadn't just slammed into the tyre wall.
- kordless 11y ago> multiplayer servers essentially keeps forks of reality for short durations to do lag compensation And now you know why I put this comment in a post about causality. Resources spent on storing information in the blockchain would be exceeding useful in a multiplayer environment. Keeps things trustworthy.
- grahvity 11y agohttps://np.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/4kdc6d/can_anyone_figure_out_what_the_fuck_hes_talking/ https://np.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/4kdc6d/can_anyone_...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mh-cx 11y agoIs it possible to translate this to layman terms?
- nabla9 11y agoThis is my understanding of how the problem is framed: Causality is local even in quantum physics. The "Spooky action at a distance" is just correlation This leaves the "acausal action at a distance" aka nonlocal correlation. There is no controversy here. There is no superluminal messaging and there are no need for hidden variables and things like that. Entangled quantum _state_ of two distant entangled electrons has no coordinates in space. Quantum states are treated as ghosts. For the authors there exist discord between instant correlation and special relativity. I have no idea what comes next. Somebody else should explain how Trace Dynamics works.
- philip142au 11y agoHow can things be correlated? what is correlation if there is no causation, I feel confused about that ... as your The "Spooky action at a distance" is just correlation.
- iheartmemcache 11y agoNon-newtonian physics is by far the weakest of the hard sciences but as I understand it "[spooky] action at a distance" has a formal meaning[1] in particle physics that has to do with quantum entanglement. Here's the NIST article on the substantial findings that lends credence spooky action specifically[2]. (I'd imagine the physics stackexchange will have a great discussion on this, and the AskScience on Reddit will have a thread approachable for people who aren't Leonard Susskind or his coterie of brilliant post-docs.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_at_a_distance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_at_a_distance [2] http://www.nist.gov/pml/div686/20151105loophole.cfm http://www.nist.gov/pml/div686/20151105loophole.cfm
- wyager 11y ago> Non-newtonian physics is by far the weakest of the hard sciences This assertion is ridiculous. The only fields "harder" (in the scientific sense) than modern physics are pure math fields. High-level physics is almost pure math anyway; much of it is abstract algebra and topology. That's not to say it's divorced from reality; reality seems to like using these principles under the hood. The "soft" stuff you are talking about isn't modern physics; it's people taking (mostly uninformed) potshot guesses at how to interpret the hard results that modern physics offers. Within the physics community, these discussions are much more muted, because it's clear that the answers to physics questions won't come out of philosophical pontificating. Physicists figure out which interpretations are compatible with experimentally verified theory, and then look for additional consequences of these interpretations that can be tested. Right now there are a number of plausible explanations of the observations of quantum mechanics, each with their own (often psychologically uncomfortable) way of dealing with its conclusions. It's rare to come across a physicist that is strongly convinced of one interpretation.
- tacos 11y agoReal paper -> Pop reporting of real paper -> Derivative crap on arxiv.org in essay form -> HN homepage. We've got it down to about two weeks now. It's a game of telephone with massive information loss at each step.
- evanb 11y agoThe Gravity Research Foundation's essay contest is one of the most well-known and prestigious essay contests in physics, in which authors are encouraged to synthesize and simplify their technical work into a short, approachable-for-physicists-but-nonexperts work with few equations. A quick perusing of the previous winners http://www.gravityresearchfoundation.org/winners_year.html http://www.gravityresearchfoundation.org/winners_year.html shows 't Hooft, Krauss, Smoot, Steinhardt, Wald, Bekenstein, Brout, Englert, Penrose, Hawking, DeWitt. It's taken very seriously. So the chain was really (a bunch of real papers) --> (those authors summarizing what they did, and putting it on the arXiv) --> HN. Calling it derivative crap is totally wrong, and suggesting that the arXiv somehow makes the papers less "real" is wrong too. Full disclosure: I wrote http://arxiv.org/abs/1603.03055 http://arxiv.org/abs/1603.03055 for the contest [honarable mention].
- timnic 11y agoCan you provide a link to the real paper that started the discussion? I looked through the references in the linked arxiv paper but could not find it.