5 ms·
I don't think this is on the right track. Obviously, learning is a matter of personal preference and experience, but trying to teach someone about groups by exp
by nerdponx 11y ago
I don't think this is on the right track. Obviously, learning is a matter of personal preference and experience, but trying to teach someone about groups by explaining the definition of a group defeats the whole purpose of even studying groups in the first place. The power of Group theory, and of mathematical abstraction in general, is that it allows us to generalize and extend existing concepts. I agree, that it would be ridiculous to rename all "groups" to "clocks", just as it would be ridiculous to rename all rectangles to squares. But for a student who has never seen a rectangle that is not a square before, it would be unfair and counterproductive for you to ask that student to put aside the example of a square when studying rectangles. For teaching purposes, it is rarely wrong to draw analogies between the generalized object and its everyday analogue.